Hogarth and Bad Taste: The Sculptures at St. Bartholomew’s as Satirical Inspiration
The engraving Masquerades and Operas (1724), also known as The Bad Taste of the Town, was William Hogarth’s first self-published work. Despite this milestone, it has become a footnote to more studied works such as The Rake’s Progress. I have discovered that Hogarth used sculptures from the Henry VIII Gate at St. Bartholomew’s Hospital in London on his depiction of the Great Gate of Burlington House (home to the Royal Academy of Arts); I believe this is an overlooked element of the print that signals his distaste for foreign art. Hogarth strongly opposed Italianate painting and architecture, even painting frescoes at St. Bartholomew’s gratis, after learning the commission had gone to an Italian. Through visual, political, and contextual analysis, I argue that allusions to Raphael and Michelangelo in Masquerades and Operas associate Italian art with “lameness” and “disease” and are meant to show the decadence of Italian art and its impact on the arts in England. Their position on the Henry VIII Gate further alludes to the malignancy of the aristocracy, whom Hogarth saw as adversely affecting British culture by adopting foreign influences. The Brexit vote and global political turmoil are at the forefront of today’s political situation. In this regard, it is valuable to look back at times of significant cultural change and examine why artists like Hogarth, and contrastingly, Hogarth’s nemesis William Kent (a proponent of classical architecture inspired by Italian examples), strove for and against intercultural exchange.