Cluster and discriminant analysis classified sediments from potential and existing wild rice lakes into three major and three hybrid types. The three major sediment types were described as clay, organic, or flocculent, and the three hybrid types as organic – flocculent, organic – clay, or organic over clay. The major differences among the six sediment types were the percent loss-on-ignition, bulk density, phosphorus, cation, and pH values. Organic sediments were characterized by high phosphorus, cation, and loss-on-ignition values, and lower pH values. Clay sediments had the highest bulk density values, but were low in phosphorus. Flocculent sediments exhibited the lowest bulk density, phosphorus, and cation values, and the highest loss-on-ignition and pH values. The three hybrid sediment types had values for these variables intermediate to their parent types. Flocculent, clay, and organic–flocculent sediment types produced the lowest dry weights of individual wild rice plants. Best production (in terms of dry weight) occurred in organic, organic–clay, and organic over clay sediments that had loss-on-ignition values ranging from 29 to 49%, were slightly acidic (pH values of 5.9 −6.2), and had high phosphorus (> 1.0 g ∙ m−2) and cation values.