Potential Pitfalls of Serum Free Light Chain Analysis to Assess Treatment Response for Multiple Myeloma

Blood ◽  
2015 ◽  
Vol 126 (23) ◽  
pp. 5308-5308
Author(s):  
Kamal Kant Singh Abbi ◽  
Guido J Tricot ◽  
Margarida Silverman ◽  
Kalyan Nadiminti ◽  
Matthew Krasowski

Abstract Background The serum free light chain (FLC test) allows measurement of low concentrations of FLC. Post-transplantation, especially after tandem autologous transplants and consolidation therapy, the immune system is often extremely suppressed and its recovery is disorganized. Patients and Methods This study was limited to patients with multiple myeloma, plasma cell leukemia and amyloidosis, who received autologous transplantation and consolidation therapy at the University of Iowa Hospitals and clinics. Most of these patients had already received some form of induction therapy with IMIDs or proteasome inhibitors or in combination. They then proceeded with a cycle of D-PACE followed by one or two autologous transplants. The preparative regimen for virtually all patients was VDT-MEL. Post-transplantation, most of the patients received consolidation therapy with VTD the first year and either VCD or Revlimid/dexamethasone for second year. Thereafter, all myeloma therapy was halted. Serum free light chains were measured with polyclonal FLC antisera according to Freelite, Binding site, UK. The kappa/ lambda ratio was calculated. Results In total 142 patients were evaluated; 12 % (17/142) of patients were found to have abnormal light chains ratio but no other evidence of active disease, including negative serum M-protein, serum IFE, urine M-protein and urine IFE. In addition, bone marrows showed no evidence of clonal plasma cells by both 10-color flow cytometry and FISH analysis of CD138 selected plasma cells; both methods have a sensitivity of ≥ 10-4. The κ/λ ratio was abnormal due to increase/decrease in the same light chain as the M- protein in 11/17 patients; 6/17 patients had abnormal κ/λ ratio due to increase in the opposite light chain as the M- protein (Table 1) Table 1. Patient with abnormal light chains due changes in Involved light chain levels Age Gender M protein/Light chain Transplant M protein Abnormal light chain Immunofixation Elevated or decreased Duration of abnormal ratio 64 Male IgG Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 2 weeks 58 Female IgA Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 4 weeks 46 Female Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 4 weeks 58 Male IgG Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 20 weeks 55 Male IgG Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 4 weeks 60 Male IgG Kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated One week 60 Female IgA Kappa Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 8 weeks 68 Female IgG Kappa Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 26 weeks 42 Male kappa Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated One week 67 Male Kappa Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Decreased 3 weeks 68 Male IgG Kappa Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 8 weeks Patient with abnormal light chain ratio due to changes in the opposite light chain levels 53 Female IgG Lambda Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 2 weeks 62 Female IgA lambda Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 6 weeks 50 Male Lambda Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated One week 60 Male IgG Lambda Tandem 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 100 weeks 68 Female IgA Lambda Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 8 weeks 68 Male lambda Single 0.0 Kappa Negative Elevated 4 weeks Conclusions According to the IMWG uniform response criteria, patients achieving CR for whom the involved FLC reduced sufficiently to normalize the FLC ratio (range, 0.26 to 1.65) in the absence of monoclonal BMPCs as assessed by immunohistochemistry or immunofluorescence are considered to have achieved stringent CR. However, patients can be in stringent complete remission with abnormal k/l ratios if 1) the ratio is abnormal because the non-involved free light chain is elevated while the involved free light chain is normal; 2) the ratio is abnormal because involved light chain is elevated, with no other evidence of disease, including multicolor flow cytometry and FISH analysis on selected plasma cells of the bone marrow and imaging by MRI and/or PET-CT scan. This occurred in > 10% of patients. It should be noted that the FLC causing the abnormal k/l ratio was always kappa. The IMWG criteria should be adjusted these potential pitfalls. Disclosures No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.

