The adoption of unrelated young by brood-guarding convict cichlid (Cichlasoma nigrofasciatum) parents is influenced by several factors. Three of these are the risk of intrabrood aggression, the risk of differential predation of their own young, and the trade-off between the benefits of brood dilution and the costs of differential predation. This study introduces the "adoptable fry size hypothesis" model, which synthesizes the findings of earlier studies on each of these factors and details the range of adoptable fry sizes that increase foster brood survival across fry development. The influence of predation risk on the behaviour of parents toward foreign fry of different sizes was examined. Brood-guarding adults approached and mouthed at foreign fry larger than the upper limit of the model least often, but bit at them most often, thus excluding them. As host fry size increased, the number of behaviours directed at foreign fry decreased. Predator number did not significantly influence the size of foreign fry toward which the adults directed their behaviour. However, the overall frequency of these behaviours increased with increasing predator number, confirming previous studies suggesting that alloparental care is motivated by high predation risk.
