OP101 Do We Need To Extend Health Technology Assessment To Health Enhancement Assessment?

2017 ◽  
Vol 33 (S1) ◽  
pp. 46-46
Author(s):  
Bjørn Hofmann
Keyword(s):  
Health Care ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Cognitive Abilities ◽  
Literature Search ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Health And Wellbeing ◽  
Wide Range

INTRODUCTION:Several health technologies used for therapy can also be used for health enhancement. Drugs stimulating cognitive abilities are but one example. Health Technology Assessment (HTA) has not been developed for assessing enhancements. This raises the question of how HTA should address the blurred distinction between therapy and enhancement. Should we (i) carve out a distinction between therapy and enhancement and limit HTA to therapy, (ii) use HTA for both therapy and enhancement (with some modifications), or (iii) should we develop a separate health enhancement assessment (HEA)?METHODS:A literature search of the medical, philosophical, and bioethical literature was conducted for debates, arguments, and suggested solutions to the issue of therapy versus enhancement.RESULTS:The same improvement in health may be therapeutic in one patient, but an enhancement in another. Moreover, both therapy and enhancement share the same goal: increased health and wellbeing. A wide range of arguments try to establish a difference between therapy and enhancement. They refer to naturalness, rehabilitation, normality, species-typical functioning/potential, disease, sustainability, and responsibility. On closer scrutiny few of these arguments do the job in bolstering the therapy-enhancement distinction. We already use a wide range of means to extend human abilities. Moreover, the therapy-enhancement distinction raises a wide range of ethical issues that are relevant for the assessment of a number of emerging health technologies.CONCLUSIONS:Existing HTA methodology can address a wide range of non-therapeutic health enhancements. However, a series of broader issues related to the goal of health care and responsibility for altering human evolution may not be addressed within traditional HTA frameworks. Specific HEAs may therefore be helpful.

HARMONIZATION OF ETHICS IN HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT: A REVISION OF THE SOCRATIC APPROACH

2014 ◽  
Vol 30 (1) ◽  
pp. 3-9 ◽  
Author(s):  
Bjørn Hofmann ◽  
Sigrid Droste ◽  
Wija Oortwijn ◽  
Irina Cleemput ◽  
Dario Sacchini
Keyword(s):  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Expert Panel ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Joint Effort ◽  
Face To Face ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Wide Range ◽  
E Mail

Background: Ethics has been part of health technology assessment (HTA) from its beginning in the 1970s, and is currently part of HTA definitions. Several methods in ethics have been used in HTA. Some approaches have been developed especially for HTA, such as the Socratic approach, which has been used for a wide range of health technologies. The Socratic approach is used in several ways, and there is a need for harmonization to promote its usability and the transferability of its results. Accordingly, the objective of this study was to stimulate experts in ethics and HTA to revise the Socratic approach.Methods: Based on the current literature and experiences in applying methods in ethics, a panel of ethics experts involved in HTA critically analyzed the limitations of the Socratic approach during a face-to-face workshop. On the basis of this analysis a revision of the Socratic approach was agreed on after deliberation in several rounds through e-mail correspondence.Results: Several limitations with the Socratic approach are identified and addressed in the revised version which consists of a procedure of six steps, 7 main questions and thirty-three explanatory and guiding questions. The revised approach has a broader scope and provides more guidance than its predecessor. Methods for information retrieval have been elaborated.Conclusion: The presented revision of the Socratic approach is the result of a joint effort of experts in the field of ethics and HTA. Consensus is reached in the expert panel on an approach that is considered to be more clear, comprehensive, and applicable for addressing ethical issues in HTA.

scholarly journals History of health technology assessment: Spain

2009 ◽  
Vol 25 (S1) ◽  
pp. 163-173 ◽  
Author(s):  
Laura Sampietro-Colom ◽  
Jose Asua ◽  
Eduardo Briones ◽  
Jordi Gol ◽  
Keyword(s):  
Health Care ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Policy Decision ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Policy Coordination ◽  
Public Healthcare ◽  
Regional Government ◽  
Health Care Environment ◽  
Health Technologies

Objectives: The aim of this study was to describe the characteristics of the introduction and diffusion of health technology assessment (HTA) in Spain.Methods: A survey to summarize the evolution of HTA was sent to representatives of different HTA initiatives in Spain.Results: HTA was introduced in the late 1980s. The main factors were the trend to an increase in healthcare expenditure, concerns regarding efficiency in providing health care, as well as in the level of rationality introducing high technology. Spain has direct (i.e., regulation) and indirect (i.e., payment systems, evidence-based programs, HTA) mechanisms to control health technologies. A recent high priority regulation has established the need of HTA to decide the introduction of a new health technology in the lists of public healthcare coverage, although similar regulations existed in the past and were scarcely implemented. HTA initiatives started at the regional government level. Its introduction followed a progressive pattern among regions. In the beginning, resources were scarce and expertise limited, with work done at intramural level. With time, expertise increase, and promotion of commissioned work was implemented. HTA knowledge transfer in the healthcare system has been carried out through courses, publications, and commissioned research. Currently, there are seven HTA units/agencies, which coordinate their work.Conclusions: HTA in Spain is in its maturity. Facing the unavoidable change of health care environment over time, HTA is also evolving and, currently, there is a trend to broaden the areas of influence of HTA by devolving capacity to hospitals and applying principles to very early phases of health technology development, under the umbrella of regional HTA units/agencies. However, there are two main challenges ahead. One is to have a real impact at the highest level of healthcare policy coordination among Spanish regions, which is done at the Central Ministry of Health. The other is to avoid the influence of political waves in the level of recognition of HTA at the policy decision-making level and to have an adequate and stable funding of HTA initiatives.