Blood ◽  
2016 ◽  
Vol 128 (22) ◽  
pp. 376-376
Author(s):  
Thomas Dejoie ◽  
Michel Attal ◽  
Philippe Moreau ◽  
Herve Avet-Loiseau

Abstract Introduction Guidelines for monitoring light chain multiple myeloma (LCMM) patients currently rely on measurements of the monoclonal protein in urine (Bence Jones proteinuria). However, the presence of light chains in the urine is highly influenced by the individual free light chain, production rate and renal function, which may make accurate monitoring challenging. Serum free light chain measurements are recommended as diagnostic aid for identifying patients with monoclonal gammopathies and as tools to monitor patients with AL amyloidosis and oligo-secretory MM. The correlation between 24hr urine and serum free light chain (sFLC) measurements is insufficient to consider the tests interchangeable, which has prevented recommendations for replacing urine with serum assessment. Here we compare the performance of serum and urine measurements for monitoring 113 newly diagnosed LCMM patients enrolled onto the IFM-2009 trial; and assess the impact of monitoring by either method with clinical outcome. Methods The IFM-2009 trial randomised patients into either arm A (8xRVD) or arm B (3xRVD followed by high-dose Melphalan with autologous stem cell rescue, and 2 further RVD treatments). All patients received one year of Lenalidomide maintenance therapy. Urine protein electrophoresis (UPEP) and immunofixation electrophoresis (uIFE) were performed prospectively using standard laboratory procedures. sFLC concentrations were measured nephellometrically using κ sFLC and λ sFLC Freelite®assays (The Binding Site Group Ltd, UK). Minimal residual disease (MRD) was assessed by 7-color flow cytometry at the end of consolidation therapy. Results At diagnosis, clonal disease was identified in 100% of patients either by an abnormal κ/λ sFLC ratio or by uIFE. However, whilst all patients had measurable disease by the sFLC assay only 64% had measurable disease using UPEP. The discordance in sensitivity was replicated throughout monitoring and monoclonal light chains were quantifiable after cycle 1 and cycle 3 in 71% vs. 37% patients, and 46% vs. 18%, using sFLC vs. 24hr urine measurements, respectively; in keeping with previous reports. To understand the clinical significance of these discordant findings we compared the depth of response determined by sFLC measurement to those determined by urine electrophoresis after 3 cycles of therapy. Patients with quantifiable disease by sFLC or an abnormal κ/λ sFLC ratio had dismal PFS (median PFS: 36 months vs. not reached, p=0.006; 33 months vs. not reached, p<0.0001, respectively). Whereas quantifiable disease by UPEP was uninformative for PFS (36 vs. 47 months, p=0.260), and abnormal vs. normal uIFE only tended towards significance (36 vs. 47 months, p=0.072); suggesting that monitoring with the sFLC assay is more clinically relevant than with 24hr urine after 3 cycles of therapy. Separating the population into patients with negative UPEP at cycle 3 (n=82), patients with a normal sFLC levels had longer PFS than those with abnormal concentrations (not reached vs. 34 months, p=0.015). Concordant with these results, in 78 patients with negative uIFE, an abnormal κ/λ sFLC ratio still heralded a poorer PFS (34 months vs. not reached, p<0.0001) and importantly overall survival (75% OS: 44 months vs. not reached, p=0.016). In contrast, separating the patients into those with identifiable disease by sFLC or an abnormal κ/λ sFLC ratio, the addition of the urine assessment provided no further discriminatory value. The absence of malignant plasma cells in the bone marrow has been proposed as an important end-point for clinical studies, and therefore we assessed the relationship between early monoclonal light chain removal, as determined by serum and urine assessment, and subsequent elimination of malignant plasma cells. Normalisation of κ/λ sFLC ratio after both 1 and 3 treatment cycles had 100% positive predictive value (PPV) for the prediction of MRD negativity post-consolidation, i.e. all patients whose serum FLC ratio normalised during induction went on to achieve MRD negative status post-consolidation; by contrast patients becoming urine IFE negative at cycles 1 and 3 had PPVs of 81% and 78%, respectively. Conclusions Serum FLC measurements offer improved sensitivity and better correlation with clinical outcome than urine assessments, hence providing a strong basis for recommending the former for monitoring LCMM patients. Disclosures Attal: amgen: Consultancy, Research Funding; celgene: Consultancy, Research Funding; janssen: Consultancy, Research Funding; sanofi: Consultancy. Moreau:Amgen: Honoraria; Celgene: Honoraria; Takeda: Honoraria; Janssen: Honoraria; BMS: Honoraria; Novartis: Honoraria. Avet-Loiseau:amgen: Consultancy; celgene: Consultancy; sanofi: Consultancy; janssen: Consultancy.


