Correlation Allowances in Model Tests Results: A Delicate Balance Between Performance, Accuracy and Commercial Interests?

2016 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gerco Hagesteijn ◽  
Patrick Hooijmans ◽  
Karola van der Meij
Keyword(s):  
Model Test ◽  
Performance Prediction ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Power Performance ◽  
Low Light ◽  
Sea Trial ◽  
Performance Accuracy ◽  
Full Scale Tests

Model tests at ballast and design draught are used to convert the sea trial results from the ballast trial draught to the contractual design draught. Correlation allowances in model test results and their effect on the trial performance prediction are of major importance. Nowadays it is not only typical to verify the contract speed but also the EEDI certification requires a verification of the speed power performance of the vessel. The use of a to favorable CA-value may lead to attractive performance figures, but also leads to higher fuel consumption figures than expected. Furthermore the design point of the propeller is affected, which leads to a too low light running margin and in some cases to erosive cavitation. During a study, large spreading in the values of the correlation allowances for design draughts have been found for merchant vessels tested at different model test institutes, but at ballast trial draught the spreading is much less. Can it happen that some institutes select favorable correlations allowances on the basis of inaccurate trial data of shipyards? Or should we accept a large spreading in correlation allowances and have these indeed been confirmed by sea trials at design draught? This paper will present a discussion using the experience of a large full scale trial database as well as the accuracy of model and full scale tests.

scholarly journals Model-Scale/Full-Scale Correlation of NRC-OCRE’s Model Resistance, Propulsion and Maneuvering Test Results

2015 ◽  
Author(s):  
Michael Lau
Keyword(s):  
Test Data ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Sea Trial ◽  
Model Scale ◽  
Performance Predictions ◽  
Ice Strength ◽  
Scale Data

There are a variety of model ices and test techniques adopted by model test facilities. Most often, the clients would ask: “How well can you predict the full scale performance from your model test results?” Model-scale/full-scale correlation becomes an important litmus test to validate a model test technique and its results. This paper summarizes the model-scale/full-scale correlation performed on model test data generated at the National Research Council - Ocean, Coastal, and River Engineering’s (NRC-OCRE) test facility in St. John’s. This correlation includes ship performance predictions, i.e., resistance, propulsion and maneuvering. Selected works from NRC-OCRE on the USCGC icebreaker Healy, the CCGS icebreaker Terry-Fox, the CCGS R-Class icebreakers Pierre Radisson and Sir John Franklin and the CCGS icebreaker Louis S. St. Laurent were reviewed and summarized. The model tests were conducted at NRC-OCRE’s ice tank with the correct density (CD) EGADS model ice. This correlation is based on the concept that a “correlation friction coefficient” (CFC) can be used to predict full-scale ship icebreaking resistance from model test data. The CFCs have been compared for correlation studies using good-quality full-scale information for the five icebreaker models in the NRC-OCRE’s model test database. The review has shown a good agreement between NRCOCRE’s model test predictions and full-scale measurements. The resistance and power correlation were performed for five sets of full-scale data. Although there is substantial uncertainty on ice thickness and ice strength within the full scale data sets that contributes to data scattering, the data suggest a conservative estimate can be obtained to address reasonably this uncertainty by increasing the model prediction by 15% that envelopes most data points. Limited correlation for maneuvering in ice was performed for the USCGC icebreaker Healy. Selected test conditions from the sea trials were duplicated for the maneuvering tests and turning diameters were measured from the arcs of partial circles made in the ice tank. Performance predictions were then compared to the full-scale data previously collected. Despite some discrepancy in ice strength and power level between the model tests and sea trial, the model data agree well with the sea trial data except for three outliers. Otherwise, the maneuvering data show a good correlation between the model test and sea trial results.

Documentation of Operational Limits of Free-Fall Lifeboats by Combining Model Tests, Full-Scale Tests, and Computer Simulation

2009 ◽  
Author(s):  
Wojciech E. Kauczynski ◽  
Per Werenskiold ◽  
Frode Narten
Keyword(s):  
Wave Height ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Free Fall ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Extrapolation Methods ◽  
Basic Performance ◽  
Calm Water ◽  
Full Scale Tests

