3D Laser Transit Measurements of the Tip Clearance Vortex in a Compressor Rotor Blade Row

Author(s):  
Andrew C. Foley ◽  
Paul C. Ivey

This paper describes the structure of the tip clearance flow in a low speed isolated compressor rotor. Pneumatic cobra probes are radially traversed upstream and downstream of the blade row and the time averaged total pressure losses across the blade row calculated. The increase in pressure losses due to the tip clearance flow is clearly seen. The nature of the tip losses is investigated further using a unique 3D laser transit anemometer to measure velocities and turbulence levels. A 3D representation of the resulting flow field is then constructed using the experimentally measured velocity vectors. With the aid of ‘stream particles’ released into this flow field a vortex structure is then visualised. A section through the path of this vortex assists in showing its development through the blade row. Due to the co-location of this vortex and the total pressure losses in the passage, it is this vortex which is believed to be responsible for the excess total pressure losses in the tip region.

Author(s):  
Chunill Hah ◽  
Melanie Voges ◽  
Martin Mueller ◽  
Heinz-Peter Schiffer

In the present study, unsteady flow phenomena due to tip clearance flow instability in a modern transonic axial compressor rotor are studied in detail. First, unsteady flow characteristics due the oscillating tip clearance vortex measured with the particle image velocimetry (PIV) and casing-mounted unsteady pressure transducers are analyzed and compared to numerical results with a large eddy simulation (LES). Then, measured characteristic frequencies of the unsteady flow near stall operation are investigated. The overall purpose of the study is to advance the current understanding of the unsteady flow field near the blade tip in an axial transonic compressor rotor near the stall operating condition. Flow interaction between the tip leakage vortex and the passage shock is inherently unsteady in a transonic compressor. The currently applied PIV measurements indicate that the flow near the tip region is unsteady even at the design condition. This self-induced unsteadiness increases significantly as the compressor operates toward the stall condition. PIV data show that the tip clearance vortex oscillates substantially near stall. The calculated unsteady characteristics from LES agree well with the PIV measurements. Calculated unsteady flow fields show that the formation of the tip clearance vortex is intermittent and the concept of vortex breakdown from steady flow analysis does not seem to apply in the current flow field. Fluid with low momentum near the pressure side of the blade close to the leading edge periodically spills over into the adjacent blade passage. The spectral analysis of measured end wall and blade surface pressure shows that there are two dominant frequencies near stall. One frequency is about 40–60% of the rotor rotation and the other dominant frequency is about 40–60% of the blade passing frequency (BPF). The first frequency represents the movement of a large blockage over several consecutive blade passages against the rotor rotation. The second frequency represents traditional tip flow instability, which has been widely observed in subsonic compressors. The LES simulations show that the second frequency is due to movement of the instability vortex.


Author(s):  
Toshiyuki Arima ◽  
Masatoshi Shirotori ◽  
Yoshihiro Yamaguchi

A three-dimensional, Reynolds-averaged, compressible Navier-Stokes analysis (using a multi-block grid with the grid embedded in the tip-clearance space) has been developed to study the tip-clearance flow of an axial compressor rotor. A low-Reynolds number k-ε model have been used to reproduce the effects of turbulence. In order to assess the effect of the tip-clearance-grid treatment on prediction for the tip-clearance flow, calculations using a single-block grid (pinched grid topology) and multi-block grid (embedded grid topology) have been performed to calculate the flow field of NASA Rotor 37. The results are compared with experimental data. It has been found that both the single-block and multi-block approaches give a good agreement with the experimental data regarding the overall performance map of the rotor. For the prediction of the spanwise distributions of averaged aerodynamic properties downstream of the rotor, however, the orderly grid over the blade tip associated with the embedded grid has produced accurate predictions particularly from 40% to 80% span. In order to investigate the tip-clearance flow for different operating conditions, calculations have been performed for conditions at 100% (transonic inflow condition) and 60% (subsonic inflow condition) of the design point speed. Computed limiting streamlines at the blade tip surface and particle traces released from the tip-clearance have been used to study the tip-clearance flow. At the 100% speed, both separation and reattachment lines have been observed and a separation bubble occurs. At the 60% speed, the separation line shifts to the blade pressure side and the reattachment line can be partly observed near the leading edge of the blade tip surface. In order to investigate the interaction of the leakage vortex from the tip clearance with the main flow, the computed secondary flows on the cross-flow sections have been analyzed at the 100% and the 60% speeds. At the 100% speed, the vortex core apparently increases in size, as it moves downstream. At 60% speed, the second vortex, first reported by Suder and Celestina in 1994, is barely observable. Furthermore, the trajectory of vortex core identified using a semi-analytical method has also been used to study the vortex motion in the flow field near the blade tip.