2021 ◽  
Vol 156 (Supplement_1) ◽  
pp. S13-S14
Author(s):  
Rebecca Treger ◽  
Kathleen Hutchinson ◽  
Andrew Bryan ◽  
Chihiro Morishima

Abstract Protein and immunofixation (IFIX) electrophoresis are used to diagnose and monitor monoclonal gammopathies. While IFIX detects clonal production of intact immunoglobulins and free light chains (FLC), the latter can also be quantified using a serum free light chain (SFLC) assay, in which polyclonal antisera detects epitopes specific for free kappa (KFLC) or lambda light chains (LFLC). An abnormal KFLC: LFLC ratio (KLR) serves as a surrogate for clonality. While the SFLC assay is highly sensitive, normal LFLC (&lt;2.63mg/dL) and KLR results (&gt;0.26 & &lt;1.65) were found in samples with distinct lambda monoclonal free light chains visualized by IFIX (X-LMFLC). To investigate this discordance, contemporaneous SFLC or KLR values were evaluated for their ability to accurately classify monoclonal FLCs identified by IFIX. We performed a retrospective analysis of serum and urine IFIX (Sebia Hydrasys) and SFLC (Freelite®, Binding Site) results from our institution between July 2010 through December 2020, using R 4.0.2 and Tidyverse packages. From among 9,594 encounters in which a single monoclonal component was initially identified by IFIX, 157 X-LMFLC and 131 X-KMFLC samples were analyzed. Elevated LFLC with normal KFLC was identified in 105/157 X-LMFLC samples (67%), while both LFLC and KFLC were elevated in 42/157 samples (27%). Concordance between X-KMFLC and KFLC was markedly higher, where 122/131 samples (93%) displayed elevated kappa FLC (&gt;1.94mg/dL) with normal LFLC, and only 7/131 X-KMFLC samples (5%) possessed both elevated KFLC and LFLC. The use of KLR to identify pathogenic monoclonal free light chains improved lambda concordance to 85%; however, 19/157 (12%) of X-LMFLC samples still exhibited normal KLR. High concordance of 98% was again observed for X-KMFLC with abnormal KLR. When samples were segregated according to normal or impaired renal function (eGFR &gt; or ≤60mL/min/1.73m², respectively), this disparate identification of X-LMFLC and X-KMFLC by the SFLC assay persisted, suggesting that renal dysfunction (as measured by eGFR) does not underlie this phenomenon. Lastly, we corroborated the above findings in a larger sample population by examining patients with urine Bence Jones FLC identified by IFIX who had free or intact monoclonal components in serum (N=724), grouped by lambda or kappa light chain involvement. The cause(s) of the discrepant performance by the Freelite® SFLC assay, relative to the Sebia Hydrasys IFIX assay, for identifying lambda FLC components is currently unclear. Possible contributory factors include assay reference range cutoffs, other patient disease parameters, and differences in assay-specific polyclonal antisera. Future analyses of these factors will help to further characterize SFLC assay performance and elucidate how interpretation of composite serum FLC test results can be improved to better guide patient management.


Author(s):  
Lauren Campbell ◽  
Dawn Simpson ◽  
Adrian Shields ◽  
Berne Ferry ◽  
Karthik Ramasamy ◽  
...  