Historically, approval of lifeboats is based on a “calm water” philosophy through the SOLAS regulatory regime. In spring 2005 during offshore installation tests in calm water, unacceptable structural deflection of the roof for one type of free-fall lifeboat was revealed. Immediate actions were initiated by the Norwegian Oil Industry Association (OLF) and Statoil, including the goal of studying and documenting the main performance factors for free-fall lifeboats at up to a 100-year weather condition. In addition, OLF has request to develop relevant criteria for in depth classification of performance, and finally to upgrade urgently, when relevant, all free-fall lifeboats operating on the Norwegian continental shelf to the agreed standards. The basic performance criteria of free-fall lifeboat systems in emergency conditions are: structural strength, acceleration loads on passengers during water impact, boat forward speed immediately after water entry, and the manoeuvring away to a safe distance from the installation. Within the OLF-project, MARINTEK has performed an extensive model test program (over 25000 tests) with the 14 different types of free-fall lifeboats (launched by vertical drop or from a skid). Boat performances have been examined in different weather conditions, ranging from still water up to 11m wave height (regular waves and wind) or 7m (irregular significant wave height with corresponding wind). Calm water model test results have been compared to full-scale test results. In order to extend prognosis of the lifeboat performances up to 100-year storm condition (Hs = 15.7m), special extrapolation methods have been developed for studying the three basic performance areas, augmented by computer simulations applied for higher sea states. This paper presents example results and experiences gained from the model tests, full-scale tests and combined use of simulations and model test results. Experimental model test set-up and applied analysis and extrapolation methods are reviewed. Finally, the application of newly proposed performance and technical criteria is discussed.

Infrared Signature Suppression for Marine Gas Turbines: Comparison of Sea Trial and Model Test Results for the DRES Ball IRSS System

1994 ◽  
Vol 116 (1) ◽  
pp. 75-81 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. M. Birk ◽  
D. VanDam
Keyword(s):  
Model Test ◽  
Gas Turbines ◽  
Flow Model ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Scale Model ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Sea Trial ◽  
Infrared Signature ◽  
Plume Temperature ◽  
Better Than

Sea Trials have recently been underway for Canada’s new City Class Patrol Frigate (CPF). These trials provided the first opportunity to measure the performance of the new DRES Ball Infrared Signature Suppression (IRSS) system installed on a ship. Prior to these trials 1/4-scale hot flow model test and computer simulation performance results were available. The CPF DRES Ball IRSS systems are installed on the exhaust uptakes of the GE LM2500 main gas turbines. The DRES Ball provides both metal surface cooling for all view angles and plume cooling. The DRES Ball significantly reduces the IR signature of the LM2500 exhaust. This paper presents a comparison between the 1/4-scale hot flow model test results with the full-scale sea trial results. Performance variables included in the comparison are: metal surface temperatures, back pressure, plume temperature distribution, and surface static pressures. Because of the confidential nature of the DRES Ball system performance, all classified data have been nondimensionalized so that only relative comparisons can be made between the full-scale and 1/4-scale data. The results show that the full-scale system performs better than the 1/4-scale model because of Reynolds number effects. The plume temperature, surface temperatures, and back pressure were all lower (better) than in the 1/4-scale model tests. One of the original concerns with the installation was that relative wind would degrade the performance of the DRES Ball onboard a ship. The wind effect was found to be benign during the trials.

scholarly journals Seakeeping Performance of a New Coastal Patrol Ship for the Croatian Navy

2020 ◽  
Vol 8 (7) ◽  
pp. 518
Author(s):  
Andrija Ljulj ◽  
Vedran Slapničar
Keyword(s):  
Full Scale ◽  
Coast Guard ◽  
Project Design ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Sea Trial ◽  
Seakeeping Performance ◽  
The World ◽  
Full Scale Tests ◽  
Marine Environmental ◽  
Scientific Purpose

This paper presents seakeeping test results for a coastal patrol ship (CPS) in the Croatian Navy (CN). The full-scale tests were conducted on a CPS prototype that was accepted by the CN. The seakeeping numerical prediction and model tests were done during preliminary project design. However, these results are not fully comparable with the prototype tests since the ship was lengthened in the last phases of the project. Key numerical calculations are presented. The CPS project aims to renew a part of the Croatian Coast Guard with five ships. After successful prototype acceptance trials, the Croatian Ministry of Defence (MoD) will continue building the first ship in the series in early 2020. Full-scale prototype seakeeping test results could be valuable in the design of similar CPS projects. The main aim of this paper is to publish parts of the sea trial results related to the seakeeping performance of the CPS. Coast guards around the world have numerous challenges related to peacetime tasks such as preventing human and drug trafficking, fighting terrorism, controlling immigration, and protecting the marine environmental. They must have reliable platforms with good seakeeping characteristics that are important for overall ship operations. The scientific purpose of this paper is to contribute to the design process of similar CPS projects in terms of the development of seakeeping requirements and their level of fulfillment on an actual ship.

