Response to Referee #1's comments on "Comparing soil carbon loss through respiration and leaching under extreme precipitation events in arid and semi-arid grasslands"

2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Xiaojuan Feng
2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ting Liu ◽  
Liang Wang ◽  
Xiaojuan Feng ◽  
Jinbo Zhang ◽  
Tian Ma ◽  
...  

Abstract. Respiration and leaching are two main processes responsible for soil carbon loss. While the former has received considerable research attention, studies examining leaching processes are limited especially in semiarid grasslands due to low precipitation. Climate change may increase the extreme precipitation event (EPE) frequency in arid and semiarid regions, potentially enhancing soil carbon loss through leaching and respiration. Here we incubated soil columns of three typical grassland soils from Inner Mongolia and Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau and examined the effect of simulated EPEs on soil carbon loss through respiration and leaching. EPEs induced transient increase of soil respiration, equivalent to 32 % and 72 % of the net ecosystem productivity (NEP) in the temperate grasslands (Xilinhot and Keqi) and 7 % in the alpine grasslands (Gangcha). By comparison, leaching loss of soil carbon accounted for 290 %, 120 % and 15 % of NEP at the corresponding sites, respectively, with dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) as the main form of carbon loss in the alkaline soils. Moreover, DIC loss increased with re-occuring EPEs in the soil with the highest pH due to increased dissolution of soil carbonates and elevated contribution of dissolved CO2 from organic carbon degradation (indicated by DIC-δ13C). These results highlight that leaching loss of soil carbon (particularly DIC) is important in the regional carbon budget of arid and semiarid grasslands. With a projected increase of EPEs under climate change, soil carbon leaching processes and its influencing factors warrant better understanding and should be incorporated into soil carbon models when estimating carbon balance in grassland ecosystems.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Huichen Zhao ◽  
Xiyan Xu ◽  
Gensuo Jia ◽  
Anzhi Zhang ◽  
Hesong Wang

Abstract The global hydrological cycle is predicted to be intensified under the warming climate, with more extreme precipitation events and longer dry spell in between. Here, we evaluated how extreme precipitation events (EPEs) with antecedent dry (dry-EPEs) and wet (wet-EPEs) water conditions influence carbon exchange along gradient of arid, semi-arid and sub-humid ecosystems based on eddy covariance datasets. After EPEs, ecosystem respiration (Re) and gross primary productivity (GPP) were stimulated by pulses of soil moisture in arid and semi-arid regions, but suppressed by decreased soil temperature in sub-humid region. Antecedent water condition determined asynchronous response of Re and GPP to EPEs, and therefore fluctuations in net carbon balance. Net carbon uptake capacity was enhanced immediately following wet-EPEs because of more rapid and greater response of GPP than Re. However, after dry-EPEs, net carbon uptake capacity decreased immediately and increased thereafter because the response of GPP to dry-EPEs lagged behind Re. More antecedent precipitation further stimulated accumulative net carbon uptake. Along the aridity gradient, duration and magnitude of net carbon release were greater in wetter regions than that in drier regions after dry-EPEs, while net carbon uptake duration was shorter in wetter regions after wet-EPEs. The accumulative net carbon uptake after EPEs decreased with increasing aridity index, indicating that net carbon uptake capacity in drier regions benefited more from EPEs. We concluded that antecedent water conditions and local climate regimes need to be considered when interpreting the response of carbon exchange to EPEs in dryland ecosystems.


2018 ◽  
Vol 15 (5) ◽  
pp. 1627-1641 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ting Liu ◽  
Liang Wang ◽  
Xiaojuan Feng ◽  
Jinbo Zhang ◽  
Tian Ma ◽  
...  

Abstract. Respiration and leaching are two main processes responsible for soil carbon loss. While the former has received considerable research attention, studies examining leaching processes are limited, especially in semiarid grasslands due to low precipitation. Climate change may increase the extreme precipitation event (EPE) frequency in arid and semiarid regions, potentially enhancing soil carbon loss through leaching and respiration. Here we incubated soil columns of three typical grassland soils from Inner Mongolia and the Qinghai–Tibetan Plateau and examined the effect of simulated EPEs on soil carbon loss through respiration and leaching. EPEs induced a transient increase in CO2 release through soil respiration, equivalent to 32 and 72 % of the net ecosystem productivity (NEP) in the temperate grasslands (Xilinhot and Keqi) and 7 % of NEP in the alpine grasslands (Gangcha). By comparison, leaching loss of soil carbon accounted for 290, 120, and 15 % of NEP at the corresponding sites, respectively, with dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC, biogenic DIC + lithogenic DIC) as the main form of carbon loss in the alkaline soils. Moreover, DIC loss increased with recurring EPEs in the soil with the highest pH due to an elevated contribution of dissolved CO2 from organic carbon degradation (indicated by DIC-δ13C). These results highlight the fact that leaching loss of soil carbon (particularly in the form of DIC) is important in the regional carbon budget of arid and semiarid grasslands and also imply that SOC mineralization in alkaline soils might be underestimated if only measured as CO2 emission from soils into the atmosphere. With a projected increase in EPEs under climate change, soil carbon leaching processes and the influencing factors warrant a better understanding and should be incorporated into soil carbon models when estimating carbon balance in grassland ecosystems.


Ecology ◽  
2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alison K. Post ◽  
Kristin P. Davis ◽  
Jillian LaRoe ◽  
David L. Hoover ◽  
Alan K. Knapp

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document