The HOD Hypothesis and a supercompact cardinal

Author(s):  
Yong Cheng
1999 ◽  
Vol 64 (4) ◽  
pp. 1675-1688
Author(s):  
Arthur W. Apter

AbstractWe extend earlier work (both individual and joint with Shelah) and prove three theorems about the class of measurable limits of compact cardinals, where a compact cardinal is one which is either strongly compact or supercompact. In particular, we construct two models in which every measurable limit of compact cardinals below the least supercompact limit of supercompact cardinals possesses non-trivial degrees of supercompactness. In one of these models, every measurable limit of compact cardinals is a limit of supercompact cardinals and also a limit of strongly compact cardinals having no non-trivial degree of supercompactness. We also show that it is consistent for the least supercompact cardinal κ to be a limit of strongly compact cardinals and be so that every measurable limit of compact cardinals below κ has a non-trivial degree of supercompactness. In this model, the only compact cardinals below κ with a non-trivial degree of supercompactness are the measurable limits of compact cardinals.


2021 ◽  
Vol 27 (2) ◽  
pp. 221-222
Author(s):  
Alejandro Poveda

AbstractThe dissertation under comment is a contribution to the area of Set Theory concerned with the interactions between the method of Forcing and the so-called Large Cardinal axioms.The dissertation is divided into two thematic blocks. In Block I we analyze the large-cardinal hierarchy between the first supercompact cardinal and Vopěnka’s Principle (Part I). In turn, Block II is devoted to the investigation of some problems arising from Singular Cardinal Combinatorics (Part II and Part III).We commence Part I by investigating the Identity Crisis phenomenon in the region comprised between the first supercompact cardinal and Vopěnka’s Principle. As a result, we generalize Magidor’s classical theorems [2] to this higher region of the large-cardinal hierarchy. Also, our analysis allows to settle all the questions that were left open in [1]. Finally, we conclude Part I by presenting a general theory of preservation of $C^{(n)}$ -extendible cardinals under class forcing iterations. From this analysis we derive several applications. For instance, our arguments are used to show that an extendible cardinal is consistent with “ $(\lambda ^{+\omega })^{\mathrm {HOD}}<\lambda ^+$ , for every regular cardinal $\lambda $ .” In particular, if Woodin’s HOD Conjecture holds, and therefore it is provable in ZFC + “There exists an extendible cardinal” that above the first extendible cardinal every singular cardinal $\lambda $ is singular in HOD and $(\lambda ^+)^{\textrm {{HOD}}}=\lambda ^+$ , there may still be no agreement at all between V and HOD about successors of regular cardinals.In Part II and Part III we analyse the relationship between the Singular Cardinal Hypothesis (SCH) with other relevant combinatorial principles at the level of successors of singular cardinals. Two of these are the Tree Property and the Reflection of Stationary sets, which are central in Infinite Combinatorics.Specifically, Part II is devoted to prove the consistency of the Tree Property at both $\kappa ^+$ and $\kappa ^{++}$ , whenever $\kappa $ is a strong limit singular cardinal witnessing an arbitrary failure of the SCH. This generalizes the main result of [3] in two senses: it allows arbitrary cofinalities for $\kappa $ and arbitrary failures for the SCH.In the last part of the dissertation (Part III) we introduce the notion of $\Sigma $ -Prikry forcing. This new concept allows an abstract and uniform approach to the theory of Prikry-type forcings and encompasses several classical examples of Prikry-type forcing notions, such as the classical Prikry forcing, the Gitik-Sharon poset, or the Extender Based Prikry forcing, among many others.Our motivation in this part of the dissertation is to prove an iteration theorem at the level of the successor of a singular cardinal. Specifically, we aim for a theorem asserting that every $\kappa ^{++}$ -length iteration with support of size $\leq \kappa $ has the $\kappa ^{++}$ -cc, provided the iterates belong to a relevant class of $\kappa ^{++}$ -cc forcings. While there are a myriad of works on this vein for regular cardinals, this contrasts with the dearth of investigations in the parallel context of singular cardinals. Our main contribution is the proof that such a result is available whenever the class of forcings under consideration is the family of $\Sigma $ -Prikry forcings. Finally, and as an application, we prove that it is consistent—modulo large cardinals—the existence of a strong limit cardinal $\kappa $ with countable cofinality such that $\mathrm {SCH}_\kappa $ fails and every finite family of stationary subsets of $\kappa ^+$ reflects simultaneously.


1986 ◽  
Vol 51 (3) ◽  
pp. 648-662 ◽  
Author(s):  
Moti Gitik

Namba [N] proved that the nonstationary ideal over a measurable (NSκ) cannot be κ+-saturated. Baumgartner, Taylor and Wagon [BTW] asked if it is possible for NSκ to be precipitous over a measurable κ. A model with this property was constructed by the author, and shortly after Foreman, Magidor and Shelah [FMS] proved a general theorem that after collapsing of a supercompact or even a superstrong to the successor of κ, NSκ became precipitous. This theorem implies that it is possible to have the nonstationary ideal precipitous over even a supercompact cardinal. Just start with a supercompact κ and a superstrong λ > κ. Make supercompactness of κ indistractible as in [L] and then collapse λ to be κ+.The aim of our paper is to show that the existence of a supercompact cardinal alone already implies the consistency of the nonstationary ideal precipitous over a supercompact. The proof gives also the following: if κ is a λ-supercompact for λ ≥ (2κ)+, then there exists a generic extension in which κ is λ-supercompact and NSκ is precipitous. Thus, for a model with NSκ precipitous over a measurable we need a (2κ)+-supercompact cardinal κ. Jech [J] proved that the precipitous of NSκ over a measurable κ implies the existence of an inner model with o(κ) = κ+ + 1. In §3 we improve this result a little by showing that the above assumption implies an inner model with a repeat point.The paper is organized as follows. In §1 some preliminary facts are proved. The model with NSκ precipitous over a supercompact is constructed in §2.


