Review comments: Developments in large-scale coastal flood hazard mapping

Author(s):  
Anonymous
Author(s):  
Michalis I. Vousdoukas ◽  
Evangelos Voukouvalas ◽  
Lorenzo Mentaschi ◽  
Francesco Dottori ◽  
Alessio Giardino ◽  
...  

Abstract. Coastal flooding related to marine extreme events has severe socio-economic impacts, and even though the latter are projected to increase under the changing climate, there is a clear deficit of information and predictive capacity related to coastal flood mapping. The present contribution reports on efforts towards a new methodology for mapping coastal flood hazard at European scale, combining (i) the contribution of waves to the total water level; (ii) improved inundation modelling; and (iii) an open, physics-based framework which can be constantly upgraded, whenever new and more accurate data become available. Four inundation approaches of gradually increasing complexity and computational costs were evaluated in terms of their applicability for large-scale coastal flooding mapping: static inundation (SM); a semi-dynamic method, considering the water volume discharge over the dykes (VD); the Flood Intensity Index approach (Iw); and the model LISFLOOD-FP (LFP). A validation test performed against observed flood extents during the Xynthia storm event showed that SM and VD can lead to an overestimation of flood extents by 232% and 209 %, while Iw and LFP showed satisfactory predictive skill. Application at pan-European scale for the present-day 100-year event confirmed that static approaches can overestimate flood extents by 56 % compared to LFP; however, Iw can deliver results of reasonable accuracy in cases when reduced computational costs are a priority. Moreover, omitting the wave contribution in the extreme TWL can result in a ~ 60 % underestimation of the flooded area. The present findings have implications for impact assessment studies, since combination of the estimated inundation maps with population exposure maps revealed differences in the estimated number of people affect within the 20–70 % range.


2016 ◽  
Vol 16 (8) ◽  
pp. 1841-1853 ◽  
Author(s):  
Michalis I. Vousdoukas ◽  
Evangelos Voukouvalas ◽  
Lorenzo Mentaschi ◽  
Francesco Dottori ◽  
Alessio Giardino ◽  
...  

Abstract. Coastal flooding related to marine extreme events has severe socioeconomic impacts, and even though the latter are projected to increase under the changing climate, there is a clear deficit of information and predictive capacity related to coastal flood mapping. The present contribution reports on efforts towards a new methodology for mapping coastal flood hazard at European scale, combining (i) the contribution of waves to the total water level; (ii) improved inundation modeling; and (iii) an open, physics-based framework which can be constantly upgraded, whenever new and more accurate data become available. Four inundation approaches of gradually increasing complexity and computational costs were evaluated in terms of their applicability to large-scale coastal flooding mapping: static inundation (SM); a semi-dynamic method, considering the water volume discharge over the dykes (VD); the flood intensity index approach (Iw); and the model LISFLOOD-FP (LFP). A validation test performed against observed flood extents during the Xynthia storm event showed that SM and VD can lead to an overestimation of flood extents by 232 and 209 %, while Iw and LFP showed satisfactory predictive skill. Application at pan-European scale for the present-day 100-year event confirmed that static approaches can overestimate flood extents by 56 % compared to LFP; however, Iw can deliver results of reasonable accuracy in cases when reduced computational costs are a priority. Moreover, omitting the wave contribution in the extreme total water level (TWL) can result in a  ∼  60 % underestimation of the flooded area. The present findings have implications for impact assessment studies, since combination of the estimated inundation maps with population exposure maps revealed differences in the estimated number of people affected within the 20–70 % range.


Water ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 13 (11) ◽  
pp. 1483
Author(s):  
Qianqian Zhou ◽  
Jiongheng Su ◽  
Karsten Arnbjerg-Nielsen ◽  
Yi Ren ◽  
Jinhua Luo ◽  
...  

Urban floods are detrimental to societies, and flood mapping techniques provide essential support for decision-making on the better management of flood risks. This study presents a GIS-based flood characterization methodology for the rapid and efficient identification of urban flood-prone areas, which is especially relevant for large-scale flood hazards and emergency assessments for data-scarce studies. The results suggested that optimal flood mapping was achieved by adopting the median values of the thresholds for local depression extraction, the topographic wetness index (TWI) and aggregation analyses. This study showed the constraints of the depression extraction and TWI methods and proposed a methodology to improve the performance. A new performance indicator was further introduced to improve the evaluation ability of hazard mapping. It was shown that the developed methodology has a much lower demand on the data and computation efforts in comparison to the traditional two-dimensional models and, meanwhile, provides relatively accurate and robust assessments of flood hazards.


2017 ◽  
Vol 7 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Ana Rueda ◽  
Sean Vitousek ◽  
Paula Camus ◽  
Antonio Tomás ◽  
Antonio Espejo ◽  
...  

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Keighobad Jafarzadegan ◽  
David Muñoz ◽  
Hamed Moftakhari ◽  
Joseph Gutenson ◽  
Guarav Savant ◽  
...  

Abstract. Deltas, estuaries, and wetlands are prone to frequent coastal flooding throughout the world. In addition, a large number of people in the United States have settled in these low-lying regions. Therefore, the ecological merit of wetlands for maintaining sustainable ecosystems highlights the importance of flood risk and hazard management in these regions. Typically, hydrodynamic models are used for coastal flood hazard mapping. The huge computational resources required for hydrodynamic modeling and the long-running time of these models (order of hours or days) are two major drawbacks that limit the application of these models for prompt decision-making by emergency responders. In the last decade, DEM-based classifiers based on Height Above Nearest Drainage (HAND) have been widely used for rapid flood hazard assessment demonstrating satisfactory performance for inland floods. The main limitation is the high sensitivity of HAND to the topography which degrades the accuracy of these methods in flat coastal regions. In addition, these methods are mostly used for a given return period and generate static hazard maps for past flood events. To cope with these two limitations, here we modify HAND and propose a composite hydrogeomorphic index for rapid flood hazard assessment in coastal areas. We also propose the development of hydrogeomorphic threshold operative curves for real-time flood hazard mapping. We select the Savannah river delta as a testbed, calibrate the proposed hydrogeomorphic index on Hurricane Matthew and validate the performance of the developed operative curves for Hurricane Irma. Validation results demonstrate that the operative curves can rapidly generate flood hazard maps with satisfactory accuracy. This indicates the high efficiency of our proposed methodology for fast and accurate estimation of hazard areas for an upcoming coastal flood event which can be beneficial for emergency responders and flood risk managers.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document