COMPREHENSIVE ASSESSMENT OF COMPLEX TECHNOLOGIES: INTEGRATING VARIOUS ASPECTS IN HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT

2017 ◽  
Vol 33 (5) ◽  
pp. 570-576 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kristin Bakke Lysdahl ◽  
Kati Mozygemba ◽  
Jacob Burns ◽  
Jan Benedikt Brönneke ◽  
James B. Chilcott ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Stakeholder Involvement ◽  
Complex Interventions ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Legal Aspects ◽  
Added Value ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Stakeholder Perspectives ◽  
Wide Range

Objectives: Despite recent development of health technology assessment (HTA) methods, there are still methodological gaps for the assessment of complex health technologies. The INTEGRATE-HTA guidance for effectiveness, economic, ethical, socio-cultural, and legal aspects, deals with challenges when assessing complex technologies, such as heterogeneous study designs, multiple stakeholder perspectives, and unpredictable outcomes. The objective of this article is to outline this guidance and describe the added value of integrating these assessment aspects.Methods: Different methods were used to develop the various parts of the guidance, but all draw on existing, published knowledge and were supported by stakeholder involvement. The guidance was modified after application in a case study and in response to feedback from internal and external reviewers.Results: The guidance consists of five parts, addressing five core aspects of HTA, all presenting stepwise approaches based on the assessment of complexity, context, and stakeholder involvement. The guidance on effectiveness, health economics and ethics aspects focus on helping users choose appropriate, or further develop, existing methods. The recommendations are based on existing methods’ applicability for dealing with problems arising with complex interventions. The guidance offers new frameworks to identify socio-cultural and legal issues, along with overviews of relevant methods and sources.Conclusions: The INTEGRATE-HTA guidance outlines a wide range of methods and facilitates appropriate choices among them. The guidance enables understanding of how complexity matters for HTA and brings together assessments from disciplines, such as epidemiology, economics, ethics, law, and social theory. This indicates relevance for a broad range of technologies.

EUR-ASSESS Project Subgroup Report on Methodology:Methodological Guidance for the Conduct of Health Technology Assessment

1997 ◽  
Vol 13 (2) ◽  
pp. 186-219 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alessandro Liberati ◽  
Trevor A. Sheldon ◽  
H. David Banta
Keyword(s):  
Health Care ◽  
Decision Making ◽  
Health Policy ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Policy Decisions ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Benefits And Costs

Health technology assessment (HTA) is primarily concerned with the consequences (benefits and costs) of health care and health policy decisions. Because decision making is complex and outcomes are often uncertain, it is helpful to attempt to assess the consequences. The quality of decisions can be improved by a process that provides a consistent framework for identifying and assessing health technologies.

Toward a procedure for integrating moral issues in health technology assessment

2005 ◽  
Vol 21 (3) ◽  
pp. 312-318 ◽  
Author(s):  
Bjørn Hofmann
Keyword(s):  
Health Policy ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Moral Philosophy ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Policy Making ◽  
Theoretical Foundation ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Moral Issues ◽  
Wide Range

Objectives: Although ethics has been on the agenda in health technology assessment (HTA) since its inception, the integration of moral issues is still not standard and is performed in a vast variety of ways. Therefore, there is a need for a procedure for integrating moral issues in HTA.Methods: Literature review of existing approaches together with application of various theories in moral philosophy and axiology.Results: The article develops a set of questions that addresses a wide range of moral issues related to the assessment and implementation of health technology. The issues include general moral issues and moral issues related to stakeholders, methodology, characteristics of technology, and to the HTA process itself. The questions form a kind of checklist for use in HTAs.Conclusions: The presented approach for integrating moral issues in HTA has a broad theoretical foundation and has shown to be useful in practice. Integrating ethical issues in HTAs can be of great importance with respect to the dissemination of HTA results and in efficient health policy making.

scholarly journals HOW TO AVOID GIVING THE RIGHT ANSWERS TO THE WRONG QUESTIONS: THE NEED FOR INTEGRATED ASSESSMENTS OF COMPLEX HEALTH TECHNOLOGIES

2017 ◽  
Vol 33 (5) ◽  
pp. 541-543 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ansgar Gerhardus ◽  
Wija Oortwijn ◽  
Gert Jan van der Wilt
Keyword(s):  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
European Commission ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Decision Makers ◽  
Patient Centered ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
The Right ◽  
Integrated Assessments

Health technologies are becoming increasingly complex and contemporary health technology assessment (HTA) is only partly equipped to address this complexity. The project “Integrated assessments of complex health technologies” (INTEGRATE-HTA), funded by the European Commission, was initiated with the overall objective to develop concepts and methods to enable patient-centered, integrated assessments of the effectiveness, and the economic, social, cultural, and ethical issues of complex technologies that take context and implementation issues into account. The project resulted in a series of guidances that should support the work of HTA scientists and decision makers alike.