Background The measurement of monoclonal free light chains is being increasingly utilized since the introduction of serum-based assays. It is important for laboratories to determine their own reference ranges in order to reflect the local population. The aim of this study was to determine if age-adjusted reference ranges for serum free light chains would have implications for demand management of further laboratory investigations including immunofixation. Methods After certain exclusions, 4293 samples from individuals seen in primary care across Oxfordshire between 2014 and 2016 were identified for analysis of patient characteristics, serum free light chain results and estimated glomerular filtration rate. Results We found age to be an independent variable when considering serum free light chain concentrations, ratio and estimated glomerular filtration rate. The reference ranges derived from our data differ markedly from the original Binding Site ranges. When the age-specific ranges are retrospectively applied to our population, there is a 38% decrease in follow-up testing with no loss of specificity. Conclusion We feel confident implementing new age-specific serum free light chain reference ranges in our laboratory. We have developed a simple algorithm for evaluating serum free light chains based on age and estimated glomerular filtration rate. We encourage laboratories to establish their own local reference ranges using large cohorts and their chosen serum free light chain assay platform.


Blood ◽  
2006 ◽  
Vol 108 (11) ◽  
pp. 5064-5064 ◽  
Author(s):  
Shaji Kumar ◽  
S. Vincent Rajkumar ◽  
Matthew Plevak ◽  
Robert A. Kyle ◽  
Jerry A. Katzmann ◽  
...  

Abstract Background: The measurement of monoclonal (M) protein in the serum and urine is critical for response assessment and disease evaluation in patients with multiple myeloma (MM). The serum free light chain (FLC) assay offers a new and sensitive method of assessing response to therapy. An important question that has not been adequately addressed is the correlation between 24 hour urine M protein levels and serum FLC measurements, and the extent to which response to therapy estimated using the FLC assay correlates with that assessed using the 24 hour urine M protein level. Methods: A total of 2194 sets of data, with simultaneous UPEP and serum FLC measurement, were studied. These included 752 unique patients, with individual patients having 1–23 paired assessments over time. FLC estimation was carried out using the serum FLC assay (Freelite; The Binding Site Limited, UK) performed on a Dade-Behring Nephelometer. Based on the established reference range, kappa/lambda FLC ratio &lt;0.26 or &gt;1.65 were defined as abnormal indicating the presence of monoclonal lambda and kappa FLC, respectively. The monoclonal light chain isotype was considered the involved FLC isotype, and the opposite light chain type as the uninvolved FLC type. The Urine M protein by UPEP was compared to the serum levels of the involved light chain using Spearman Rank Correlation. For comparisons in individual patients over time, those with at least 10 measurements each were studied. Results: The median involved FLC level in patients with an undetectable urine M protein was 2.3 mg/dl compared to 32.2 mg/dL among those with a detectable urine M protein (P&lt;0.001). Among the 1676 points with an abnormal FLC ratio, only 75% had an M protein detected in the urine, P &lt; 0.001. Conversely, among patients with a positive urine M-protein, 91% had an abnormal FLC ratio. When all the 2194 data points were considered together, there was a significant correlation between the urine M protein level and the FLC levels (FLC level calculated as the difference between involved and uninvolved levels), rho=0.763, P &lt; 0.001. The correlation did not change when patients with a serum creatinine of over 2.5 were excluded. The correlation between FLC levels and urinary M protein can be affected by several factors such as renal function that will differ across patients. Therefore, we examined whether the correlation between the two variables is stronger when the variations introduced by inter-patient differences in the relationship between the two variables are eliminated. In order to do this, we studied individual patients on whom multiple data points over time were available. One patient who had the maximum number of paired assessments (23 pairs) of serum FLC level and urinary M protein; the correlation between the two variables over time was highly significant, rho 0.981, p&lt;0.001. Similarly 26 other patients who had measurable urine M protein levels in whom 10 nor more paired observations over time were available, also showed significant correlations, rho, range 0.726–0.981, p&lt;0.01. Conclusion: There is a significant correlation between urine M-protein and serum free light chain across patients and the correlation is stronger in individual patients in whom the effect of inter-patient variation in other confounding factors can be eliminated. These data if confirmed in a clinical trial setting would support the use of serum FLC levels instead of urinary M protein measurements to assess response to therapy.