Sailing Performance of "Naniwa-maru" - A Full Scale Reconstruction of a Sailing Trader of Japanese Heritage

2001 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kensaku Nomoto ◽  
Yutaka Masuyama ◽  
Akira Sakurai
Keyword(s):  
Wind Speed ◽  
Wind Tunnel ◽  
19Th Century ◽  
Wind Velocity ◽  
Performance Prediction ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Sea Trial

"Naniwa-maru" is a reconstruction of a sailing trader that used to ply between Osaka and Edo, today's Tokyo, in the 18th to the mid-19th century. The rig was simple; single mast with a huge square sail. It was of totally wooden construction in a genuine Japanese manner. The present paper relates to her sailing sea-trial results compared with performance prediction based upon tank tests and wind tunnel studies. According to the trial the ship could reach as high as 70° to weather on her track and the speed then was some 30% of the true wind velocity in a fair sailing breeze. She was swiftest on a broad reach, achieving more than 40% of the wind speed. The said prediction proved to explain the test results fairly well.

Infra-Red Signature Suppression for Marine Gas Turbines: Comparison of Sea Trial and Model Test Results for the DRES Ball IRSS System

1992 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. M. Birk ◽  
D. Vandam
Keyword(s):  
Model Test ◽  
Gas Turbines ◽  
Flow Model ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Scale Model ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Sea Trial ◽  
Infra Red ◽  
Plume Temperature ◽  
Better Than

Sea Trials have recently been underway for Canada’s new City Class Patrol Frigate (CPF). These trials provided the first opportunity to measure the performance of the new DRES Ball Infra-red Signature Suppression (IRSS) system installed on a ship. Prior to these trials 1/4 scale hot flow model test and computer simulation performance results were available. The CPF DRES Ball IRSS systems are installed on the exhaust uptakes of the GE LM2500 main gas turbines. The DRES Ball provides both metal surface cooling for all view angles and plume cooling. The DRES Ball significantly reduces the IR signature of the LM2500 exhaust. This paper presents a comparison between the 1/4 scale hot flow model test results with the full scale sea trial results. Performance variables included in the comparison are; metal surface temperatures, back pressure, plume temperature distribution, and surface static pressures. Because of the confidential nature of the DRES Ball system performance, all classified data has been nondimensionalized so that only relative comparisons can be made between the full scale and 1/4 scale data. The results show that the full scale system performs better than the 1/4 scale model because of Reynolds number effects. The plume temperature, surface temperatures and back pressure were all lower (better) than in the 1/4 scale model tests. One of the original concerns with the installation was that relative wind would degrade the performance of the DRES Ball onboard a ship. The wind effect was found to be benign during the trials.

Paper 11. Yaw Motion Stability; Twin-Screw, Twin-Rudder Ships—Some Model and Ship Results

1972 ◽  
Vol 14 (7) ◽  
pp. 75-79
Author(s):  
G. D. Thurman
Keyword(s):  
Model Test ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Motion Stability ◽  
Ship Model ◽  
Pull Out ◽  
Twin Screw ◽  
Model Correlation ◽  
Stability Results

This paper describes the pull-out manoeuvre as an indication of yaw motion stability. Results of model tests at the Admiralty Experiment Works and full-scale trials data are presented as a demonstration of ship/model correlation; additional model test results are given to illustrate use of the manoeuvre for detecting changes in stability due to alterations in ship configuration.

Investigation on Reasons for Possible Difference Between VIM Response in the Field and in Model Tests

2016 ◽  
Author(s):  
Arjen Koop ◽  
Jaap de Wilde ◽  
André Luís Condino Fujarra ◽  
Oriol Rijken ◽  
Samuel Linder ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Reynolds Number ◽  
Fatigue Damage ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Scale Effects ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Strong Impact ◽  
Numerical Verification ◽  
Field Observations ◽  
Test Results

