INTEGRATION OF MACHINE LEARNING AND COMPUTATIONAL FLUID DYNAMICS TO DEVELOP TURBULENCE MODELS FOR IMPROVED LOW-PRESSURE TURBINE WAKE MIXING PREDICTION

2021 ◽  
pp. 1-12
Author(s):  
Harshal D Akolekar ◽  
Yaomin Zhao ◽  
Richard Sandberg ◽  
Roberto Pacciani

Abstract This paper presents the development of accurate turbulence closures for low-pressure turbine (LPT) wake mixing prediction by integrating a machine-learning approach based on gene expression programming (GEP), with Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) based computational fluid dynamics (CFD). In order to further improve the performance and robustness of GEP-based data-driven closures, the fitness of models is evaluated by running RANS calculations in an integrated way, instead of an algebraic function. Using a canonical turbine wake with inlet conditions prescribed based on high-fidelity data of the T106A cascade, we demonstrate that the ‘CFD-driven’ machine-learning approach produces physically correct non-linear turbulence closures, i.e., predict the right down-stream wake development and maintain an accurate peak wake loss throughout the domain. We then extend our analysis to full turbine blade cases and show that the model development is sensitive to the training region due to the presence of deterministic unsteadiness in the near-wake. Models developed including the near-wake have artificially large diffusion coefficients to over-compensate for the vortex shedding steady RANS cannot capture. In contrast, excluding the near-wake in the model development produces the correct physical model behavior, but predictive accuracy in the near-wake remains unsatisfactory. This can be remedied by using the physically consistent models in unsteady RANS. Overall, the ‘CFD-driven’ models were found to be robust and capture the correct physical wake mixing behavior across different LPT operating conditions and airfoils such as T106C and PakB.

Author(s):  
Harshal D. Akolekar ◽  
Yaomin Zhao ◽  
Richard D. Sandberg ◽  
Roberto Pacciani

Abstract This paper presents development of accurate turbulence closures for wake mixing prediction by integrating a machine-learning approach with Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS)-based computational fluid dynamics (CFD). The data-driven modeling framework is based on the gene expression programming (GEP) approach previously shown to generate non-linear RANS models with good accuracy. To further improve the performance and robustness of the data-driven closures, here we exploit that GEP produces tangible models to integrate RANS in the closure development process. Specifically, rather than using as cost function a comparison of the GEP-based closure terms with a frozen high-fidelity dataset, each GEP model is instead automatically implemented into a RANS solver and the subsequent calculation results compared with reference data. By first using a canonical turbine wake with inlet conditions prescribed based on high-fidelity data, we demonstrate that the CFD-driven machine-learning approach produces non-linear turbulence closures that are physically correct, i.e. predict the right downstream wake development and maintain an accurate peak wake loss throughout the domain. We then extend our analysis to full turbine-blade cases and show that the model development is sensitive to the training region due to the presence of deterministic unsteadiness in the near wake region. Models developed including this region have artificially large diffusion coefficients to over-compensate for the vortex shedding steady RANS cannot capture. In contrast, excluding the near wake region in the model development produces the correct physical model behavior, but predictive accuracy in the near-wake remains unsatisfactory. We show that this can be remedied by using the physically consistent models in unsteady RANS, implying that the non-linear closure producing the best predictive accuracy depends on whether it will be deployed in RANS or unsteady RANS calculations. Overall, the models developed with the CFD-assisted machine learning approach were found to be robust and capture the correct physical behavior across different operating conditions.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Camilo Fernando Rodríguez-Genó ◽  
Léster Alfonso

Abstract. A parameterization for the collision-coalescence process is presented, based on the methodology of basis functions. The whole drop spectra is depicted as a linear combination of two lognormal distribution functions, in which all distribution parameters are formulated by means of six distribution moments included in a system of equations, thus eliminating the need of fixing any parameters. This basis functions parameterization avoids the classification of drops in artificial categories such as cloud water (cloud droplets) or rain water (raindrops). The total moment tendencies are calculated using a machine learning approach, in which one deep neural network was trained for each of the total moment orders involved. The neural networks were trained using randomly generated data following a uniform distribution, over a wide range of parameters employed by the parameterization. An analysis of the predicted total moment errors was performed, aimed to stablish the accuracy of the parameterization at reproducing the integrated distribution moments representative of physical variables. The applied machine learning approach shows a good accuracy level when compared to the output of an explicit collision-coalescence model.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document