Abstract
Background: Fertilization modes may affect sperm characteristics, such as morphology, velocity, and motility. However, there is surprisingly little information on how fertilization mode affects sperm evolution because several factors (e.g. sperm competition and phylogeny) are intricately intertwined with this factor when phylogenetically distant species are compared. Here, we compared sperm characteristics between six externally and four internally fertilizing marine fishes from three different groups containing close relatives, taking into account the level of sperm competition. We also analysed the relationship between relative testis mass (as an index of sperm competition level) and sperm characteristics.Results: Sperm head morphology was significantly longer in species with internal fertilization than in those with external fertilization, suggesting that a longer head is advantageous for swimming in viscous ovarian fluid or the complex ovarian structure. In addition, sperm motility differed between external fertilizers and internal fertilizers; sperm of externally fertilizing species were only motile in seawater, and sperm of internally fertilizing species were only motile in an isotonic solution. These results suggest that sperm motility has adapted according to the fertilization mode. In contrast, total sperm length and sperm velocity did not correlate with fertilization mode, perhaps because of the different levels of sperm competition. Relative testis mass is positively correlated with sperm velocity and negatively correlated with the ratio of sperm head length/flagellum length. This finding suggests that species with high levels of sperm competition have sperm that are fast and have relatively long flagella compared to head length. These results contradict a previous assumption that the evolution of internal fertilization increases total sperm length. In addition, copulatory behaviour with internal insemination may involve a large intromittent organ, but this is not essential in fish, probably due to the avoidance of water resistance.Conclusions: We propose a new scenario of sperm evolution in which internal fertilization increases sperm head length but not total sperm length and changes sperm motility. In contrast, sperm competition affects sperm length and velocity. Our findings provide a new perspective on the evolutionary biology of sperm in fish.