This work is a review essay of two books: Africanity Redefined: CollectedEssays of Ali A. Mazrui, edited by Ali Alamin Mazrui, Ricardo ReneLaremont, Tracia Leacock Seghatolislami, Michael A. Toler, and FouadKalouche (Africa World Press: 2002) and Governace and Leadership:Debating the African Condition: Ali Mazrui and His Critics, edited byAlamin M. Mazrui and Willy Mutunga (Africa World Press: 2003) Theseare the first two volumes in a three-volume work dealing with the correspondenceamong Ali Mazrui and his opponents, as well as his supporters,on issues relating to Africa.Mazrui, a Kenyan scholar, is currently Albert Schweitzer professor inhumanities and director of the Institute of Global Cultural Studies, BinghamtonUniversity, State University of New York. An Oxford scholar, he isalso Albert Luthuli professor-at-large in humanities and development studiesat the University of Jos, Nigeria, as well as Andrew D. White professorat-large emeritus and senior scholar in Africana studies at CornellUniversity (www.islamonline.net). In addition, he has authored many publicationsand television and radio documentaries. Perhaps his best-knownwork in the West is his BBC radio and television documentary series “TheAfricans,” which was co-produced by the BBC and the public televisionstation WETA.Writing on Mazrui, Sulayman Nyang of Howard University states:Ali Mazrui is a controversial but independent and original thinker. He isa master word-monger and certainly does not belong to that class of menwho lament that words fail them. …It is because of his conjurer’s abilityto negotiate between the realm of serious issues and the province of ...