Numerical analysis of soil microstructure reveals conditions for natural attenuation in aged tar oil contaminated soil

Author(s):  
Pavel Ivanov ◽  
Karin Eusterhues ◽  
Kai Uwe Totsche

<p>Understanding of ongoing biogeochemical processes (natural attenuation) within contaminated soils is crucial for the development of plausible remediation strategies. We studied a tar oil contaminated soil with weak grass vegetation at a former manufactured gas plant site in Germany. Despite of the apparent toxicity (the soil contained up to 120 g kg<sup>-1</sup> petroleum hydrocarbons, 26 g kg<sup>-1</sup> toxic metals, and 100 mg kg<sup>-1</sup> polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons), the contaminated layers have 3-5 times as much cell counts as an uncontaminated control soil nearby. To test, if the geometry of the pore space provides favourable living space for microorganisms, we applied scanning electron microscopy to the thin sections and calculated on sets of 15 images per layer three specific Minkowski functionals, connected to soil total porosity, interface, and hydraulic parameters.</p><p>Our investigation showed that the uncontaminated control soil has a relatively low porosity of 15-20 %, of which 50-70 % is comprised of small (< 15 µm) pores. These pores are poorly connected and show high distances between them (mean distance to the next pore 10 µm). The dominating habitats in the control soil are therefore created by small pores. They provide good protection from predators and desiccation, but input of dissolved organic C and removal of metabolic products are diffusion limited. Coarser pores (>15 µm) provide less space (< 50 % of total porosity) and solid surface area (< 20 %), are prone to desiccation and offer less protection from predators. However, they serve as preferential flow paths for the soil solution (input of nutrients) and are well aerated, therefore we expect the microbial activity in them to appear in “hot moments”, i.e. after rain events.</p><p>All layers of the contaminated profile have higher porosities (20-70 %) than the control. Coarse pores comprise 83-90 % of total pore area and create 34-52 % of total interface. Pores are also more connected and tortuous than in the control soil, which implies a better aeration and circulation of soil solution. The loops of pore channels may retain soil solution and be therefore preferably populated with microorganisms. The small (< 15 µm) pores comprise less than 17 % of total porosity but represent a substantial proportion of the interface (48-66 % vs 82-91 % in control). In the uppermost layer of the contaminated profile, such pores occur in plant residues, are close to the largest pores (mean distance to the next pore 4 µm) and therefore, along with good protection, are supplied with air, water, and non-tar C. In the middle of the profile, the small pores, presumably constantly filled with water, are located within dense tar pieces remote from the neighbouring pores (mean distance to the next pore 22 µm), and therefore, with hindered aeration and no supply of non-tar C, may create anaerobic domains of tar attenuation.</p><p>Our results show that the contaminated soil offers more favourable conditions for microorganisms than the control soil, probably because the hydrocarbons provide suitable energy and nutrition sources and a beneficial pore space geometry.</p>

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pavel Ivanov ◽  
Karin Eusterhues ◽  
Thomas Ritschel ◽  
Thilo Rennert ◽  
Lisa Mahler ◽  
...  

<p>The development of effective remediation strategies for soils contaminated by aged non-aqueous phase liquids like tars requires detailed investigation of composition, microstructure and microbial communities. We studied an aged tar spill with an overgrowing grass vegetation at a former manufactured gas plant site in Germany. The soil contained 10-120 g kg<sup>-1</sup> petroleum hydrocarbons, up to 26 g kg<sup>-1</sup> potentially toxic metals, and up to 100 mg kg<sup>-1</sup> polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Although these substances are considered toxic and recalcitrant, the microbial biomass was up to twice as much in contaminated layers than in uncontaminated layers of the control soil. We assume the high content of vital elements, such as C (up to 500 g kg<sup>-1</sup>), S (5 g kg<sup>-1</sup>), P (4.8 g kg<sup>-1</sup>), Fe (65 g kg<sup>-1</sup>), and N in plant residues, compensates possible toxicity.</p><p>Investigation of the 2D soil microstructure on thin sections with digital light and scanning electron microscopy showed increased total porosity (2-3 times more than in control) and the share of coarse wide pores (> 50 µm, root channels and large cracks) in contaminated layers. Within the root channels aerobic conditions persist, with free inflow of soil solution and supply of root exudates.</p><p>Tar dominated particles between the coarse pores had small isolated pores, and the average distance to the next pore within the particles (assessed by Euclidian distance) was about 3 times higher than for the control soil. This highlights anaerobic conditions within the pores, where tar borne compounds are the source of nutrition and energy.</p><p>FTIR microspectroscopy showed oxidized tar on root coatings and near some isolated pores. Natural attenuation of the contaminant proceeds both under aerobic and anaerobic conditions.</p><p>Positive matrix factorization analysis of EDX spectra allowed us to map the spatial distribution of different components (quartz, feldspars, secondary minerals, metal-rich particles, tar and the embedding resin). We found presumably authigenic Fe minerals within small isolated pores and along root channels. Based on XANES spectroscopy and the difference between total Fe and Fe in Fe oxides (Fe<sub>DCB</sub>), they contained Fe<sup>2+</sup> and Fe<sup>3+</sup> in different proportions, which suggests Fe reduction to be an accompanying process during tar attenuation.</p><p>The 16S rRNA analysis showed similar microbial communities on the rooted rim of the spill and the control soil. The community in the centre of the spill was less diverse and remarkably different. The contaminated profiles contained specific functional groups of bacteria (e.g. Fe-reducing Geobacteraceae or N-fixing Rhizobiales). Microfluidic droplet cultivation facilitated abundant microbial growth from tar layers under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions.</p><p>We conclude that aged tar is used as a substrate by the microbial communities, especially in the presence of grass vegetation. Natural attenuation of tar occurs in hotspots under either oxic (root channels and large connected voids) and anoxic (small isolated pores) conditions and is coupled with reduction of Fe.</p>


