Development of an Application for the Automatic Evaluation of the Quality of 3D CAD Models

Author(s):  
Inmaculada Pou Schmidt ◽  
Alejandro Rodríguez Ortega ◽  
Francisco Albert Gil ◽  
Nuria Aleixos Borrás
Author(s):  
Jorge Dorribo-Camba ◽  
Gerardo Alducin-Quintero ◽  
Pascual Perona ◽  
Manuel Contero

The long term goals of this research are to study the effectiveness of CAD 3D annotation techniques to support the explicit communication of design intent and rationale, and to analyze the impact of the annotations in the alteration and reutilization of 3D models in a product design context. Towards these goals, we are initially examining the formal annotation practices defined by model-based standards such as ASME Y14.41-2012 and ISO 16792:2006, and their implementation in current CAD systems. This paper presents a prototype implementation of a module to automatically extract textual information from annotated 3D CAD models. Automated extraction of data annotation can be used to analyze both the content and the quality of the annotations with the purpose of determining what makes annotations effective and ultimately communicating design intent. The architecture of a system designed to manage and manipulate this information is also described and analyzed.


Author(s):  
Manuel Contero ◽  
Ferran Naya ◽  
David Pérez-López ◽  
Pedro Company ◽  
Jorge D. Camba

Design reusability largely depends on the parametric quality of its associated digital product data. In this regard, the quality of the master model (typically a history-based parametric model) is crucial. However, no quantitative metrics exist that can provide an accurate assessment of parametric complexity and model reusability. In this paper, a set of 370 parametric 3D CAD models of various geometric complexities were analyzed to assess their robustness when undergoing alteration. Three indicators for estimating the modification ability of the model are proposed: Ratio for Exhaustive Modification, Ratio for Selective Exhaustive Modification, and Ratio for Weighted Exhaustive Modification. Correlations between these indicators as well as other geometric complexity metrics are studied. The geometric complexity metrics considered in our study include number of faces, surface area to volume ratio, sphericity, and convexity. Our experimental results with the proposed indicators provide new insights on the quantitative assessment of parametric complexity and support their use as reliable indicators of CAD model reusability.


2020 ◽  
Vol 65 (1) ◽  
pp. 181-205
Author(s):  
Hye-Yeon Chung

AbstractHuman evaluation (HE) of translation is generally considered to be valid, but it requires a lot of effort. Automatic evaluation (AE) which assesses the quality of machine translations can be done easily, but it still requires validation. This study addresses the questions of whether and how AE can be used for human translations. For this purpose AE formulas and HE criteria were compared to each other in order to examine the validity of AE. In the empirical part of the study, 120 translations were evaluated by professional translators as well as by two representative AE-systems, BLEU/ METEOR, respectively. The correlations between AE and HE were relatively high at 0.849** (BLEU) and 0.862** (METEOR) in the overall analysis, but in the ratings of the individual texts, AE and ME exhibited a substantial difference. The AE-ME correlations were often below 0.3 or even in the negative range. Ultimately, the results indicate that neither METEOR nor BLEU can be used to assess human translation at this stage. But this paper suggests three possibilities to apply AE to compromise the weakness of HE.


2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (4) ◽  
pp. 145
Author(s):  
Nenad Bojcetic ◽  
Filip Valjak ◽  
Dragan Zezelj ◽  
Tomislav Martinec

The article describes an attempt to address the automatized evaluation of student three-dimensional (3D) computer-aided design (CAD) models. The driving idea was conceptualized under the restraints of the COVID pandemic, driven by the problem of evaluating a large number of student 3D CAD models. The described computer solution can be implemented using any CAD computer application that supports customization. Test cases showed that the proposed solution was valid and could be used to evaluate many students’ 3D CAD models. The computer solution can also be used to help students to better understand how to create a 3D CAD model, thereby complying with the requirements of particular teachers.


Author(s):  
Koichi Tsumori ◽  
Yoshizumi Fukuhara ◽  
Hiroyuki Terunuma ◽  
Koji Yamamoto ◽  
Satoshi Momiyama

A new inspection standard that enhanced quality of operating /maintenance management of the nuclear power plant was introduced in 2009. After the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster (Mar. 11th 2011), the situation surrounding the nuclear industry has dramatically changed, and the requirement for maintenance management of nuclear power plants is pushed for more stringent nuclear safety regulations. The new inspection standard requires enhancing equipment maintenance. It is necessary to enhance maintenance of not only equipment but also piping and pipe support. In this paper, we built the methodology for enhancing maintenance plan by rationalizing and visualizing of piping and pipe support based on the “Maintenance Program” in cooperating with 3D-CAD system.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Weijuan Cao ◽  
Trevor Robinson ◽  
Hua Yang ◽  
Flavien Boussuge ◽  
Andrew Colligan ◽  
...  

