Expert, Novice, and Intermediate Performance: Exploring the Relationship Between Clinical Reasoning Behaviors and Diagnostic Performance

Author(s):  
Alejandra Ruiz-Segura ◽  
Susanne P. Lajoie
1988 ◽  
Vol 34 (7) ◽  
pp. 1464-1467 ◽  
Author(s):  
T J Wilke ◽  
D J Utley

Abstract We examined the relationship between analytical sensitivity, precision at the lower limit of the reference interval, and diagnostic performance in hyperthyroidism for one radioimmunoassay and five immunometric assay kits for thyrotropin. The analytical sensitivity of these kits extended from 0.05 to 1.56 milli-int. units/L. Diagnostic efficiencies of the immunometric assays, in discriminating between euthyroidism and hyperthyroidism, ranged between 93% and 98%. There was a highly significant correlation (r = 0.99, P less than 0.001) between analytical sensitivity and diagnostic efficiency. The between-assay coefficients of variations, at the lower limit of the reference interval, ranged from 26% to 87%. There was no correlation (r = 0.36) between precision, at this concentration, and diagnostic efficiency. We conclude that analytical sensitivity and not precision is the major determinant in controlling the diagnostic performance of a thyrotropin assay in hyperthyroidism.


Author(s):  
Allison Sauerwein ◽  
Jane Wegner

Clinical reasoning skills underlie the decisions speech-language pathologists (SLPs) make during practice. Although clinical reasoning is included in speech-language pathology accreditation standards in the United States, there is limited research on preservice SLPs’ development or use of clinical reasoning skills. Because clinical reasoning skills specific to augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) service provision have not been identified or reported in depth, this qualitative study focused on two cases of children with developmental disabilities who used AAC systems. Eight novice (i.e. preservice) SLPs and eight expert SLPs completed think-aloud tasks while they developed intervention plans, which made their clinical reasoning skills observable. Responses were transcribed for qualitative analysis. Six clinical reasoning skills were identified: summarizing, interpreting, hypothesizing, rationalizing, comparing and deferring. Expert and novices used four of these clinical reasoning skills similarly; however, there were differences among the remaining two skills. Novices deferred more frequently during the tasks and were limited in their ability to make comparisons to the fictional cases as compared to the experts. The expert-novice gap in clinical reasoning presents implications for teaching preservice SLPs in the classroom and the clinic.


Author(s):  
Thiani Pillay ◽  
Mershen Pillay

Background: This study explored the available literature on the phenomenon of clinical reasoning and described its influence on the clinical swallow evaluation. By exploring the relationship between clinical reasoning and the clinical swallow evaluation, it is possible to modernise the approach to dysphagia assessment.Objectives: This study aimed to contextualise the available literature on clinical reasoning and the CSE to low-middle income contexts through the use of a scoping review and expert consultation.Method: A scoping review was performed based on the PRISMA-ScR framework. The data was analysed using thematic analysis. Articles were considered if they discussed the clinical swallow evaluation and clinical reasoning, and were published in the last 49 years.Results: Through rigorous electronic and manual searching, 12 articles were identified. This review made an argument for the value of clinical reasoning within the clinical swallow evaluation. The results of the study revealed three core themes related to the acquisition, variability and positive impact of clinical reasoning in the clinical swallow evaluation.Conclusion: The results of this review showed that the clinical swallow evaluation is a complex process with significant levels of variability usually linked to the impact of context. This demonstrates that in order to deliver effective and relevant services, despite challenging conditions, healthcare practitioners must depend on clinical reasoning to make appropriate modifications to the assessment process that considers these salient factors.


2020 ◽  
Vol 41 (Supplement_1) ◽  
Author(s):  
L Lewis ◽  
S D Raudsepp ◽  
T G Yandle ◽  
C M Frampton ◽  
A M Richards ◽  
...  

