Problem The prognosis of bipolar electrocautery nerve injury is unpredictable because few experiments compare it to characterized nerve injury models. Methods 16 Lewis rats were randomized to sciatic crush or bipolar cautery and at 21 days evaluated with nerve morphometry and walking tack analysis. Double transgenic Thy1-CFP/S100-GFP mice were used to serially image axonal regeneration and Schwann cells (SC) over time following injury. Results In rats, bipolar cautery injury shows greater disruption of myelin and neurofilament architecture at the injury site. There is decreased total nerve fiber counts distal to the injury (p<0.05). Walking track analysis demonstrates functional recovery after crush, but not after cautery injury. Serial imaging of mice, shows axonal regeneration starting at week 1 after crush, but late, partial axonal regeneration in the cautery group; these findings were reflected in endplate reinnervation at 42 days. Conclusion Results suggest that a Sunderland type 3 injury, characterized by slow, variable, incomplete recovery, results from a bipolar electrocautery injury. Significance Bipolar cautery injuries can be observed without immediate surgical intervention.