Blood ◽  
2007 ◽  
Vol 110 (11) ◽  
pp. 1479-1479 ◽  
Author(s):  
Roger G. Owen ◽  
J. Anthony Child ◽  
Andy C. Rawstron ◽  
Sue Bell ◽  
Kim Cocks ◽  
...  

Abstract It is becoming increasingly clear that the use of immunofixation (IF) to define complete response (CR) in MM has its limitations. Paraprotein concentration is not a direct measure of tumour bulk and maximal responses may take many months to achieve which inevitably underestimate CR rates in therapeutic schedules that contain the sequential use of different agents. The purpose of this study was to prospectively assess the applicability and value of the serum free light chain (SFLC) assay and multiparameter flow cytometry (MFC) to assess CR in the intensive pathway of the MRC Myeloma IX Trial. In this trial patients are initially randomised to induction with CVAD or CTD and patients with stable disease or better proceed to high dose melphalan (HDM) with stem cell support. There is a second randomisation to maintenance thalidomide or no further therapy. SFLC as well as standard serum and urine paraprotein assessments were performed in a central reference laboratory at the following time points: presentation, end of induction, day 100 post HDM and 3 monthly until relapse. Similarly MFC in which neoplastic plasma cells are identified and differentiated from normal plasma cells on the basis of CD19 and CD56 expression was evaluated (again in a central laboratory) at presentation, end of induction and day 100 following HDM and annually until relapse. An initial analysis of 207/1114 randomised patients was performed and the results are detailed below - End of induction Day 100 post HDM IF negative 16.3% 49.4% SFLC normal 46.1% 78.6% MFC negative 10.2% 50.7% The SFLC assay was informative in 95% of patients and provided for a more rapid assessment of response than conventional methods. A normal SFLC assay at the end of induction appeared to predict for attainment of an IF-neg CR at day 100 (70% IF-neg CR if SFLC normal vs 30% when SFLC abnormal at the end of induction). It should however be noted that 58% of patients who failed to achieve an IF-neg CR at day 100 had a normal SFLC assay. MFC provides for a direct assessment of residual neoplastic plasma cells. The assay was informative in 96.7% of patients and has a reproducible sensitivity of 0.01%. The majority of patients (89.8%) had detectable disease at the end of induction with a median of 0.7% neoplastic plasma cells (range 0.01–14%). Further cytoreduction was provided by the HDM such that 49.3% had flow detectable disease at day 100 with a median of 0.26% neoplastic plasma cells (range 0.02–8%). 30% of patients with IF-neg CR had detectable disease while 21% of patients with a persistent paraprotein had no detectable disease in their marrow. The majority of the latter patients had IgG paraproteins and it is postulated that many of these pts will ultimately achieve an IF-neg CR. We would conclude that given the kinetics of paraprotein clearance in MM it may be more appropriate to define CR on the basis of a normal SFLC assay and the absence of minimal residual disease by MFC. In this way it should be possible to more accurately define the CR rate achieved by individual components of multi-agent sequential regimens.


Blood ◽  
2012 ◽  
Vol 120 (21) ◽  
pp. 1828-1828
Author(s):  
Heinz Ludwig ◽  
Philip Young ◽  
Dejan Milosavljevic ◽  
Niklas Zojer ◽  
Wolfgang Hübl ◽  
...  