Abstract Funding Acknowledgements The National Heart Foundation of New Zealand Background Heart failure (HF) is a leading cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Plasma levels of B-type natriuretic peptide (BNP) or its amino terminal congener (NT-proBNP) are used for HF diagnosis and risk stratification.  Circulating levels of both BNP and NT-proBNP are reduced by obesity and this phenomenon is one of the key weaknesses of the diagnostic performance of the natriuretic peptides in HF.  Formation of BNP from enzymatic cleavage of proBNP1-108 between residues 76 and 77 by corin and/or furin is influenced by the degree of proBNP glycosylation, therefore we investigated the relationship between proBNP glycosylation, plasma NT-proBNP and body mass index (BMI) in HF patients. Methods Three assays were developed to distinguish between total proBNP (glycosylated plus non-glycosylated proBNP), proBNP not glycosylated at threonine 71 (NG-T71) and proBNP not glycosylated in the central region (NG-C). Intra and inter-assay CVs were <15%, limits of detection were <2 pmol/L and samples diluted in parallel. Results Applying these assays and an NT-proBNP assay to plasma samples from 106 healthy volunteers and 238 patients with HF determined that concentrations (median(IQR)) of proBNP, NG-T71 and NT-proBNP were greater in HF patients compared to controls (24.9 (3.6-55), 9.4 (1.5-21) and 212 (104-409) pmol/L vs 3.0 (1.5-19), 3.0 (1.5-14.5) and 4.7 (2-8) pmol/L respectively, all p < 0.012).  NG-C was undetectable in most samples. ProBNP levels in HF patients with BMI above and below 30 kg/m2 were not different (21.9 (2.6-70) pmol/L and 25.7 (3.9-53) pmol/L respectively, p = 0.85), whereas HF patients with BMI > 30 had lower NT-proBNP and NG-T71 levels (121 (64-248) and 3 (1.5-16) pmol/L verse 271 (178-486) and 13.5 (1.5-24.2) pmol/L respectively, p < 0.003) and higher proBNP:NT-proBNP and proBNP:NG-T71 ratios  (p = 0.001 and p = 0.02 respectively) than those with BMI < 30. Discussion and Conclusion Using three new assays specific for different glycosylated forms of proBNP we have shown that the processing of proBNP is dysregulated in heart failure compared to controls due to increased glycosylation at threonine 71 of proBNP.  Obese patients with HF have even greater dysregulation, demonstrated by decreased concentrations of proBNP that is not glycosylated at T71 (NG-T71), and concomitant decreases in NT-proBNP.  Thus, we have shown for the first time that increased BMI is associated with increased proBNP glycosylation at T71 in patients with heart failure.  Glycosylation-induced impairment of proBNP processing explains, at least in part, the reduction in plasma concentrations of B-type cardiac natriuretic peptides observed in obesity. Using these assays to evaluate the proBNP profile of larger patient cohorts will further develop understanding of the relationships between BNP production, BMI and heart failure pathogenesis, which would be expected to lead to increased diagnostic performance.


2021 ◽  
pp. 016173462110296
Author(s):  
Rebeca Mirón Mombiela ◽  
Jelena Vucetic ◽  
Paloma Monllor ◽  
Jenny S. Cárdenas-Herrán ◽  
Paloma Taltavull de La Paz ◽  
...  

To determine the relationship between muscle echo intensity (EI) and fractal dimension (FD), and the diagnostic performance of both ultrasound parameters for the identification of frailty phenotype. A retrospective interpretation of ultrasound scans from a previous cohort (November 2014–February 2015) was performed. The sample included healthy participants <60 years old, and participants ≥60 divided into robust, pre-frail, and frail groups according to Fried frailty criteria. A region of interest of the rectus femoris from the ultrasound scan was segmented, and histogram function was applied to obtain EI. For fractal analysis, images were processed using two-dimensional box-counting techniques to calculate FD. Statistical analyses were performed with diagnostic performance tests. A total of 102 participants (mean age 63 ± 16, 57 men) were evaluated. Muscle fractal dimension correlated with EI ( r = .38, p < .01) and showed different pattern in the scatter plots when participants were grouped by non-frail (control + robust) and frail (pre-frail + frail). The diagnostic accuracy for EI to categorize frailty was of 0.69 (95%CI: 0.59–0.78, p = .001), with high intra-rater (ICC: 0.98, 95%CI: 0.98–0.99); p < .001) and inter-rater (ICC: 0.89, 95%CI: 0.75–0.95; p < .001) reliability and low measurement error for both parameters (EI: −0.18, LOA95%: −10.8 to 10.5; FD: 0.00, LOA95%: −0.09 to 0.10) in arbitrary units. The ROC curve combining both parameters was not better than EI alone ( p = .18). Muscle FD correlated with EI and showed different patterns according to frailty phenotype, with EI outperforming FD as a possible diagnostic tool for frailty.


MedEdPublish ◽  
2022 ◽  
Vol 12 ◽  
pp. 1
Author(s):  
Michael Berge ◽  
Michael Soh ◽  
Fahlsing Christopher ◽  
Rene McKinnon ◽  
Berish Wetstein ◽  
...  

Background: This study sought to explore the relationship between semantic competence (or dyscompetence) displayed during “think-alouds” performed by resident and attending physicians and clinical reasoning performance. Methods: Internal medicine resident physicians and practicing internists participated in think-alouds performed after watching videos of typical presentations of common diseases in internal medicine. The think-alouds were evaluated for the presence of semantic competence and dyscompetence and these results were correlated with clinical reasoning performance.  Results: We found that the length of think-aloud was negatively correlated with clinical reasoning performance. Beyond this finding, however, we did not find any other significant correlations between semantic competence or dyscompetence and clinical reasoning performance. Conclusions: While this study did not produce the previously hypothesized findings of correlation between semantic competence and clinical reasoning performance, we discuss the possible implications and areas of future study regarding the relationship between semantic competency and clinical reasoning performance.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document