1985 ◽  
Vol 50 (4) ◽  
pp. 881-894 ◽  
Author(s):  
Moti Gitik

AbstractAssuming the existence of a supercompact cardinal, we construct a model of ZFC + (There exists a nonsplitting stationary subset of ). Answering a question of Uri Abraham [A], [A-S], we prove that adding a real to the world always makes stationary


2018 ◽  
Vol 83 (1) ◽  
pp. 1-12 ◽  
Author(s):  
MAXWELL LEVINE

AbstractWe assume the existence of a supercompact cardinal and produce a model with weak square but no very good scale at a particular cardinal. This follows work of Cummings, Foreman, and Magidor, but uses a different approach. We produce another model, starting from countably many supercompact cardinals, where □K,<K holds but □K, λ fails for λ < K.


2010 ◽  
Vol 10 (01n02) ◽  
pp. 101-339 ◽  
Author(s):  
W. HUGH WOODIN

We investigate both iteration hypotheses and extender models at the level of one supercompact cardinal. The HOD Conjecture is introduced and shown to be a key conjecture both for the Inner Model Program and for understanding the limits of the large cardinal hierarchy. We show that if the HOD Conjecture is true then this provides strong evidence for the existence of an ultimate version of Gödel's constructible universe L. Whether or not this "ultimate" L exists is now arguably the central issue for the Inner Model Program.


1992 ◽  
Vol 57 (2) ◽  
pp. 461-465
Author(s):  
Julius B. Barbanel

AbstractSuppose that U and U′ are normal ultrafilters associated with some supercompact cardinal. How may we compare U and U′? In what ways are they similar, and in what ways are they different? Partial answers are given in [1], [2], [3], [5], [6], and [7]. In this paper, we continue this study.In [6], Menas introduced a combinatorial principle χ(U) of normal ultrafilters U associated with supercompact cardinals, and showed that normal ultrafilters satisfying this property also satisfy a partition property. In [5], Kunen and Pelletier showed that this partition property for U does not imply χ(U). Using results from [3], we present a different method of finding such normal ultrafilters which satisfy the partition property but do not satisfy χ(U). Our method yields a large collection of such normal ultrafilters.


1990 ◽  
Vol 55 (2) ◽  
pp. 492-501 ◽  
Author(s):  
Arthur W. Apter

Before the remarkable theorem of Martin and Steel [6] showing that the existence of a supercompact cardinal κ implies L[R] ⊨ ZF + AD + DC, and the later theorem of Woodin [9] showing that Con(ZFC + There exists an ω sequence of Woodin cardinals) ⇔ Con(ZF + AD + DC), much set-theoretic research was focused upon showing that the consistency of fragments of AD + DC followed from more “reasonable” hypotheses such as versions of supercompactness. A good example of this is provided by the results of [1], in which the following theorems are proven.


2013 ◽  
Vol 56 (2) ◽  
pp. 317-325
Author(s):  
François G. Dorais

AbstractIn 1968, Galvin conjectured that an uncountable poset P is the union of countably many chains if and only if this is true for every subposet Q ⊆ P with size ℵ1. In 1981, Rado formulated a similar conjecture that an uncountable interval graph G is countably chromatic if and only if this is true for every induced subgraph H ⊆ G with size ℵ1. Todorčević has shown that Rado's conjecture is consistent relative to the existence of a supercompact cardinal, while the consistency of Galvin's conjecture remains open. In this paper, we survey and collect a variety of results related to these two conjectures. We also show that the extension of Rado's conjecture to the class of all chordal graphs is relatively consistent with the existence of a supercompact cardinal.


1987 ◽  
Vol 52 (1) ◽  
pp. 149-151
Author(s):  
J. M. Henle

This paper concerns ultrafilters on a cardinal γ extending the filter of λ-closed, unbounded sets, λ < γ. The history of these ultrafilters is closely connected with that of the axiom of determinacy (AD). Solovay noticed first that, under AD, there was such an ultrafilter for γ = ℵ1; λ = ω. Later, Kleinberg found that the existence of such ultrafilters followed from the partition relation γ → (γ)λ+λ. Specific instances of this and more powerful relations on cardinals were then proved from AD by Martin, Kunen, Paris, and others. The axiom of determinacy was recently shown consistent with ZF relative to something less than a supercompact cardinal by Martin and Steel. Solovay's and Kleinberg's results were actually stronger, and we discuss this at the end of the paper. Good references for these results include [K2] and [KM].We are interested here in the case where γ is the ultrapower of a strong partition cardinal κ (a cardinal satisfying for all α < κ). Such cardinals exist in great abundance assuming AD, and in fact, if sufficiently many cardinals are strong, then AD holds in L[R] [KKMW].


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document