Abstract
Insights into the complex clonal architecture of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) unravelled by deep sequencing technologies have challenged the concept of AML as a hierarchically organised disease initiated and driven by rare self-renewing leukemic stem cells (LSCs). In contrast to normal human hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), which are highly enriched in the CD34+ CD38- population, LSCs have also been found in the CD34- and the CD38+ fractions questioning the existence of a consistent LSC surface marker profile for AML. Besides, low LSC frequencies in primary samples, rapid onset of differentiation upon ex vivo culture, and genetic inter-specimen heterogeneity hamper the dissection of the molecular machinery that drives LSC self-renewal.
We performed RNA-Sequencing of primary human AML samples and assessed LSC frequencies by limiting dilution analyses for 56 of these in NOD.Cg-Prkdcscid Il2rgtm1Wjl/SzJ (NSG) mice. By comparing gene expression profiles between high vs low LSC frequency leukemias, we identified the G-protein coupled receptor 56 (GPR56) has significantly more expressed in high LSC frequency leukemias. We validated the RNA-seq data with protein expression by FACS and found an excellent correlation. To determine whether GPR56 positive cells overlapped with the known LSC-associated phenotype CD34+ CD38-, we stained 45 AML samples with CD34, CD38, GPR56, and antibodies against other described LSC markers. Although CD34+ GPR56+ and CD34+ CD38- compartments identified the same population in some samples, we found in the majority of samples that GPR56 further subdivided the CD34+ CD38- compartment. Accordingly, not only the proportions of total GPR56+ and CD34+ GPR56+ cells were significantly higher in LSChigh versus LSClow samples, but also the proportion of GPR56+ cells within the CD34+ CD38- compartment was significantly different between the groups indicating that GPR56 might be of additional value to what is currently considered the best described LSC phenotype. The percentage of total CD34 positive cells did not correlate with LSC frequency clearly distinguishing GPR56 from CD34 or CD38, which are only suitable LSC markers when used in combination. We analysed other potential LSC markers (TIM3, CD96, CD44, CD123, CLL1 and CD47) in our RNA-Seq dataset and by FACS analysis in combination with CD34 as we did for GPR56 and none of them correlated with LSC frequency in our sample collection.
To determine whether GPR56 discriminates engrafting LSCs from non-LSCs, we sorted GPR56+ and GPR56- cells within the CD34-positive and -negative compartments from selected specimens with known engraftment potential. We found that GPR56 identified the engrafting fraction in CD34positive AML samples, with a >50 fold enrichment in LSC in the CD34+GRP56+ fraction vs the CD34+GPR56- fraction within the same sample, demonstrating that GPR56 is a good LSC marker.
Specimens with high molecular or cytogenetic risk such as chromosome 5 or 7 anomalies and EVI1- rearrangementexpressed high levels of both, GPR56 and CD34, while samples with coexistent FLT3 -ITD, DNMT3A, and NPM1 mutations displayed a unique CD34low GPR56high profile. Moreover, we found a divergent distribution of variant allele frequencies in GPR56+ versus GPR56- fractions identifying GPR56 as a discriminator of leukemic sub-clones with high and low NSG engrafting capacity. Analysis of engrafted cells re-sorted based on GPR56 after being harvested from mouse bone marrow revealed reduced complexity of the clonal composition. Most importantly, GPR56 positive cells differentiated to GPR56 negative cells in mice, which did not happen in the human niche, in which GPR56 positive and negative fractions represented two independently evolved subclones.
In summary our work identifies GPR56 as a novel LSC marker in AML and also shows that GPR56 readily identifies a functionally distinct LSC-rich subclone in the majority of human AML patients and reveals hitherto unforeseen complexity in the interaction between human LSCs and the NSG mouse environment.
Disclosures
No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.
CD9, a potential leukemia stem cell marker, regulates drug resistance and leukemia development in acute myeloid leukemia
