A Hypothesis: Linking Phase Separation to Meiotic Sex Chromosome Inactivation and Sex-Body Formation

During meiotic prophase I, X and Y chromosomes in mammalian spermatocytes only stably pair at a small homologous region called the pseudoautosomal region (PAR). However, the rest of the sex chromosomes remain largely unsynapsed. The extensive asynapsis triggers transcriptional silencing - meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI). Along with MSCI, a special nuclear territory, sex body or XY body, forms. In the early steps of MSCI, DNA damage response (DDR) factors, such as BRCA1, ATR, and γH2AX, function as sensors and effectors of the silencing signals. Downstream canonical repressive histone modifications, including methylation, acetylation, ubiquitylation, and SUMOylation, are responsible for the transcriptional repression of the sex chromosomes. Nevertheless, mechanisms of the sex-body formation remain unclear. Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) may drive the formation of several chromatin subcompartments, such as pericentric heterochromatin, nucleoli, inactive X chromosomes. Although several proteins involved in phase separation are found in the sex bodies, when and whether these proteins exert functions in the sex-body formation and MSCI is still unknown. Here, we reviewed recent publications on the mechanisms of MSCI and LLPS, pointed out the potential link between LLPS and the formation of sex bodies, and discussed its implications for future research.

Deficiency of SYCP3-related XLR3 Disrupts the Initiation of Meiotic Sex Chromosome Inactivation in Mouse Spermatogenesis

In mammals, the X and Y chromosomes share only small regions of homology called pseudo-autosomal regions (PAR) where pairing and recombination in spermatocytes can occur. Consequently, the sex chromosomes remain largely unsynapsed during meiosis I and are sequestered in a nuclear compartment known as the XY body where they are transcriptionally silenced in a process called meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI). MSCI mirrors meiotic silencing of unpaired chromatin (MSUC), the sequestration and transcriptional repression of unpaired DNA observed widely in eukaryotes. MSCI is initiated by the assembly of the axial elements of the synaptonemal complex (SC) comprising the structural proteins SYCP2 and SYCP3 followed by the ordered recruitment of DNA Damage Response (DDR) factors to effect gene silencing. However, the precise mechanism of how unsynapsed chromatin is detected in meiocytes is poorly understood. The sex chromosomes in eutherian mammals harbor multiple clusters of SYCP3-like amplicons comprising the Xlr gene family, only a handful of which have been functionally studied. We used a shRNA-transgenic mouse model to create a deficiency in the testis-expressed multicopy Xlr3 genes to investigate their role in spermatogenesis. Here we show that knockdown of Xlr3 in mice leads to spermatogenic defects and a skewed sex ratio that can be traced to MSCI breakdown. Spermatocytes deficient in XLR3 form the XY body and the SC axial elements therein, but are compromised in their ability to recruit DDR components to the XY body.

Chromosome Integrity is Required for the Initiation of Meiotic Sex Chromosome Inactivation in Caenorhabditis elegans

During meiosis of heterogametic cells, such as XY meiocytes, sex chromosomes of many species undergo transcriptional silencing known as meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI). Silencing also occurs in aberrantly unsynapsed autosomal chromatin. The silencing of unsynapsed chromatin, is assumed to be the underline mechanism for MSCI. Initiation of MSCI is disrupted in meiocytes with sex chromosome-autosome translocations. Whether this is due to aberrant synapsis or the lack of sex chromosome integrity has never been determined. To address this, we used CRISPR to engineer Caenorhabditis elegans stable strains with broken X chromosomes that didn’t undergo translocations with autosomes. In early meiotic nuclei of these mutants, the X fragments lack silent chromatin modifications and instead the fragments are enriched with transcribing chromatin modifications. Moreover, the level of active RNA polymerase II staining on the X fragments in mutant nuclei is similar to that on autosomes, indicating active transcription on the X. Contrary to previous models, which predicted that any unsynapsed chromatin is silenced during meiosis, X fragments that did not synapse were robustly stained with RNA polymerase II and gene expression levels were high throughout the broken X. Therefore, lack of synapsis does not trigger MSCI if sex chromosome integrity is lost. Moreover, our results suggest that a unique character of the chromatin of sex chromosomes underlies their lack of meiotic silencing due to both unsynapsed chromatin and sex chromosome mechanisms when their integrity is lost.

Dynamics of Meiotic Sex Chromosome Inactivation and Pachytene Activation in Mice Spermatogenesis

During germ cell development, cells undergo a drastic switch from mitosis to meiosis to form haploid germ cells. Sequencing and computational technologies now allow studying development at the single-cell level. Here we developed a multiplexed trajectory reconstruction to create a high-resolution developmental map of spermatogonia and prophase-I spermatocytes from testes of a Dazl-GFP reporter mouse. We identified three main transitions in the meiotic prophase-I: meiotic entry, the meiotic sex chromosome inactivation (MSCI), and concomitant pachytene activation. We validated the key features of these transitions in vivo using single molecule FISH. Focusing on MSCI, we found that 34% of sex chromosomal genes are induced shortly before MSCI, that silencing time is diverse and correlates with specific gene functions. These highlight a previously underappreciated level of regulation of MSCI. Finally, we found that spermatozoal genes in pachytene are activated in a temporal pattern reflecting the future anatomic and functional order of the sperm cell. Altogether we highlighted how precise and sequential changes in gene expression regulate cellular states in meiotic prophase-I.