Cognitive Style and Performance under Distraction: A Partial Replication
This study is a partial test of a hypothesis advanced by Broverman (1960a, 1960b) that performance under distraction is a function of the degree of match between the requirements of the task and the cognitive style of Ss. It is expected that, when there is a match, little decrement in performance under distraction will be observed. 61 adult Ss were administered the Stroop Word Color Interference Test and categorized as either perceptual-motor or conceptual dominant. Each S was also given anagrams and mathematics problems with and without distraction. No differences between the cognitive style groups were obtained on performance without distraction. However, there were differences in decrement scores (distraction minus non-distraction); conceptual Ss were less disrupted by distraction on anagrams than were perceptual-motor Ss ( p < .05). No differences were obtained on the mathematics problems. The results were taken as partial support from Broverman's hypothesis.