2012 ◽  
Vol 157 (4) ◽  
pp. 460-466 ◽  
Author(s):  
Viktoriya Vasilieva ◽  
Kerstin E. Scherr ◽  
Eva Edelmann ◽  
Marion Hasinger ◽  
Andreas P. Loibner

2007 ◽  
Vol 56 (2) ◽  
pp. 182-188 ◽  
Author(s):  
Roongnapa Tongarun ◽  
Ekawan Luepromchai ◽  
Alisa S. Vangnai

2004 ◽  
Vol 50 (5) ◽  
pp. 347-353 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. Schulze ◽  
A. Tiehm

Intrinsic biodegradation, representing the key process in Natural Attenuation, was examined at a tar-oil polluted disposal site. Methods to assess microbial natural attenuation of BTEX and PAH included analysis of groundwater hydrochemistry, pollutant profiles, composition of the microflora, and microcosm studies. In the polluted groundwater downgradient the disposal site, oxygen and nitrate were only available adjacent to the groundwater table and at the plume fringes. In the anaerobic core of the plume, a sequence of predominating redox zones (methanogenic, sulphate-reducing, Fe(III)-reducing) was observed. Changing pollutant profiles in the plume indicated active biodegradation processes, e.g. biodegradation of toluene and naphthalene in the anaerobic zones. High numbers of microorganisms capable of growing under anaerobic conditions and of aerobic pollutant degrading organisms confirmed the impact of biodegradation at this site. In microcosm studies, the autochthonous microflora utilised toluene, ethylbenzene, and naphthalene under sulfate- and Fe(III)-reducing conditions. Additionally, benzene and phenanthrene were degraded in the presence of Fe(III). Under aerobic conditions, all BTEX and PAH were rapidly degraded. The microcosm studies in particular were suitable to examine the role of specific electron acceptors, and represented an important component of the multiple line of evidence concept to assess natural attenuation.


2019 ◽  
Vol 13 (3) ◽  
pp. 775-793 ◽  
Author(s):  
Carie M. Frantz ◽  
Bonnie Light ◽  
Samuel M. Farley ◽  
Shelly Carpenter ◽  
Ross Lieblappen ◽  
...  

Abstract. Field investigations of the properties of heavily melted “rotten” Arctic sea ice were carried out on shorefast and drifting ice off the coast of Utqiaġvik (formerly Barrow), Alaska, during the melt season. While no formal criteria exist to qualify when ice becomes rotten, the objective of this study was to sample melting ice at the point at which its structural and optical properties are sufficiently advanced beyond the peak of the summer season. Baseline data on the physical (temperature, salinity, density, microstructure) and optical (light scattering) properties of shorefast ice were recorded in May and June 2015. In July of both 2015 and 2017, small boats were used to access drifting rotten ice within ∼32 km of Utqiaġvik. Measurements showed that pore space increased as ice temperature increased (−8 to 0 ∘C), ice salinity decreased (10 to 0 ppt), and bulk density decreased (0.9 to 0.6 g cm−3). Changes in pore space were characterized with thin-section microphotography and X-ray micro-computed tomography in the laboratory. These analyses yielded changes in average brine inclusion number density (which decreased from 32 to 0.01 mm−3), mean pore size (which increased from 80 µm to 3 mm), and total porosity (increased from 0 % to > 45 %) and structural anisotropy (variable, with values of generally less than 0.7). Additionally, light-scattering coefficients of the ice increased from approximately 0.06 to > 0.35 cm−1 as the ice melt progressed. Together, these findings indicate that the properties of Arctic sea ice at the end of melt season are significantly distinct from those of often-studied summertime ice. If such rotten ice were to become more prevalent in a warmer Arctic with longer melt seasons, this could have implications for the exchange of fluid and heat at the ocean surface.


2007 ◽  
Vol 41 (15) ◽  
pp. 5314-5322 ◽  
Author(s):  
Anne-Kirsten Reineke ◽  
Thomas Göen ◽  
Alfred Preiss ◽  
Juliane Hollender

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document