Islam in the Temple of Reason
This chapter explores the struggle over “dechristianization” and its ways of reconceiving Islam as a historical precedent for religious revolution, as a more rational deism better aligned with revolutionary principles, or as a fanatical superstition to be eliminated. This was not simply a conflict between religion and secularism, but a struggle over what should replace religion that divided even the radical party of revolutionaries. In this struggle, Islam was not swept aside, but on the contrary drawn to the forefront in a number of ways. If atheists saw Islam alongside Christianity and Judaism as a religion to be eliminated, they nonetheless maintained the figure of the Muslim as a test case for the universal vocation of the Revolution. For deists, too, Islam—strictly monotheistic and universalist—could seem much closer to their vision of a purified religion.