Implementing the SWF Framework
The SWF framework is a fully generic methodology for policy assessment. One important application in the economic literature concerns taxation (termed “optimal tax” scholarship); but the framework is applicable to any type of governmental policy choice. This chapter illustrates the implementation of the SWF framework, using the regulation of fatality risks as a case study. Risk regulation is chosen because this is the major application of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) in the U.S. government. The chapter focuses on the utilitarian and continuous-prioritarian SWFs. Utilitarianism gives priority to the young in reducing fatality risks and to those with higher income. Continuous prioritarianism intensifies the preference for the young, but mitigates or reverse the preference for those with higher income. CBA is significantly different from both utilitarianism and continuous prioritarianism. It markedly intensifies the utilitarian preference for reducing the risks of those with higher incomes; and, unlike both SWF-based approaches, is insensitive to the distribution of policy cost.