There are many
broad-leaved forests in Japan that were formerly managed for charcoal
production, which have been abandoned for decades. Appropriate thinning can
revitalize these forests if the cost balance of the management is positive. Two
critical elements are the construction of spur roads to facilitate mechanized
harvesting operations and management planning that considers stand properties
such as the growing stock, species, and tree size distribution. We surveyed
three abandoned former broad-leaved coppice stands; one coastal, one cool
temperate and one warm temperate. The stock in all three stands exceeded 300 m3
ha-1, two- to three-fold the official forest registry data
estimates. The dominant species in terms of tree numbers are Castanopsis sieboldii, Pieris japonica, and Quercus glauca. Medium-sized trees
involve those well suited for firewood, i.e., Quercus acuta, Quercus glauca,
Quercus serrata, etc. Each plot
contained a few large trees that potentially have a high market value, e.g., Cinnamomum camphora, Zelkova serrata, Abies firma, etc. The average income from harvested trees was
estimated to be 10200 JPY (Japanese Yen) m-3, whereas the thinning
costs would be 3200 to 5400 JPY m-3, with the additional spur road
construction costs. The management cost balance of a broad-leaved stand in a 60
year rotation was evaluated with both Net Present Value (NPV) (for interest
rates of 1, 2, 3, and 4%) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). This balance was
compared with that of a typical plantation stand of Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) and of a
fast-growing plantation stand of Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata). The estimated NPVs were largest for the
fast-growing plantation stand, second largest for the typical plantation stand,
and lowest for the broad-leaved stand with a NPV interest rate of 1 + %. However,
the IRR of the broad-leaved stand was the highest, followed by that of the
fast-growing plantation stand, while the IRR of the typical plantation stand
was the lowest. This order was the same for NPVs assuming higher interest
rates. 1 JPY=0.0086 € on
April 29, 2019.