A Robust and Versatile Framework to Compare Spike Detection Methods in Calcium Imaging of Neuronal Activity

Author(s):  
Samuel Kubler ◽  
Suvadip Mukherjee ◽  
Jean-Christophe Olivo-Marin ◽  
Thibault Lagache
2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alex A. Legaria ◽  
Julia A. Licholai ◽  
Alexxai V. Kravitz

AbstractFiber photometry recordings are commonly used as a proxy for neuronal activity, based on the assumption that increases in bulk calcium fluorescence reflect increases in spiking of the underlying neural population. However, this assumption has not been adequately tested. Here, using endoscopic calcium imaging in the striatum we report that the bulk fluorescence signal correlates weakly with somatic calcium signals, suggesting that this signal does not reflect spiking activity, but may instead reflect subthreshold changes in neuropil calcium. Consistent with this suggestion, the bulk fluorescence photometry signal correlated strongly with neuropil calcium signals extracted from these same endoscopic recordings. We further confirmed that photometry did not reflect striatal spiking activity with simultaneous in vivo extracellular electrophysiology and fiber photometry recordings in awake behaving mice. We conclude that the fiber photometry signal should not be considered a proxy for spiking activity in neural populations in the striatum.Significance statementFiber photometry is a technique for recording brain activity that has gained popularity in recent years due to it being an efficient and robust way to record the activity of genetically defined populations of neurons. However, it remains unclear what cellular events are reflected in the photometry signal. While it is often assumed that the photometry signal reflects changes in spiking of the underlying cell population, this has not been adequately tested. Here, we processed calcium imaging recordings to extract both somatic and non-somatic components of the imaging field, as well as a photometry signal from the whole field. Surprisingly, we found that the photometry signal correlated much more strongly with the non-somatic than the somatic signals. This suggests that the photometry signal most strongly reflects subthreshold changes in calcium, and not spiking. We confirmed this point with simultaneous fiber photometry and extracellular spiking recordings, again finding that photometry signals relate poorly to spiking in the striatum. Our results may change interpretations of studies that use fiber photometry as an index of spiking output of neural populations.


Author(s):  
Stephanie Reynolds ◽  
Jon Oñativia ◽  
Simon R. Schultz ◽  
Pier Luigi Dragotti

Author(s):  
Kenneth Ndyabawe ◽  
Mark Haidekker ◽  
Amish Asthana ◽  
William S. Kisaalita

We present a spheroid trapping device, compatible with traditional tissue culture plates, to confine microtissues in a small area and allow suspension cultures to be treated like adherent cultures with minimal loss of spheroids due to aspiration. We also illustrate an automated morphology-independent procedure for cell recognition, segmentation, and a calcium spike detection technique for high-throughput analysis in 3D cultured tissue. Our cell recognition technique uses a maximum intensity projection of spatial-temporal data to create a binary mask, which delineates individual cell boundaries and extracts mean fluorescent data for each cell through a series of intensity thresholding and cluster labeling operations. The temporal data are subject to sorting for imaging artifacts, baseline correction, smoothing, and spike detection algorithms. We validated this procedure through analysis of calcium data from 2D and 3D SHSY-5Y cell cultures. Using this approach, we rapidly created regions of interest (ROIs) and extracted fluorescent intensity data from hundreds of cells in the field of view with superior data fidelity over hand-drawn ROIs even in dense (3D tissue) cell populations. We sorted data from cells with imaging artifacts (such as photo bleaching and dye saturation), classified nonfiring and firing cells, estimated the number of spikes in each cell, and documented the results, facilitating large-scale calcium imaging analysis in both 2D and 3D cultures. Since our recognition and segmentation technique is independent of morphology, our protocol provides a versatile platform for the analysis of large confocal calcium imaging data from neuronal cells, glial cells, and other cell types.


2013 ◽  
Vol 104 (2) ◽  
pp. 338a
Author(s):  
Stephan Direnberger ◽  
Roberto Banchi ◽  
Christian Seebacher ◽  
Felix Felmy ◽  
Hans Straka ◽  
...  

2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Abdelhadi El Yazidi ◽  
Michel Ramonet ◽  
Philippe Ciais ◽  
Gregoire Broquet ◽  
Isabelle Pison ◽  
...  

Abstract. This study deals with the problem of identifying atmospheric data that are influenced by local emissions which cause spikes in time series of greenhouse gases and long-lived tracer measurements. We considered three spike detection methods known as coefficient of variation (COV), robust extraction of baseline signal (REBS), and standard deviation of the background (SD), to detect and filter positive spikes in continuous greenhouse gas time series from four monitoring stations representative of the ICOS (Integrated Carbon Observation System) European Infrastructure network. The results of the different methods are compared to each other and against a manual detection performed by station managers. Four stations were selected as test cases to apply the spike detection methods: a continental rural tower of 100 m height in Eastern France (OPE); a high mountain observatory in the south-west of France (PDM); a regional marine background site in Crete (FKL); and a marine clean-air background site in the southern hemisphere in Amsterdam island (AMS). This panel allows addressing the spike detection problems in time series with different variability. Two years of continuous measurements of CO2, CH4 and CO were analyzed. All the methods were found to be able to detect short-term spikes (lasting from a few seconds to few minutes) in the time series. Analysis of the results of each method leads us to exclude the use of the COV method because of its requirement to arbitrarily specify an a priori percentage of rejected data in the time series, which may over- or under-estimate the actual number of spikes. The two other methods freely determine the number of spikes for a given set of parameters, and the values of these parameters were calibrated to provide the best match with spikes known to reflect local emissions episodes well documented by the station managers. More than 96 % of the spikes manually identified by station managers were successfully detected both in the SD and the REBS methods after the best adjustment of parameter values. At PDM, measurements made by two analyzers 200 m from each other allow to confirm that the CH4 spikes identified in one of the time-series but not in the other correspond to a local source from a sewage treatment facility in one of the observatory buildings. From this experiment, we found that the REBS method underestimates the number of positive anomalies in the CH4 data caused by local sewage emissions. As a conclusion, we recommend the use of the SD method, which also appears as the easiest one to implement as automatic data processing, for the operational filtering of spikes in greenhouses gases time series at global and regional monitoring stations of networks like ICOS.


2013 ◽  
Vol 14 (S1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Olav Stetter ◽  
Javier Orlandi ◽  
Jordi Soriano ◽  
Demian Battaglia ◽  
Theo Geisel

2018 ◽  
Vol 86 (1) ◽  
pp. e56 ◽  
Author(s):  
Lifeng Zhang ◽  
Bo Liang ◽  
Giovanni Barbera ◽  
Sarah Hawes ◽  
Yan Zhang ◽  
...  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document