Abstract
BackgroundHealthy Options (HO) is a psychosocial support group intervention facilitated by community-based health workers (CBHWs) to treat depression in perinatal women living with HIV in Tanzania. The objective of this study was to determine incremental cost-effectiveness of HO in treating perinatal depression in HIV positive women in comparison to enhanced standard of mental health care delivered by nurse midwives.MethodsThis study is a cost-effectiveness analysis of HO, a pair-matched cluster-randomized controlled trial conducted in Tanzania. The primary outcome for this study was the level of depressive symptoms. Secondary outcomes included antiretroviral therapy adherence, safe disclosure of HIV status to partner, and food security, among others. This study applied an ingredients approach to cost all resources used in the HO intervention. We estimated total cost, unit cost and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio from a health care provider perspective. We used 3 year time horizon, univariate sensitivity analysis, and adjusted costs to 2017 value.ResultsHO demonstrated effectiveness in reducing depressive symptoms among pregnant women with HIV in Tanzania. Mean reduction in depressive symptoms was observed at 6 weeks and 9 months postpartum with statistical significance. HO costs $849 USD per woman treated (equivalent to $889 in 2017 value). Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio at 6 weeks postpartum is $81,091 per mean decrease in depressive symptoms (equivalent to $84,878 in 2017 value), and at 9 months postpartum is $280,277 per mean decrease in depressive symptoms (equivalent to $293,363 in 2017 value). With sensitivity analysis, results at 6 weeks postpartum ranged from $79,309 to $84,576 (equivalent to $83,012 to $88,525 in 2017 value), and at 9 months ranged from $ 194,001 to $1,139,546 (equivalent to $203,067 to $1,192,753 in 2017 value).ConclusionsBenefits of HO are significantly sustained through 9 months postpartum and intervention unit costs are within range of similar interventions. Human resources composed the largest share of HO total cost. Although uncertainty in the cost-effectiveness ratio of this intervention varied widely, since mental health specialists are scarce in Tanzania, working with CBHWs is likely to offer effective treatment that is more feasible and is a less costly alternative to the usual care.Trial registration: The trial is registered at Clinicaltrials.gov (NCT02039973).