Improving hydrologic model realism by using stable water isotopes

Author(s):  
Harsh Beria ◽  
Lionel Benoit ◽  
Natalie Ceperley ◽  
Anthony Michelon ◽  
Joshua R. Larsen ◽  
...  

<p>The last century of hydrological research has led to significant improvements in representing different hydrological processes in rainfall-runoff models. With widely available streamflow data, such models are typically calibrated against this reference time series, which can limit their predictive power. One option to improve the realism of rainfall-runoff models is by incorporating environmental tracers such as stable isotopes of water, water temperature and electrical conductivity within the modeling setup. Conventionally, stable water isotopes have been used to learn more about the dominant hydrological processes that occur within a given catchment, which generally helps improve the hydrologic model structure, but often at the cost of increased model complexity to simulate the tracer concentration along with streamflow.</p><p>In this study, we develop a framework to incorporate stable water isotopes in continuous hydrological modeling, without significantly increasing model complexity. In the first step, stable water isotopes are used along with streamflow recession analysis to initialize the model state variables. After that, a Bayesian mixing model is used to infer the proportion of slow vs fast subsurface flow, and the results are used as additional constraints during the model calibration. This framework is extensively tested in a snow-dominated experimental catchment called Vallon de Nant, located in the Southwestern Swiss Alps (1189-3051 m. a.s.l.). During the presentation, we will discuss the advantages and limitations of such a modeling approach and how it can be extended to other experimental catchments.</p>

2015 ◽  
Vol 29 (23) ◽  
pp. 4957-4967 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tsung-Ren Peng ◽  
Kuan-Yu Chen ◽  
Wen-Jun Zhan ◽  
Wan-Chung Lu ◽  
Lun-Tao John Tong

2018 ◽  
Vol 5 (6) ◽  
Author(s):  
Harsh Beria ◽  
Joshua R. Larsen ◽  
Natalie Claire Ceperley ◽  
Anthony Michelon ◽  
Torsten Vennemann ◽  
...  

2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Harsh Beria ◽  
Joshua Larsen ◽  
Natalie Ceperley ◽  
Anthony Michelon ◽  
Torsten Vennemann ◽  
...  

2017 ◽  
Vol 21 (10) ◽  
pp. 5089-5110 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pertti Ala-aho ◽  
Doerthe Tetzlaff ◽  
James P. McNamara ◽  
Hjalmar Laudon ◽  
Chris Soulsby

Abstract. Tracer-aided hydrological models are increasingly used to reveal fundamentals of runoff generation processes and water travel times in catchments. Modelling studies integrating stable water isotopes as tracers are mostly based in temperate and warm climates, leaving catchments with strong snow influences underrepresented in the literature. Such catchments are challenging, as the isotopic tracer signals in water entering the catchments as snowmelt are typically distorted from incoming precipitation due to fractionation processes in seasonal snowpack. We used the Spatially distributed Tracer-Aided Rainfall–Runoff (STARR) model to simulate fluxes, storage, and mixing of water and tracers, as well as estimating water ages in three long-term experimental catchments with varying degrees of snow influence and contrasting landscape characteristics. In the context of northern catchments the sites have exceptionally long and rich data sets of hydrometric data and – most importantly – stable water isotopes for both rain and snow conditions. To adapt the STARR model for sites with strong snow influence, we used a novel parsimonious calculation scheme that takes into account the isotopic fractionation through snow sublimation and snowmelt. The modified STARR setup simulated the streamflows, isotope ratios, and snow pack dynamics quite well in all three catchments. From this, our simulations indicated contrasting median water ages and water age distributions between catchments brought about mainly by differences in topography and soil characteristics. However, the variable degree of snow influence in catchments also had a major influence on the stream hydrograph, storage dynamics, and water age distributions, which was captured by the model. Our study suggested that snow sublimation fractionation processes can be important to include in tracer-aided modelling for catchments with seasonal snowpack, while the influence of fractionation during snowmelt could not be unequivocally shown. Our work showed the utility of isotopes to provide a proof of concept for our modelling framework in snow-influenced catchments.


