This chapter suggests that despite the removal of God from human history, which radically altered the understanding of the mechanism that propelled Jewish history, assessments of Jewish historical fate as unfailingly painful survived intact. Observers continued to project the Jews as an endlessly afflicted people and to highlight forced Jewish displacement as the most extreme element in the relentless tragedy of the Jewish people. The ongoing emphasis on Jewish suffering and hurtful demographic dislocation combined with the removal of God and divine causation from the historical arena sparked a search for new causative explanations for the long-established and widely shared views of the tribulations of the previous two millennia of Jewish history. These new explanations revised but at the same time reinforced the still regnant conviction that Jews have suffered incessantly since the onset of their purported third exile.