scholarly journals THE PSYCHOLOGICAL IMPACT OF BREAST-CONSERVING SURGERY VERSUS MASTECTOMY IN EGYPTIAN FEMALE PATIENTS

2021 ◽  
Vol 7 (4) ◽  
pp. 124-133
Author(s):  
Ahmed Abdelatif ◽  
Galal Abounaggah ◽  
Mohamed Elmesery ◽  
Mohamed Asal ◽  
Moataz Eweda

The previous research on breast cancer's psychological impact was based on its effects on shape, with breast removal, and the subsequent effect on sexual attractiveness. Several changes that affect life behavior after breast cancer surgery including insomnia, difficulty returning to usual activities and work, nightmares and loss of appetite. These manifestations may be due to depression but they are only considered abnormal if they persist after the period of physical recovery from surgery. We conducted a study to assess the effects of the surgical decision and psychological impact of this decision on Egyptian females with breast cancer. Most patients were subjected to a questionnaire including all environmental and clinical factors affecting the surgical decision either mastectomy or breast-conserving surgery. As a conclusion we can say that breast conservative surgery is better accepted psychologically by patients than modified radical mastectomy as it did not affect sexual life, cosmetic appearance, mood, self-satisfaction, and quality of life.

2021 ◽  
pp. 253-260
Author(s):  
Nita S. Nair ◽  
Prasanth Penumadu ◽  
Prabha Yadav ◽  
Nitin Sethi ◽  
Pavneet S. Kohli ◽  
...  

PURPOSE Quality of life has become an integral aspect of the management of breast cancer. Many women still need to undergo a modified radical mastectomy (MRM). Factors affecting the choice a woman makes to undergo breast reconstruction (BR) are unclear and are hypothesized to be influenced by socioeconomic factors. We conducted a survey to evaluate the awareness and acceptability of BR among women with breast cancer at our institution. METHODS A novel questionnaire was designed and served to 3 groups of women: planned for MRM, follow up (FU) post-MRM, and FU post breast-conserving surgery. RESULTS Responses were analyzed from 492 women. Of these, 280 (56.91%) were planned for MRM and 212 (43.08%) women were on FU. Almost 45% women were older than 50 years of age, and literacy rate was 87.6%. More than 70% were homemakers and 15 women (3%) were unmarried. The aspects evaluating awareness of BR suggested that 251 (51.01%) women had knowledge about BR. Major source of information was the surgeon (45.81%) and media (32.87%). About 80% women on FU post-MRM did not want reconstruction, and 55% did not opt for BR as they had coped with the mastectomy and did not feel the need for BR. Only 6% cited family or financial reasons and 10% cited recurrence concerns. Among women planned for surgery, 65.71% had not considered BR. When questioned, 25 (12.88%) felt influenced by cost, 102 (52.58%) felt they did not need it, and 20 (10.31%) were worried it would affect treatment. CONCLUSION Our study shows high awareness regarding BR, but only 27.89% women opt for BR independent of economic issues. We recommend all patients should be counseled about the reconstructive options when their MRM is planned.


2005 ◽  
Vol 94 (3) ◽  
pp. 211-215 ◽  
Author(s):  
T. Meretoja ◽  
E. Suominen

Background and Aims: The aim of this study is to evaluate the demand for plastic operations after primary breast cancer surgery. In addition, this study aims to increase knowledge on factors affecting the wish of women for breast reconstruction. Material and Methods: A questionnaire was sent to some 111 patients who had undergone either mastectomy or breast conserving surgery. The response rate was 76 %. The questionnaire consisted of 20 structured questions. The data was analysed statistically using the t test and the chi-square test. Results: 28 % of the mastectomized patients wanted a breast reconstruction. Factors found to affect the patient's wish for reconstruction were age ( p < 0.001) and whether the patient had received radio- ( p < 0.05) or chemotherapy ( p < 0.05). A difference was found between the mastectomy group and the breast conserving surgery group as to satisfaction in the general ( p < 0.05) and the cosmetic ( p < 0.05) outcome of the surgery, as well as patient's expectations regarding the outcome ( p < 0.01). Conclusions: Rather fewer mastectomized patients wanted a reconstruction. The proportion, however, grew significantly larger in the younger age groups. This study also shows that receiving radio- or chemotherapy seems to predict a woman's choice against a reconstruction. Patients who receive radio- or chemotherapy may consider their illness more severe and life-threatening than those not receiving such treatments.


