Rational Supplier Selection Based on Two-Phase Deep Analysis considering Fuzzy QFD and Game Theory

Viewing from the perspective of a traditional manufacturing enterprise, the paper proposes a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation system model, which selects the most suitable supplier or suppliers to undertake the supply tasks and to achieve the purposes of reducing procurement costs and improving the supply quality and reliability, so as to fully meet customer demands. Based on decision-makers’ preferences and suppliers’ supply capabilities, subjective and objective weight of criteria are both developed for supplier selection with the corresponding weighting method, namely, quality function deployment (QFD) and entropy weight. Specially, the two-phase fuzzy QFD method combined with the trapezoidal fuzzy number (TFN) is creatively applied to realize the complicated conversion process. Furthermore, the game theory is employed to combine the advantages of the subjective and objective weighting method, by which the comprehensive weight can be determined. A numerical example is given to demonstrate the proposed modeling process. Through programming drawing images for comparative analysis and sensitivity analysis, study image trends, and draw conclusions, the proposed model effectively alleviates the weight deviation and has higher rationality and extensibility in supplier selection.

Enhancement of value stream mapping application process through using fuzzy DEMATEL and fuzzy QFD approaches: a case study considering economic and environmental perspectives

Purpose This paper aims to investigate an integrated approach that aims at enhancing the application process of value stream mapping (VSM) method. It also proposes an extended VSM called Economic and Environmental VSM(E-EVSM). The proposed approach highlights the improvement of economic and environmental performances. Design/methodology/approach The proposed approach has studied the integration of VSM, fuzzy decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) and fuzzy quality function deployment (QFD) to improve the economic and environmental performances of manufacturing processes. The VSM method is used for data collection and manufacturing process assessment, whereas fuzzy DEMATEL is used to analyse the current state map. Finally, fuzzy QFD is used to organize the improvement phase of VSM method. Findings The clear findings of this research prove the effectiveness of VSM method on the environmental and economic performances of manufacturing processes. In addition, the proposed approach will show the advantages of fuzzy DEMATEL and fuzzy QFD approaches in improving the application of the VSM method. Research limitations/implications The limitation of this study includes the lack of consideration of other dimensions such as social, technological and managerial. In addition, the proposed approach studied an average set of environmental and economic indicators. Originality/value The novelty of the proposed approach is proved by the development of an extended VSM method (E-EVSM). Also, the proposed approach contributes by a new methodology for analysing and improving the current state map of manufacturing processes.

Sustainability Assessment of Construction Technologies for Large Pipelines on Urban Highways: Scenario Analysis using Fuzzy QFD

Urban highways users frequently face disruptions due to construction and maintenance of buried infrastructure. In conventional open cut construction, social costs (vehicle operating and traffic delay costs) are generally high at work zone construction areas (WZCA). Municipalities also bear additional costs due to early maintenance of alternate routes, i.e., non-work zone construction area (NWZCA). Besides, work zone and non-work zone areas together experience significant potential socio-economic and environment impacts. In addition to minimal disturbance to existing socioenvironmental setting and user cost savings, trenchless construction result in agency cost savings by avoiding early maintenance at NWZCA. Past studies primarily focused on social costs associated to WZCA. In present research, a sustainability assessment framework has been developed that includes agency and user costs at both the work zone and non-work zone area. The framework evaluates various traffic detoured scenarios (for open cut construction) and trenchless technology scenario based on all three dimensions of sustainability. Fuzzy Quality Function Deployment (Fuzzy QFD) method has been used to incorporate the interaction between the agency’s sustainability objectives and public expectations for large-sized pipeline construction projects in urban areas. The framework effectively handles the uncertainties associated to data limitations and vagueness in expert opinion for subjective assessment criteria. To evaluate the pragmatism of proposed framework, it was applied on the case of a storm sewer construction project in Qassim Region, Saudi Arabia. Trenchless technology was found to be the most sustainable construction scenario followed by the open cut scenario with 50% traffic detoured to NWCA. The proposed methodology is also sought to enhance decision making process pertaining to the viability of trenchless technologies in KSA and elsewhere.