2021 ◽  
Vol 16 (11) ◽  
pp. C11013
Author(s):  
J.M. Santos ◽  
E. Ricardo ◽  
F.J. da Silva ◽  
T. Ribeiro ◽  
S. Heuraux ◽  
...  

Abstract The use of advanced simulation has become increasingly more important in the planning, design, and assessment phases of future fusion plasma diagnostics, and in the interpretation of experimental data from existing ones. The design cycle of complex reflectometry systems, such as the ones being planned for next generation machines (IDTT and DEMO), relies heavily on the results produced by synthetic diagnostics, used for system performance evaluation and prediction, both crucial in the design process decision making. These synthetic diagnostics need realistic representations of all system components to incorporate the main effects that shape their behavior. Some of the most important elements that are required to be well modelled and integrated in simulations are the wave launcher structures, such as the waveguides, tapers, and antennas, as well as the vessel wall structures and access to the plasma. The latter are of paramount importance and are often neglected in this type of studies. Faithfully modelling them is not an easy task, especially in 3D simulations. The procedure herein proposed consists in using CAD models of a given machine, together with parameterizable models of the launcher, to produce a description suited for Finite Difference Time Domain (FDTD) 3D simulation, combining the capabilities of real-world CAD design with the power of simulation. However, CAD model geometric descriptions are incompatible with the ones used by standard FDTD codes. CAD software usually outputs models in a tessellated mesh while FDTD simulators use Volumetric Pixel (VOXEL) descriptions. To solve this interface problem, we implemented a pipeline to automatically convert complex CAD models of tokamak vessel components and wave launcher structures to the VOXEL input required by REFMUL3, a full wave 3D Maxwell FDTD parallel code. To illustrate the full procedure, a complex reflectometry synthetic diagnostic for IDTT was setup, converted and simulated. This setup includes 3 antennas recessed into the vessel wall, for thermal protection, one for transmission and reception, and two just for reception.


Author(s):  
Meisha Rosenberg ◽  
Judy M. Vance

Successful collaborative design requires in-depth communication between experts from different disciplines. Many design decisions are made based on a shared mental model and understanding of key features and functions before the first prototype is built. Large-Scale Immersive Computing Environments (LSICEs) provide the opportunity for teams of experts to view and interact with 3D CAD models using natural human motions to explore potential design configurations. This paper presents the results of a class exercise where student design teams used an LSICE to examine their design ideas and make decisions during the design process. The goal of this research is to gain an understanding of (1) whether the decisions made by the students are improved by full-scale visualizations of their designs in LSICEs, (2) how the use of LSICEs affect the communication of students with collaborators and clients, and (3) how the interaction methods provided in LSICEs affect the design process. The results of this research indicate that the use of LSICEs improves communication among design team members.


Author(s):  
Sagar Chowdhury ◽  
Zahed Siddique

With the advancements of 3D modeling software, the use of CAD in design has become a standard practice. In recent years development in computer hardware and improvements in user friendliness of the CAD software has allowed designers to quickly and easily modify the CAD models. This modification capability allows CAD to be an integral part of the design process. Due to the increase in global competition, companies have become increasingly interested in fast and efficient design processes. One way to achieve improved efficiency is through better collaboration among designers working in common or similar projects and disciplines. A large design problem often requires specialized knowledge from several fields. Collaboration among the designers from these fields will ensure efficient design. Interaction among the designers can prevent redesign of similar components/subsystems, which requires the ability to share their designs. With the increase of collaboration, designers can now get access to large databases of 3D CAD models. But the challenge lies in search capabilities to identify common models from a large database. These considerations suggest that in the near future a challenge in 3D CAD industry will be how to find models of similar components and products. This paper presents an approach and its implementation to measure the similarity among a number of CAD models. The approach is based on the extraction and organization of information from the CAD models, which is followed by the suitable selection of commonality index and calculation of the commonality among a set of CAD models. A set of Vacuum cleaners are modeled and then compared to demonstrate the application of the approach.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document