In the computer vision field, many 3D deep learning models that directly manage 3D point clouds (proposed after PointNet) have been published. Moreover, deep learning-based-techniques have demonstrated state-of-the-art performance for supervised learning tasks on 3D point cloud data, such as classification and segmentation tasks for open datasets in competitions. Furthermore, many researchers have attempted to apply these deep learning-based techniques to 3D point clouds observed by aerial laser scanners (ALSs). However, most of these studies were developed for 3D point clouds without radiometric information. In this paper, we investigate the possibility of using a deep learning method to solve the semantic segmentation task of airborne full-waveform light detection and ranging (lidar) data that consists of geometric information and radiometric waveform data. Thus, we propose a data-driven semantic segmentation model called the full-waveform network (FWNet), which handles the waveform of full-waveform lidar data without any conversion process, such as projection onto a 2D grid or calculating handcrafted features. Our FWNet is based on a PointNet-based architecture, which can extract the local and global features of each input waveform data, along with its corresponding geographical coordinates. Subsequently, the classifier consists of 1D convolutional operational layers, which predict the class vector corresponding to the input waveform from the extracted local and global features. Our trained FWNet achieved higher scores in its recall, precision, and F1 score for unseen test data—higher scores than those of previously proposed methods in full-waveform lidar data analysis domain. Specifically, our FWNet achieved a mean recall of 0.73, a mean precision of 0.81, and a mean F1 score of 0.76. We further performed an ablation study, that is assessing the effectiveness of our proposed method, of the above-mentioned metric. Moreover, we investigated the effectiveness of our PointNet based local and global feature extraction method using the visualization of the feature vector. In this way, we have shown that our network for local and global feature extraction allows training with semantic segmentation without requiring expert knowledge on full-waveform lidar data or translation into 2D images or voxels.
Comparing Machine and Deep Learning Methods for Large 3D Heritage Semantic Segmentation
