Systematic Review of Dairy Processing Sludge and Secondary STRUBIAS Products Used in Agriculture

Worldwide dairy processing plants produce high volumes of dairy processing sludge (DPS), which can be converted into secondary derivatives such as struvite, biochar and ash (collectively termed STRUBIAS). All of these products have high fertilizer equivalent values (FEV), but future certification as phosphorus (P)-fertilizers in the European Union will mean they need to adhere to new technical regulations for fertilizing materials i.e., content limits pertaining to heavy metals (Cd, Cu, Hg, Ni, Pb, and Zn), synthetic organic compounds and pathogens. This systematic review presents the current state of knowledge about these bio-based fertilizers and identifies knowledge gaps. In addition, a review and calculation of greenhouse gas emissions from a range of concept dairy sludge management and production systems for STRUBIAS products [i.e., biochar from pyrolysis and hydrochar from hydrothermal carbonization (HTC)] is presented. Results from the initial review showed that DPS composition depends on product type and treatment processes at a given processing plant, which leads to varied nutrient, heavy metal and carbon contents. These products are all typically high in nutrients and carbon, but low in heavy metals. Further work needs to concentrate on examining their pathogenic microorganism and emerging contaminant contents, in addition to conducting an economic assessment of production and end-user costs related to chemical fertilizer equivalents. With respect to STRUBIAS products, contaminants not present in the raw DPS may need further treatment before being land applied in agriculture e.g., heated producing ashes, hydrochar, or biochar. An examination of these products from an environmental perspective shows that their water quality footprint could be minimized using application rates based on P incorporation of these products into nutrient management planning and application by incorporation into the soil. Results from the concept system showed that elimination of methane emissions was possible, along with a reduction in nitrous oxide. Less carbon (C) is transferred to agricultural fields where DPS is processed into biochar and hydrochar, but due to high recalcitrance, the C in this form is retained much longer in the soil, and therefore STRUBIAS products represent a more stable and long-term option to increase soil C stocks and sequestration.

Differing Phosphorus Crop Availability of Aluminium and Calcium Precipitated Dairy Processing Sludge Potential Recycled Alternatives to Mineral Phosphorus Fertiliser

The European dairy industry generates large volumes of wastewater from milk and dairy food processing. Removal of phosphorus (P) by complexing with metal (e.g., aluminium, calcium) cations in P rich sludge is a potential P source for agricultural reuse and P recycling. However, there is a significant knowledge gap concerning the plant availability of this complexed P in comparison to conventional mineral P fertiliser. The current absence of information on plant P bioavailability of dairy processing sludge (DPS) limits the ability of farmers and nutrient management advisors to incorporate it correctly into fertiliser programmes. The present study examined the most common types of dairy sludge—(1) aluminium-precipitated sludge (“Al-DPS”) and (2) calcium-precipitated lime-stabilised sludge (“Ca-DPS”) at field scale to assess P availability in grassland versus mineral P fertiliser over a growing season. The experimental design was a randomised complete block with five replications. Crop yield and P uptake were assessed for 4 harvests. The initial soil test P was at a low level and the experimental treatments were super phosphate at 15, 30, 40, 50 and 60 kg P ha−1, two dairy sludge applied at 40 kg P ha−1 (comparison was made with mineral P at same application rate) and a zero P control applied in a single application at the beginning of the growing season. Results showed a significant positive slope in the relationship between P uptake response and mineral P application rate indicating the suitability of the experimental site for P availability assessment. The P bioavailability of Al- and Ca-DPS varied greatly between treatments. The P fertiliser replacement value based on the 1st harvest was 50 and 16% increased to 109 and 31% cumulatively over the four harvests for Al- and Ca-DPS, respectively. The Al concentration in Al-DPS did not limit P bioavailability, but low P bioavailability from Ca-DPS can be associated with its high Ca content that can lead to formation of low soluble Ca-P compounds at alkaline pH conditions with a high Ca/P ratio. These findings show that P availability from dairy sludge can be quite different depending on treatment process. Consequently, it is critical to have P availability information as well as total P content available to ensure the application rate meets crop requirements without creating environmental risk by over application.