2009 ◽  
Vol 27 (15_suppl) ◽  
pp. e20633-e20633
Author(s):  
M. Garip ◽  
M. Gumus ◽  
F. Dane ◽  
M. Seker ◽  
A. Bilici ◽  
...  

e20633 Background: Many prospective randomized studies have shown that modified radical mastectomy (MRM) and breast conserving surgery (BCS) are equivalent in terms of overall survival. Patients’ social and cultural features and clinicopathological characteristics of the tumors generally influence the decision of selecting surgical type. Here, we aimed to evaluate the variables that affect the type of surgical resection in our patients’ population. Methods: One hundred patients undergone breast surgery with the diagnosis of breast cancer from December 2007 to March 2008 were included in the study. After detailed history taking and physical examination, all patients were given questionnaire evaluating sociodemographical data and parameters influencing their decision in choosing type of breast surgery. Results: Overall, 100 patients (80 MRM, 20 BCS) were evaluated in this study. Age was statistically significant predictive indicator in choosing BCS (p: 0.025). Nulliparous women were more likely to select BCS than multiparous (p:0,004). Patients who have the experience of breastfeeding less likely preferred BCS (p: 0.007). Having taken second opinion from a different breast surgeon about type of surgery during evaluation made patients select more BCS (p: 0.023). Although not statistically significant patients who had family history of breast cancer had selected MRM more than BCS (p: 0.088). Marital status, life assurance, age at first birth, and education status were not associated with the decision of selecting type of surgery. Conclusions: We concluded that cosmetic concern and risk of relapse affect the decision of surgical type in breast cancer patients. Broader efforts should be made to inform our patients about the results of BCS. No significant financial relationships to disclose.


2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Anne Kuritzky ◽  
Laila Khazai ◽  
Roberto Diaz ◽  
Christine Laronga

The identification of an axillary metastasis in the absence of a primary breast cancer can pose a diagnostic and therapeutic dilemma. The clinician should first use more sensitive imaging modalities, such as breast magnetic resonance imaging, to attempt to find the primary index lesion. If the primary cancer remains occult and the molecular markers are consistent with a breast origin, then the recommended treatment includes multimodality therapy including surgery, chemotherapy/endocrine treatment, and radiation. Historically, the modified radical mastectomy was the standard of practice. Recently, in the era of improved adjuvant therapies, breast-conserving surgery with irradiation is also being considered. Multiple retrospective reviews have shown no difference in survival or recurrence with these two surgical pathways. However, due to the rare nature of this clinical presentation, no multiinstitutional or prospective clinical trial data are available.  Key words: axillary lymph node dissection, axillary metastasis, breast cancer, breast conservation, local recurrence, occult primary tumor, radiotherapy 


Author(s):  
Peter A. van Dam ◽  
Cary Kaufman ◽  
Carlos Garcia-Etienne ◽  
Marie-Jeanne Vrancken Peeters ◽  
Robert Mansel

Abstract: The role of the surgeon managing breast diseases has been the subject of continuous evolution, moving from the cancer-extirpative surgeon to a deeply informed surgical leader, who interacts in a multidisciplinary setting also encompassing tasks for risk assessment, genetic counselling, and new diagnostic approaches. Surgical removal of the tumour remains the cornerstone in treating early stage breast cancer. During the last century, breast cancer surgery became less radical, breast-conserving treatment emerged, and the role of axillary lymphadenectomy changed from a therapeutic procedure into a staging procedure with prognostic implications. Later, the sentinel node concept reduced the need for complete axillary clearance in most cases. Nowadays, thanks to breast-conserving surgery, oncoplastic techniques, and reconstructive procedures, most breast cancer patients can overcome this disease without serious permanent physical mutilation. A multidisciplinary approach, benchmarking, and quality assurance have improved outcomes markedly.


2019 ◽  
Vol 29 (3) ◽  
pp. 683-692
Author(s):  
K. V. Deepa ◽  
A. Gadgil ◽  
Jenny Löfgren ◽  
S. Mehare ◽  
Prashant Bhandarkar ◽  
...  

Abstract Purpose Breast cancer is the commonest cancer in women worldwide. Surgery is a central part of the treatment. Modified radical mastectomy (MRM) is often replaced by breast conserving therapy (BCT) in high-income countries. MRM is still the standard choice, in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) as radiotherapy, a mandatory component of BCT is not widely available. It is important to understand whether quality of life (QOL) after MRM is comparable to that after BCT. This has not been studied well in LMICs. We present, 5-year follow-up of QOL scores in breast cancer patients from India. Methods We interviewed women undergoing breast cancer surgery preoperatively, at 6 months after surgery, and at 1 year and 5 years, postoperatively. QOL scores were evaluated using FACT B questionnaire. Average QOL scores of women undergoing BCT were compared with those undergoing MRM. Total scores, domain scores and trends of scores over time were analyzed. Results We interviewed 54 women with a mean age of 53 years (SD 9 ± years). QOL scores in all the women, dipped during the treatment period, in all subscales but improved thereafter and even surpassed the baseline in physical, emotional and breast-specific domains (p < 0.05) at 5 years. At the end of 5 years, there was no statistically significant difference between the MRM and BCT groups in any of the total or domain scores. Conclusion QOL scores in Indian women did not differ significantly between MRM and BCT in the long term. Both options are acceptable in the study setting.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document