Author(s):  
Mark P. Wernet ◽  
Dale Van Zante ◽  
Tony J. Strazisar ◽  
W. Trevor John ◽  
P. Susan Prahst

The accurate characterization and simulation of rotor tip clearance flows has received much attention in recent years due to their impact on compressor-performance and stability. At NASA Glenn the first known three dimensional Digital Particle Image Velocimetry (DPIV) measurements of the tip region of a low speed compressor rotor have been acquired to characterize the behavior of the rotor tip clearance flow. The measurements were acquired phase-locked to the rotor position so that changes in the tip clearance vortex position relative to the rotor blade can be seen. The DPIV technique allows the magnitude and relative contributions of both the asynchronous motions of a coherent structure and the temporal unsteadiness to be evaluated. Comparison of measurements taken at the peak efficiency and at near stall operating conditions characterizes the mean position of the clearance vortex and the changes in the unsteady behavior of the vortex with blade loading. Comparisons of the 3-D DPIV measurements at the compressor design point to a 3D steady N-S solution are also done to assess the fidelity of steady, single-passage simulations to model an unsteady flow field.


Author(s):  
Chunill Hah ◽  
Douglas C. Rabe ◽  
Aspi R. Wadia

The current paper reports on investigations aimed at advancing the understanding of the flow field near the casing of a forward-swept transonic compressor rotor. The role of tip clearance flow and its interaction with the passage shock on stall inception are analyzed in detail. Steady and unsteady three-dimensional viscous flow calculations are applied to obtain flow fields at various operating conditions. The numerical results are first compared with available measured data. Then, the numerically obtained flow fields are interrogated to identify the roles of flow interactions between the tip clearance flow, the passage shock, and the blade/endwall boundary layers. In addition to the flow field with nominal tip clearance, two more flow fields are analyzed in order to identify the mechanisms of blockage generation: one with zero tip clearance, and one with nominal tip clearance on the forward portion of the blade and zero clearance on the aft portion. The current study shows that the tip clearance vortex does not break down, even when the rotor operates in a stalled condition. Interaction between the shock and the suction surface boundary layer causes the shock, and therefore the tip clearance vortex, to oscillate. However, for the currently investigated transonic compressor rotor, so-called breakdown of the tip clearance vortex does not occur during stall inception. The tip clearance vortex originates near the leading edge tip, but moves downward in the spanwise direction inside the blade passage. A low momentum region develops above the tip clearance vortex from flow originating from the casing boundary layer. The low momentum area builds up immediately downstream of the passage shock and above the core vortex. This area migrates toward the pressure side of the blade passage as the flow rate is decreased. The low momentum area prevents incoming flow from passing through the pressure side of the passage and initiates stall inception. It is well known that inviscid effects dominate tip clearance flow. However, complex viscous flow structures develop inside the casing boundary layer at operating conditions near stall.


1994 ◽  
Author(s):  
D. Muthuvel Murugan ◽  
Widen Tabakoff ◽  
Awatef Hamed

Detailed flow investigation in the downstream region of a radial inflow turbine has been performed using a three component Laser Doppler Velocimetry. The flow velocities are measured in the exit region of the turbine at off-design operating conditions. The results are presented as contour and vector plots of mean velocities, flow angles and turbulent stresses. The measured parameters are correlated to the rotor blade rotation to observe any periodic nature of the flow. The measurements reveal a complex flow pattern near the tip region at the rotor exit due to the interaction of the tip clearance flow. The degree of swirl of the flow near the tip region at the rotor exit is observed to be high due to the gross under turning of the flow near the tip region. The effect of the rotor on the exit flow field is observed in the proximity of the rotor exit.


Author(s):  
HaoGuang Zhang ◽  
Kang An ◽  
Feng Tan ◽  
YanHui Wu ◽  
WuLi Chu

The compressor aerodynamic design is conducted under the condition of clean inlet in general, but a compressor often operates under the condition of inlet distortion in the practical application. It has been proven by a lot of experimental and numerical investigations that inlet distortion can decrease the performance and stability of compressors. The circumferential or radial distorted inlet in mostly numerical investigations is made by changing the total pressure and total temperature in the inlet ring surface of the compressors. In most of inlet distortion experiments, distorted inlets are usually created by using wire net, flashboards, barriers or the generator of rotating distortion. The fashion of generating distorted inlet for experiment is different from that for numerical simulation. Consequently, the flow mechanism of affecting the flow field and stability of a compressor with distorted inlet for experiment is partly different than that for numerical simulation. In the numerical work reported here, the inlet distortion is generated by setting some barriers in the inlet ring surface of an axial subsonic compressor rotor. Two kinds of distorted inlet are investigated to exploring the effect of distorted range on the flow field and stability of the compressor with ten-passage unsteady numerical method. The numerical results show that the inlet distortions not only degrade the total pressure and efficiency of the compressor rotor, but also decrease the stability of the rotor. The larger the range of distorted inlet is, the stronger the adverse effect is. The comprehensive stall margin for the inlet distortion of 24 degrees and 48 degrees of ten-passages is reduced about 3.35% and 5.88% respectively. The detailed analysis of the flow field in the compressor indicates that the blockage resulted from tip clearance leakage vortex (TLV) and the flow separation near the suction surfaces of some blades tip for distorted inlet is more serious than that resulted from TLV for clean inlet. Moreover, the larger the range of distorted inlet is, the larger the range of the blockage is. The analysis of unsteady flow shows that during this process, which is that one rotor blade passes through the region affected by the distorted inlet, the range of the blockage in the rotor passage increases first, then reduces, and increases last.