OP92 Addressing Challenges Of Implementing A Health Technology Assessment Framework In South Africa

2017 ◽  
Vol 33 (S1) ◽  
pp. 41-42
Author(s):  
Jani Mueller
Keyword(s):  
South Africa ◽  
Health Care ◽  
Decision Making ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Healthcare Sector ◽  
Public And Private ◽  
The Public ◽  
Health Technologies

INTRODUCTION:South Africa is in the process of providing comprehensive health insurance to all its citizens, thus paving the pathway for Health Technology Assessment (HTA) to play a significant role in provision of safe and effective healthcare. The National Department of Health (DoH) has a published framework and Health Technology Act and strategies since the 1990s to improve health outcomes, and service and delivery of care. The purpose of this study is to explore challenges faced in the implementation of the framework and policies.METHODS:The study will be based on review and analysis of health technology policies and legislations introduced in South Africa since the 1990s. These documents are available from the DoH archive. The review from this grey literature was supplemented by information collected from a self-completion questionnaire, which was distributed to key stakeholders. Respondents were identified by direct contact with ministries of health and professional bodies, and included health professionals from the public and private healthcare sector, for example, practitioners, experts from hospitals, and industry representatives. The questionnaire addressed issues pertaining to decision making regarding health service delivery and the status of HTA in the country.RESULTS:The framework lays out the strategy to facilitate appropriate utilization of health technologies and includes among others, an HTA section. Fragmented use of HTA or parts thereof has been observed in the public and private health care sector. Furthermore, the respondents pointed out that decisions on health technology can be political, institutional or professionally driven whereas they all agreed that a formal and institutional implementation of HTA would improve healthcare service.CONCLUSIONS:The goal to achieve universal health care provides an excellent window of opportunity for formal use of HTA in policy- and decision-making. However, (i) the inadequate number of trained professionals and education and training opportunities (ii) lack of awareness and understanding of the principles of HTA and its impact on the improvement of health care are among the many challenges faced by the system. It has also been observed that national and regional champions can act as change agents and would have a snowball effect.

scholarly journals EXCHANGING VIEWS ON HTA

2012 ◽  
Vol 28 (2) ◽  
pp. 85-85
Author(s):  
Marjukka Mäkelä
Keyword(s):  
Health Care ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Lively Discussion ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Methodological Challenges ◽  
Starting Point

This issue of the International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care (IJTAHC) brings to the readers a lively discussion on the possibility of benchmarking health technology assessment (HTA) organizations. Michael Drummond and colleagues present a paper discussing “the conceptual and methodological challenges associated with benchmarking” (1). They propose a set of criteria for comparing the quality of organizations that produce assessments on health technologies. Aiming at explicit and transparent comparisons, Drummond et al. also highlight the possible problems in their approach, and present their paper as a starting point for discussion.

Health technology assessment of utilization, practice and ethical issues of self-pay services in the German ambulatory health care setting

2013 ◽  
Vol 59 (1) ◽  
pp. 175-187 ◽  
Author(s):  
Theresa Hunger ◽  
Petra Schnell-Inderst ◽  
Katharina Hintringer ◽  
Ruth Schwarzer ◽  
Vanadin Seifert-Klauss ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Health Care ◽  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Care Setting ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Health Care Setting ◽  
Ambulatory Health Care

scholarly journals The Use of the Health Technology Assessment for Technology Acquisition in Hospitals

2017 ◽  
Vol 11 (21) ◽  
Author(s):  
Alejandra Cano Muñoz ◽  
Diana Marcela Troncoso Escobar ◽  
Rosiamry Terezinha De Almeida ◽  
Nayibe Bonilla Mosquera ◽  
Sandra Patricia Usaquén Perilla
Keyword(s):  
Health Technology Assessment ◽  
Technology Assessment ◽  
Ethical Issues ◽  
Social Economic ◽  
Local Level ◽  
Health Technology ◽  
Decision Makers ◽  
Health Technologies ◽  
Technology Acquisition ◽  
The Social

Decision makers at the national and local level of health systems require evidence of effectiveness, safety and costs of health technologies for resource allocation. In this sense Health Technology Assessment (HTA) is a favorable tool considering it is a multidisciplinary process to evaluate the benefits as well as the social, economic, organizational and ethical issues of a health technology. The aim of this study was to review the literature in order to identify the attributes used in the process of technology acquisition. It was analyzed the attributes of HTA with the purpose of classifying them, to see which are the most recommended for acquisition in hospitals. The identified literature indicated that not only the clinical and economic attributes were considered, but also attributes related to the context of the hospital such as the effect of technology on other hospital services and others associated with the organization

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document