In socially structured animal populations, vital rates such as survival and reproduction, are affected by complex interactions among individuals of different social ranks and among social groups. Due to this complexity, mechanistic approaches to model vital rates may be preferred over commonly used structured population models. However, mechanistic approaches come at a cost of increased modelling complexity, computational requirements, and reliance on simulated metrics, while structured population models are analytically tractable. This chapter compares different approaches to modelling population dynamics of socially structured populations. It first simulates individual-based data based on the life cycle of a hypothetical cooperative breeder and then projects population dynamics using a matrix population model (MPM), an integral projection model (IPM), and an individual-based model (IBM). The authors demonstrate that, when projecting population size or structure, the relatively simpler MPM can outperform both the IPM and IBM. However, mechanistic details parametrised in the more complex IBM are required to accurately project interactions within social groups. The R scripts in this chapter provide a roadmap to both simulate data that best describe a socially structured system and assess the level of model complexity needed to capture the dynamics of the system.
Re-evaluating the effect of harvesting regimes on Nile crocodiles using an integral projection model
