Fruiting phenology and the survival of insect fruit predators: a case study from the South-east Asian Dipterocarpaceae
Nanophyes shoreae is a pre-dispersal weevil fruit-predator of some species in the Dipterocarpaceae. The dipterocarps typically mass flower at supra-annual intervals, with sporadic flowering events involving a few trees of a reduced number of species in the intervening periods. The hypothesis is tested that N. shoreae populations are maintained between mass-fruiting events by recruitment during sporadic fruiting. A record of flowering among 143 dipterocarps of 27 species is reported in Pasoh Forest Reserve, West Malaysia from May 1985 to July 1987. A quantitative analysis of N. shoreae pre-imaginal survival is described in one of the five sporadic flowering events that occurred. The primary mortality factors were abscission of fruit containing eggs and consumption by vertebrates of fruit containing pupae and third instar larvae. Overall the percentage of N. shoreae eggs that developed to produce adult weevils varied from 0 to 1.8%. This survival is low compared with that of other fruit predators. Thus, sporadic fruiting does not greatly boost N. shoreae populations between mass-flowering events and the key to the survival of this weevil lies elsewhere. The implications of this low recruitment for the evolution of mass flowering are discussed.