Statistical Tolerance Analysis With Sensitivities Established With Tolerance-Maps

Author(s):  
Aniket N. Chitale ◽  
Joseph K. Davidson ◽  
Jami J. Shah

The purpose of math models for tolerances is to aid a designer in assessing relationships between tolerances that contribute to variations of a dependent dimension that must be controlled to achieve some design function and which identifies a target (functional) feature. The T-Maps model for representing limits to allowable manufacturing variations is applied to identify the sensitivity of a dependent dimension to each of the contributing tolerances to the relationship. The method is to choose from a library of T-Maps the one that represents, in its own local (canonical) reference frame, each contributing feature and the tolerances specified on it; transform this T-Map to a coordinate frame centered at the target feature; obtain the accumulation T-Map for the assembly with the Minkowski sum; and fit a circumscribing functional T-Map to it. The fitting is accomplished numerically to determine the associated functional tolerance value. The sensitivity for each contributing tolerance-and-feature combination is determined by perturbing the tolerance, refitting the functional map to the accumulation map, and forming a ratio of incremental tolerance values from the two functional T-Maps. Perturbing the tolerance-feature combinations one at a time, the sensitivities for an entire stack of contributing tolerances can be built. For certain classes of loop equations, the same sensitivities result by fitting the functional T-Map to the T-Map for each feature, one-by-one, and forming the overall result as a scalar sum. Sensitivities help a designer to optimize tolerance assignments by identifying those tolerances that most strongly influence the dependent dimension at the target feature. Since the fitting of the functional T-Map is accomplished by intersection of geometric shapes, all the T-Maps are constructed with linear half-spaces.

Author(s):  
Aniket N. Chitale ◽  
J. K. Davidson ◽  
Jami J. Shah

Math models aid designers in assessing relationships between tolerances that contribute to variations of a dependent dimension that must be controlled to achieve some design function at a target (functional) feature. The Tolerance-Maps© (T-Maps©) model for representing limits to allowable manufacturing variations is applied to identify the sensitivity of a dependent dimension to each contributing tolerance of the relationship. For each contributing feature and tolerances specified on it, the appropriate T-Map is chosen from a library of T-Maps, each represented in its own respective local reference frame. Each chosen T-Map is then transformed to the coordinate frame at the target feature, and the accumulation T-Map of these is formed with the Minkowski sum. The shape of a functional T-Map/deviation space is circumscribed (fitted) to this accumulation map. Since fitting is accomplished numerically by intersecting geometric shapes, T-Maps/deviation spaces are constructed with linear half-spaces. The sensitivity for each tolerance-and-feature combination is determined by perturbing the tolerance, refitting the functional shape to the modified accumulation map, and forming a ratio of the increment of functional tolerance to the perturbation. Taking tolerance-feature combinations one by one, sensitivities for an entire stack can be built. For certain loop equations, the same sensitivities result by fitting the functional shape to the T-Map/deviation space for each feature, without a Minkowski sum, and forming the overall result as a scalar sum. Sensitivities are used to optimize tolerance assignments by identifying the tolerances that most strongly influence the dependent dimension at the target feature. Form variations are not included in the analysis.


Author(s):  
James Guilford ◽  
M. Sethi ◽  
Joshua Turner

Abstract Designers are increasingly finding the need for an automated tolerance analysis package which interprets tolerances according to established tolerancing standards. Unfortunately, most of the commercial packages available make simplifying assumptions for the conventional plus-minus tolerances and do not support geometric tolerancing at all. Construction of a tolerance analysis models with these packages can be time consuming. GEOS is an automated tolerance analysis package which overcomes these shortcomings. It is based on variational modeling and feasibility space approaches. This report presents the results for a worst case amd statistical tolerance analysis done on an industrial assembly using GEOS. For this analysis, no special models had to be created as GEOS can accept the 3-D CAD model directly. The models used both conventional plus-minus tolerances as well as geometric tolerances. A GEOS graphical front-end, integrated with a commercial CAD system, was used to define the assembly relations, design function, and analysis parameters.


2008 ◽  
Vol 07 (01) ◽  
pp. 127-130 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. G. LIU ◽  
P. WANG ◽  
Z. G. LI

In statistical tolerance analysis, it is usually assumed that the statistical tolerance is normally distributed. But in practice, there are many non-normal distributions, such as uniform distribution, triangular distribution, etc. The simple way to analyze non-normal distributions is to approximately represent it with normal distribution, but the accuracy is low. Monte-Carlo simulation can analyze non-normal distributions with higher accuracy, but is time consuming. Convolution method is an accurate method to analyze statistical tolerance, but there are few reported works about it because of the difficulty. In this paper, analytical convolution is used to analyze non-normal distribution, and the probability density functions of closed loop component are obtained. Comparing with other methods, convolution method is accurate and faster.


Author(s):  
S. H. Mullins ◽  
D. C. Anderson

Abstract Presented is a method for mathematically modeling mechanical component tolerances. The method translates the semantics of ANSI Y14.5M tolerances into an algebraic form. This algebraic form is suitable for either worst-case or statistical tolerance analysis and seeks to satisfy the requirements of both dimensional metrology and design analysis and synthesis. The method is illustrated by application to datum systems, position tolerances, orientation tolerances, and size tolerances.


Procedia CIRP ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 75 ◽  
pp. 220-225 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gaurav Ameta ◽  
Joseph K. Davidson ◽  
Jami J. Shah

Author(s):  
Edoh Goka ◽  
Lazhar Homri ◽  
Pierre Beaurepaire ◽  
Jean-Yves Dantan

Tolerance analysis aims toward the verification impact of the individual tolerances on the assembly and functional requirements of a mechanism. The manufactured products have several types of contact and are inherent in imperfections, which often causes the failure of the assembly and its functioning. Tolerances are, therefore, allocated to each part of the mechanism in purpose to obtain an optimal quality of the final product. Three main issues are generally defined to realize the tolerance analysis of a mechanical assembly: the geometrical deviations modeling, the geometrical behavior modeling, and the tolerance analysis techniques. In this paper, a method is proposed to realize the tolerance analysis of an over-constrained mechanical assembly with form defects by considering the contacts nature (fixed, sliding, and floating contacts) in its geometrical behavior modeling. Different optimization methods are used to study the different contact types. The overall statistical tolerance analysis of the over-constrained mechanical assembly is carried out by determining the assembly and the functionality probabilities based on optimization techniques combined with a Monte Carlo simulation (MCS). An application to an over-constrained mechanical assembly is given at the end.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document