Duplex Ultrasound Scanning for Chronic Venous Disease: Recurrent Varicose Veins in the Thigh after Surgery to the Long Saphenous Vein

Objective: To use duplex ultrasound scanning to compare limbs with recurrent and primary varicose veins and to identify connections between deep veins and recurrences. Setting: A non-invasive vascular laboratory in Melbourne, Australia. Patients: A study of 779 limbs with recurrent varicose veins previously treated by ligation or stripping of the long saphenous vein and 1521 limbs with primary varicose veins. Main outcome measures: Connections between deep veins and recurrent varices, reflux in superficial and deep veins, and outward flow in perforators as demonstrated by duplex ultrasonography. Results: Recurrence was due to reflux in the long saphenous territory in 71.8%, short saphenous reflux alone in 14.7% or outward flow in calf perforators without saphenous reflux in 5.2%, while no source was detected in 8.3%. Limbs with recurrent veins in the long saphenous territory were compared with limbs with primary varicose veins; there was more frequent outward flow in thigh perforators (25.2% vs. 16.2%) but no difference for deep reflux (20.7% vs. 17.5%) or outward flow in calf perforators (56.8% vs. 53.1%). The source for recurrence in the long saphenous territory was from a single large connection in the groin in 46.3%, multiple smaller proximal connections in a further 46.3%, or thigh perforators in 7.4%. The destination was to an intact long saphenous vein in 33.7%, major tributaries in 28.7% or to other varices in 37.6%. Limbs known to have been treated by long saphenous ligation alone were compared with those known to be treated by long saphenous ligation and stripping; the source was more likely to be from a single large vein in the groin (60.3% vs. 39.9%) and the destination was more likely to be an intact long saphenous vein or major tributary (75.0% vs. 55.2%). Conclusions: Duplex ultrasound scanning detected the source of recurrent varicose veins in over 90% of patients and demonstrated whether there were single large or multiple smaller connections in the veins affected, and this helps to select the most appropriate treatment. Recurrence after stripping the long saphenous vein was more likely to be due to multiple small connections passing to scattered varices and this may allow more simple treatment by injection sclerotherapy rather than repeat surgery.