High tolerance to simulated root herbivory in hydroponically grown cuttings of Salix phylicifolia

The shortage of information regarding the effects of root damage on forest plants, especially trees and shrubs, is the most critical gap in our knowledge of belowground insect herbivory. This study examines how the tea-leaved willow, Salix phylicifolia, responds to simulated root herbivory and how nutrient availability affects these responses. Hydroponically grown cuttings were used to precisely apply the desired levels of root damage. Root: shoot ratios increased proportionally to the intensity of root damage, whereas specific leaf area, leaf water content and chlorophyll fluorescence were not affected. The removal of 2–64% of roots once in early summer and the removal of 25% of roots three times during the summer did not change biomass production by cuttings. The repeated removal of 50 and 75% of roots decreased shoot biomass and, to a lesser extent, total root production. The tolerance of tea-leaved willow to root damage was greater in low nutrient treatment than in high nutrient treatment, thus supporting the Growth Rate Model. According to this model, in low resource conditions plants do not attain their maximum growth rate and therefore have a higher capacity for regrowth after damage. We conclude that, in the absence of water limitations, tea-leaved willow shows high tolerance to root losses and is unlikely to be affected by realistic levels of root herbivory.

Root Herbivory: Grass Species, Epichloë Endophytes and Moisture Status Make a Difference

The root-feeding scarab insect Costelytra giveni causes severe damage to pasture ecosystems in New Zealand. Loline alkaloids produced by some Epichloë endophytes deter this insect. In two experiments, tall fescue infected with E. coenophiala, strain AR584, and endophyte-free (Nil) controls were subjected to pulse drought stress (DS) or well-watered conditions (WW). The second experiment also included meadow fescue infected with E. uncinata. After 4–6 weeks exposure to the different conditions, roots were excised and fed to C. giveni larvae for 7 days. Relative root consumption (RC), frass production, and relative weight change (RWC) of larvae were measured and the loline content of roots determined. RC and frass output were higher for larvae feeding on Nil DS tall fescue than WW and reduced by AR584. RWC was also greater on DS than on WW Nil plants but reduced by endophyte only in DS plants. RC, frass output, and RWC of larvae were reduced by endophyte in DS and WW meadow fescue, but the effect was greater for WW plants. Loline alkaloid concentration in roots was significantly higher in DS than WW tall fescue in Experiment I but higher in WW than DS meadow fescue in Experiment II. These experiments have demonstrated that moisture status interacts with endophyte to differentially affect root herbivory in tall fescue and meadow fescue.

Drought Stress Impairs Communication Between Solanum tuberosum (Solanales: Solanaceae) and Subterranean Biological Control Agents

The attraction of entomopathogenic nematodes (EPNs) to herbivore-injured plant roots has been documented recently to be a common tritrophic interaction. Belowground tritrophic interactions are especially subject to modulation by many abiotic factors including drought. In this study, complementary greenhouse experiments were conducted to understand how drought stress might affect a potato plant’s impact on EPN behavior. In separate trials, the responses of the EPN Steinernema diaprepesi (Nguyen and Duncan) (Rhabditida: Steinernematidae) to root herbivory by larvae of the weevil Diaprepes abbreviatus (Linnaeus) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), in well-watered and drought stressed potato plants, were measured using soil-matrix olfactometers with two arms. The drought treatments were initiated in 30-d old plants. Drought-stressed potato plants received water when potentiometers read approximately 20 kPa, while for well-watered plants, the number was 8 kPa. Four weeks after initiating the treatments, 400 ml water was added to all pots, immediately before starting the experiments. The experiments revealed that S. diaprepesi infective juveniles (IJs) did not migrate preferentially toward drought-stressed or well-watered plants when neither were subjected to herbivory [t(21) = 1.13, P = 0.269]. However, plants with roots damaged by herbivory attracted more S. diaprepesi IJs if they were well watered than if they were drought stressed [t(24) = 3.19, P = 0.004]. If both plants in the olfactometers were drought stressed, EPNs moved preferentially toward those with root herbivory than those with undamaged roots [t(23) = 3.19, P = 0.004]. No difference was detected in gas chromatography profiles between droughted and well-watered plant roots subjected to herbivory [F(24, 336) = 0.68, P = 0.87]. GC analysis showed that three compounds, including 3-nonanone [t(6) = 4.83, P = 0.003], artemisyl ketone [t(7) = 6.21, P = 0.000], and benzoic acid, 4-ethoxy-, ethyl ester [t(7) = −4.22, P = 0.004] were significantly higher in drought stressed than control plant roots. These results indicate that potatoes, like other plants, can recruit EPNs in response to root herbivory, and that drought stress dampens this tritrophic interaction where choice is involved. Additional research that resolves the mechanisms of these interactions may provide insights to exploit EPNs for crop protection.