2019 ◽  
Vol 213 ◽  
pp. 337-348 ◽  
Author(s):  
Richard P. Fiorella ◽  
Ryan Bares ◽  
John C. Lin ◽  
Gabriel J. Bowen

2020 ◽  
Vol 34 (8) ◽  
pp. 1868-1887
Author(s):  
Stuart Andrew Vyse ◽  
Majid Taie Semiromi ◽  
Gunnar Lischeid ◽  
Christoph Merz

2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pertti Ala-aho ◽  
Doerthe Tetzlaff ◽  
James P. McNamara ◽  
Hjalmar Laudon ◽  
Chris Soulsby

Abstract. Tracer-aided hydrological models are increasingly used to reveal fundamentals of runoff generation processes and water travel times in catchments. Modelling studies integrating stable water isotopes as tracers are mostly based in temperate and warm climates, leaving catchments with strong snow-influences catchments underrepresented in the literature. Such catchments are challenging, as the isotopic tracer signals in water entering the catchments as snowmelt are typically distorted from incoming precipitation due to fractionation processes in seasonal snowpack. We used the Spatially Distributed Tracer-Aided Rainfall-Runoff model (STARR) to simulate fluxes, storage and mixing of water and tracers, as well as estimating water ages in three long-term experimental catchments with varying degrees of snow influence and contrasting landscape characteristics. The sites have exceptionally long and rich datasets of hydrometric data and - most importantly - stable water isotopes for both rain and snow conditions. To adapt the STARR model for sites with strong snow-influence, we developed a novel parsimonious calculation scheme that takes into account the isotopic fractionation through snow evaporation and snow melt. The modified STARR setup simulated the stream flows, isotope ratios and snow pack dynamics quite well in all three catchments. From this, our simulations indicated contrasting median water ages and water age distributions between catchments brought about mainly by differences in topography, soils and geology. However, the variable degree of snow influence in catchments also had a major influence on the stream hydrograph, storage dynamics and water age distributions, which was captured by the model. Our study demonstrated the importance of including snow evaporative fractionation processes in tracer-aided modelling for catchments with seasonal snowpack, while the influence of fractionation during snowmelt could not be unequivocally shown. Our work shows the utility of isotopes to provide a proof of concept for our modelling framework in snow influenced catchments.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Christopher Johannes Diekmann ◽  
Matthias Schneider ◽  
Peter Knippertz ◽  
Andries Jan de Vries ◽  
Stephan Pfahl ◽  
...  

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tailin Li ◽  
Nina Noreika ◽  
Jakub Jeřábek ◽  
Tomáš Dostál ◽  
David Zumr

<p>A better understanding of hydrological processes in agricultural catchments is not only crucial to hydrologists but also helpful for local farmers. Therefore, we have built the freely-available web-based WALNUD dataset (Water in Agricultural Landscape – NUčice Database) for our experimental catchment Nučice (0.53 km<sup>2</sup>), the Czech Republic. We have included observed precipitation, air temperature, stream discharge, and soil moisture in the dataset. Furthermore, we have applied numerical modelling techniques to investigate the hydrological processes (e.g. soil moisture variability, water balance) at the experimental catchment using the dataset.</p><p>The Nučice catchment, established in 2011, serves for the observation of rainfall-runoff processes, soil erosion and water balance of the cultivated landscape. The average altitude is 401 m a.s.l., the mean land slope is 3.9 %, and the climate is humid continental (mean annual temperature 7.9 °C, average annual precipitation 630 mm). The catchment consists of three fields covering over 95 % of the area. There is a narrow stream which begins as a subsurface drainage pipe in the uppermost field draining the water at catchment. The typical crops are winter wheat, rapeseed, mustard and alfalfa. The installed equipment includes a standard meteorological station, several rain gauges distributed in the area of the basin, and an H flume to monitor the stream discharge, water turbidity and basic water quality indicators. The soil water content (at point scale) and groundwater level are also recorded. Recently, we have installed two cosmic-ray soil moisture sensors (StyX Neutronica) to estimate large-scale topsoil water content at the catchment.</p><p>Even though the soil management and soil properties in the fields of Nučice seem to be nearly homogeneous, we have observed variability in the topsoil moisture pattern. The method for the explanation of the soil water regime was the combination of the connectivity indices and numerical modelling. The soil moisture profiles from the point-scale sensors were processed in a 1-D physically-based soil water model (HYDRUS-1D) to optimize the soil hydraulic parameters. Further, the soil hydraulic parameters were used as input into a 3D spatially-distributed model, MIKE-SHE. The MIKE-SHE simulation has been mainly calibrated with rainfall-runoff observations. Meanwhile, the spatial patterns of the soil moisture were assessed from the simulation for both dry and wet catchment conditions. From the MIKE-SHE simulation, the optimized soil hydraulic parameters have improved the estimation of soil moisture dynamics and runoff generation. Also, the correlation between the observed and simulated soil moisture spatial patterns showed different behaviors during the dry and wet catchment conditions.</p><p>This study has been supported by the Grant Agency of the Czech Technical University in Prague, grant No. SGS20/156/OHK1/3T/11 and the Project SHui which is co-funded by the European Union Project: 773903 and the Chinese MOST.</p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document