Floating offshore structures, such as production semi-submersibles and spars, can exhibit significant in-line and transverse oscillatory motions under current conditions. When caused by vortex shedding from the floater, such motions are generally called Vortex-Induced Motions (VIM). For semi-submersibles these motions could have a strong impact on the fatigue life of mooring and riser systems. Some field development studies indicate that the VIM induced fatigue damage for larger diameter Steel Catenary Risers (SCRs) can have a magnitude equal to or larger than the wave-induced fatigue damage. The VIM phenomenon for multi-column floaters is characterized by complex interactions between the flow and the motions of the floater. Presently, model tests are the preferred method to predict the VIM response of a multi-column floater. However, several studies indicate that the observed VIM response in the field is less than what is observed in model test campaigns: typical model test results are very conservative. Using such test results in the development of mooring and riser design can easily result in very conservative designs which can have a significant impact on mooring and riser cost, or even affect SCR selection and/or feasibility. The primary objective of the VIM JIP was to increase the physical insight into the VIM phenomenon. This knowledge is then used to address possible areas that could explain the differences between the results from model tests and field observations. To address these objectives, the JIP focused on model testing and CFD studies. A key segment of the JIP was the use of identical semi-submersible hull geometries for the numerical and experimental studies thereby facilitating the interpretation of the various response comparisons. The JIP identified that a CFD model, at model-scale Reynolds number, can reasonably well reproduce the VIM response observed in model tests. However, to have confidence in the CFD results extensive numerical verification studies have to be carried out. The effect of external damping was investigated in model tests and in CFD calculations. Both the numerical and experimental results show that external damping significantly reduces the VIM response. Comparisons between CFD results at model- and full-scale Reynolds number indicate that Froude scaling is applicable, with minor scale effects identified on the amplitudes of the VIM motions. Changing the mass ratio of the floater has a small influence on the VIM response. Experimentally it was found that VIM response under inline or transverse waves is slightly smaller than without the presence of waves and is wave heading and wave height dependent. The presence of waves does not explain the observed differences between model test results and field observations. The effect of unsteady current on the VIM response is minimal. Based on the results from the JIP it is concluded that increased external damping reduces the VIM response. The questions that remain are if the increased external damping is actually present in full-scale conditions and if the mooring and riser systems provide the required damping to reduce the VIM amplitudes.

Guidelines for CFD Simulations of Spar VIM

2013 ◽  
Author(s):  
Charles Lefevre ◽  
Yiannis Constantinides ◽  
Jang Whan Kim ◽  
Mike Henneke ◽  
Robert Gordon ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Reynolds Number ◽  
Test Data ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Mooring System ◽  
Time Step ◽  
Cfd Simulations ◽  
Scaled Model ◽  
Sway Motion

Vortex-Induced Motion (VIM), which occurs as a consequence of exposure to strong current such as Loop Current eddies in the Gulf of Mexico, is one of the critical factors in the design of the mooring and riser systems for deepwater offshore structures such as Spars and multi-column Deep Draft Floaters (DDFs). The VIM response can have a significant impact on the fatigue life of mooring and riser components. In particular, Steel Catenary Risers (SCRs) suspended from the floater can be sensitive to VIM-induced fatigue at their mudline touchdown points. Industry currently relies on scaled model testing to determine VIM for design. However, scaled model tests are limited in their ability to represent VIM for the full scale structure since they are generally not able to represent the full scale Reynolds number and also cannot fully represent waves effects, nonlinear mooring system behavior or sheared and unsteady currents. The use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to simulate VIM can more realistically represent the full scale Reynolds number, waves effects, mooring system, and ocean currents than scaled physical model tests. This paper describes a set of VIM CFD simulations for a Spar hard tank with appurtenances and their comparison against a high quality scaled model test. The test data showed considerable sensitivity to heading angle relative to the incident flow as well as to reduced velocity. The simulated VIM-induced sway motion was compared against the model test data for different reduced velocities (Vm) and Spar headings. Agreement between CFD and model test VIM-induced sway motion was within 9% over the full range of Vm and headings. Use of the Improved Delayed Detached Eddy Simulation (IDDES, Shur et al 2008) turbulence model gives the best agreement with the model test measurements. Guidelines are provided for meshing and time step/solver setting selection.

Launching of Ships and Floating Structures from Horizontal Berth by Tipping Table

1998 ◽  
Vol 14 (04) ◽  
pp. 265-276
Author(s):  
Ivo Senjanovic
Keyword(s):  
Structural Dynamics ◽  
Review Paper ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Strength Analysis ◽  
Test Results ◽  
Floating Structures ◽  
Measurement Results

This review paper covers extensive investigations which were undertaken in order to verify the idea of launching of ships and other floating structures from a horizontal berth by a set of turning pads. This includes structural dynamics during launching, model tests and strength analysis of the structure and the launching system. The most important results, which were used for the design of the launching system, are presented. The preparation of a barge for side launching is described, and the full-scale measurement results are compared with the test results. The advantages of building ships and offshore structures on a horizontal berth are pointed out in the conclusion.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document