DISCUSSION ON: LATERAL VELOCITY VARIATIONS NEAR BOREHOLES
The requirement that integrated vertical times from a continuous velocity log check to within some small percent the vertical times computed from the observed travel times of a geophone survey in the same borehole is to me unreasonable. Although we geophysicists know that there are inherent errors in the results of geophone surveys because of possible errors in weathering velocity corrections, datum velocity corrections, depth of shot corrections, and especially seismic travel‐path assumptions, we have presumed the cumulative error in all but unusual surveys to be within the limits of accuracy of reflection seismograph interpretation. The usual seismic travel path assumption, particularly in areas of high velocity stringers or velocity inversions, can be very treacherous in the computation of vertical times. Consequently, I cannot understand why some of our colleagues insist that the log results are incorrect unless they check very closely with the computed vertical shot times. Maybe the computed times are wrong!