Abstract Abstract 1828 Introduction: Intact immunoglobulin or fragments thereof (intact/fragmented Ig) can be found in the urine due to nephrotic injury or the preferential scavenging of albumin by the renal FcRn receptor leading to immunoglobulin catabolism. Until now the occurrence, frequency and clinical impact of this phenomenon has not been assessed in patients with multiple myeloma (MM). Here we determine the incidence of intact/fragmented Ig in urine and evaluate its prognostic relevance. Patients and Methods: 94 patients with MM, median age 70 years old (range 41–87) with a male / female ratio 28/66, ISS stage I (48), stage II (23), stage III (28), 69 IgG (43 IgGk/26 IgGl) and 25 IgA (15 IgAk/7 IgAl) were enrolled. Serum free light chain concentrations (sFLC) were measured using commercially available immunoassays (Freelite™, The Binding Site, Birmingham, UK) and compared to electrophoresis results (Hydrasys, Sebia, Paris, France). Overall survival was estimated by the product limiting method of Kaplan-Meyer and survival was compared by the log rank test. Results: Overall, sFLC ratios had a greater sensitivity than urine immunofixation (uIFE) for the detection of monoclonal light chains 86/94 vs. 46/94. In 13/46 (28%) uIFE positive patients intact immunoglobulins or significant fragments (intact/fragmented Ig) thereof were detected, 12 IgG, (12/69, 17%) and 1 IgA (1/25, 4%). Three of these patients had normal urine protein concentrations (<250mg/L) and 2/13 patients had glomerular injury identified by increased levels of albumin excretion. There was no difference in creatinine levels between patients with or without intact/fragmented Ig (p=0.673). Analysis of overall survival in patients stratified at presentation according to uIFE results, namely the presence of intact/fragmented Ig, abnormal serum free light chain ratio-, and negative uIFE results revealed significantly shorter overall survival for the intact/fragmented Ig group (median OS: 34.5 vs. 66.0, vs. 80.6 months, respectively, p< 0.048) (figure 1). Discussion: Our findings confirm the superiority of the serum free light chain assay for detection of monoclonal free light chains as compared to urine immunofixation. However, the serum free light chain assay is inadequate for detection of intact/fragmented Ig in urine. The most important finding presented here is the observation that intact and/or fragment immunoglobulin is present in a substantial number of patients with MM. This phenomenon is mainly restricted to IgG isotypes. There are two possible explanations for these findings: first, the presence of glomerular injury, but this phenomenon (increased albumin leakage) was only seen in two patients and hence is unlikely to account for this observation. The second explanation relies upon disruption of the FcRn receptor function in immunoglobulin scavenging. This receptor will preferentially scavenge albumin in the renal setting, but dysfunction may lead to increased immunoglobulin catabolism and the presence of intact and/or fragmented Ig (Sarav, JASN, 20: 1941–1952, 2009). The results may reflect a hitherto unidentified subtle renal dysfunction. In line with this notion overall survival in our patients intact/fragmented Ig was found to be significantly shorter. Conclusion: We observed an unexpected high incidence of intact/fragmented Ig in the urine of our patients with MM. Patients with urinary excretion of intact/fragmented immunoglobulin had significantly shorter survival. These findings should be validated in further studies. Disclosures: Young: Binding Site: Employment. Harding:Binding Site: Employment.


Blood ◽  
2001 ◽  
Vol 97 (9) ◽  
pp. 2900-2902 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mark Drayson ◽  
Lian X. Tang ◽  
Roger Drew ◽  
Graham P. Mead ◽  
Hugh Carr-Smith ◽  
...  

Abstract Using sensitive, automated immunoassays, increased concentrations of either κ or λ free light chains (and abnormal κ/λ ratios) were detected in the sera of 19 of 28 patients with nonsecretory multiple myeloma. Four other patients had suppression of one or both light chains, and the remaining 5 sera had normal or raised free light-chain concentrations with substantially normal κ/λ ratios. Six of the patients with an elevated single free light chain, who were studied during follow-up, had changes in disease activity that were reflected by the changes in free light-chain concentrations. It is concluded that quantification of free light chains in serum should prove useful for the diagnosis and monitoring of many patients with nonsecretory myeloma.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document