In genome-wide association studies, linear mixed models (LMMs) have been widely used to explore the molecular mechanism of complex traits. However, typical association approaches suffer from several important drawbacks: estimation of variance components in LMMs with large scale individuals is computationally slow; single-locus model is unsatisfactory to handle complex confounding and causes loss of statistical power. To address these issues, we propose an efficient two-stage method based on hybrid of restricted and penalized maximum likelihood, named HRePML. Firstly, we performed restricted maximum likelihood (REML) on single-locus LMM to remove unrelated markers, where spectral decomposition on covariance matrix was used to fast estimate variance components. Secondly, we carried out penalized maximum likelihood (PML) on multi-locus LMM for markers with reasonably large effects. To validate the effectiveness of HRePML, we conducted a series of simulation studies and real data analyses. As a result, our method always had the highest average statistical power compared with multi-locus mixed-model (MLMM), fixed and random model circulating probability unification (FarmCPU), and genome-wide efficient mixed model association (GEMMA). More importantly, HRePML can provide higher accuracy estimation of marker effects. HRePML also identifies 41 previous reported genes associated with development traits in Arabidopsis, which is more than was detected by the other methods.
Bias correction for estimated QTL effects using the penalized maximum likelihood method