Author(s):  
Wei Zhu ◽  
Songtao Wang ◽  
Longxin Zhang ◽  
Jun Ding ◽  
Zhongqi Wang

This study aimed to enhance the understanding of flow phenomena in low-reaction aspirated compressors. Three-dimensional, multi-passage steady and unsteady numerical simulations are performed to investigate the performance sensitivity to tip clearance variation on the first-stage rotor of a multistage low-reaction aspirated compressor. Three kinds of tip clearance sizes including 1.0τ, 2.0τ and 3.0τ are modeled, in which 1.0τ corresponds to the designed tip clearance size of 0.2 mm. The steady numerical simulations show that the overall performance of the rotor moves toward lower mass flow rate when the tip clearance size is increased. Moreover, energy losses, efficiency reduction and stall margin decrease are also observed with increasing tip clearance size. This can be mostly attributed to the damaging impact of intense tip clearance flow. For unsteady simulation, the result shows periodical oscillation of the tip leakage vortex and a “two-passage periodic structure” in the tip region at the near-stall point. The occurrence of the periodical oscillation is due to the severe interaction between the tip clearance flow and the shock wave. However, the rotor operating state is still stable at this working point because a dynamic balance is established between the tip clearance flow and incoming flow.


Author(s):  
Chunill Hah ◽  
Michael Hathaway ◽  
Joseph Katz

The primary focus of this paper is to investigate the effect of rotor tip gap size on how the rotor unsteady tip clearance flow structure changes in a low speed one and half stage axial compressor at near stall operation (for example, where maximum pressure rise is obtained). A Large Eddy Simulation (LES) is applied to calculate the unsteady flow field at this flow condition with both a small and a large tip gaps. The numerically obtained flow fields at the small clearance matches fairly well with the available initial measurements obtained at the Johns Hopkins University with 3-D unsteady PIV in an index-matched test facility which renders the compressor blades and casing optically transparent. With this setup, the unsteady velocity field in the entire flow domain, including the flow inside the tip gap, can be measured. The numerical results are also compared with previously published measurements in a low speed single stage compressor (Maerz et al. [2002]). The current study shows that, with the smaller rotor tip gap, the tip clearance vortex moves to the leading edge plane at near stall operating condition, creating a nearly circumferentially aligned vortex that persists around the entire rotor. On the other hand, with a large tip gap, the clearance vortex stays inside the blade passage at near stall operation. With the large tip gap, flow instability and related large pressure fluctuation at the leading edge are observed in this one and a half stage compressor. Detailed examination of the unsteady flow structure in this compressor stage reveals that the flow instability is due to shed vortices near the leading edge, and not due to a three-dimensional separation vortex originating from the suction side of the blade, which is commonly referred to during a spike-type stall inception. The entire tip clearance flow is highly unsteady. Many vortex structures in the tip clearance flow, including the sheet vortex system near the casing, interact with each other. The core tip clearance vortex, which is formed with the rotor tip gap flows near the leading edge, is also highly unsteady or intermittent due to pressure oscillations near the leading edge and varies from passage to passage. For the current compressor stage, the evidence does not seem to support that a classical vortex breakup occurs in any organized way, even with the large tip gap. Although wakes from the IGV influence the tip clearance flow in the rotor, the major characteristics of rotor tip clearance flows in isolated or single stage rotors are observed in this one and a half stage axial compressor.


Author(s):  
Ronald Mailach ◽  
Ingolf Lehmann ◽  
Konrad Vogeler

In this two-part paper results of the periodical unsteady flow field within the third rotor blade row of the four-stage Dresden Low-Speed Research Compressor are presented. The main part of the experimental investigations was performed using Laser-Doppler-Anemometry. Results of the flow field at several spanwise positions between midspan and rotor blade tip will be discussed. In addition time-resolving pressure sensors at midspan of the rotor blades provide information about the unsteady profile pressure distribution. In part II of the paper the flow field in the rotor blade tip region will be discussed. The experimental results reveal a strong periodical interaction of the incoming stator wakes and the rotor blade tip clearance vortices. Consequently, in the rotor frame of reference the tip clearance vortices are periodical with the stator blade passing frequency. Due to the wakes the tip clearance vortices are separated into different segments. Along the mean vortex trajectory these parts can be characterised by alternating patches of higher and lower velocity and flow turning or subsequent counterrotating vortex pairs. These flow patterns move downstream along the tip clearance vortex path in time. As a result of the wake influence the orientation and extension of the tip clearance vortices as well as the flow blockage periodically vary in time.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document