Vehicle technologies and bus fleet replacement optimization: problem properties and sensitivity analysis utilizing real-world data

In real world data (RWD) studies, observed datasets are often subject to left truncation, which can bias estimates of survival parameters. Standard methods can only suitably account for left truncation when survival and entry time are independent. Therefore, in the dependent left truncation setting, it is important to quantify the magnitude and direction of estimator bias to determine whether an analysis provides valid results. We conduct simulation studies of common RWD analytic settings in order to determine when standard analysis provides reliable estimates, and to identify factors that contribute most to estimator bias. We also outline a procedure for conducting a simulation-based sensitivity analysis for an arbitrary dataset subject to dependent left truncation. Our simulation results show that when comparing a truncated real-world arm to a non-truncated arm, we observe the estimated hazard ratio biased upwards, providing conservative inference. The most important data-generating parameter contributing to bias is the proportion of left truncated patients, given any level of dependence between survival and entry time. For specific datasets and analyses that may differ from our example, we recommend applying our sensitivity analysis approach to determine how results would change given varying proportions of truncation.

Download Full-text

Budget Impact Analysis of Diabetes Drugs: A Systematic Literature Review

Frontiers in Public Health ◽

10.3389/fpubh.2021.765999 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 9 ◽

Author(s):

Zejun Luo ◽

Zhen Ruan ◽

Dongning Yao ◽

Carolina Oi Lam Ung ◽

Yunfeng Lai ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Sensitivity Analysis ◽

Model Validation ◽

Practice Guidelines ◽

Real World ◽

Impact Analysis ◽

Budget Impact ◽

Good Practice ◽

Budget Impact Analysis ◽

Real World Data ◽

World Data

Background: Budget impact analysis (BIA) is an economic assessment that estimates the financial consequences of adopting a new intervention. BIA is used to make informed reimbursement decisions, as a supplement to cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs).Objectives: We systematically reviewed BIA studies associated with anti-diabetic drugs and assessed the extent to which international BIA guidelines were followed in these studies.Methods: We conducted a literature search on PubMed, Web of Science, Econlit, Medline, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Data knowledge Service platform from database inception to June 30, 2021. ISPOR good practice guidelines were used as a methodological standard for assessing BIAs. We extracted and compared the study characteristics outlined by the ISPOR BIA Task Force to evaluate the guideline compliance of the included BIA.Results: A total of eighteen studies on the BIA for anti-diabetic drugs were identified. More than half studies were from developed countries. Seventeen studies were based on model and one study was based on real-world data. Overall, analysis considered a payer perspective, reported potential budget impacts over 1–5 years. Assumptions were mainly made about target population size, market share uptake of new interventions, and scope of cost. The data used for analysis varied among studies and was rarely justified. Model validation and sensitivity analysis were lacking in the current BIA studies. Rebate analysis was conducted in a few studies to explore the price discount that was required for new interventions to demonstrate cost equivalence to comparators.Conclusion: Existing studies evaluating budget impact for anti-diabetic drugs vary greatly in methodology, some of which showed low compliance to good practice guidelines. In order for the BIA to be useful for assisting in health plan decision-making, it is important for future studies to optimize compliance to national or ISPOR good practice guidelines on BIA. Model validation and sensitivity analysis should also be improved in future BIA studies. Continued improvement of BIA using real-world data is necessary to ensure high-quality analyses and to provide reliable results.

Download Full-text