Interactions in self-assembled microbial communities saturate with diversity

How the diversity of organisms competing for or sharing resources influences community production is an important question in ecology but has rarely been explored in natural microbial communities. These generally contain large numbers of species making it difficult to disentangle how the effects of different interactions scale with diversity. Here, we show that changing diversity affects measures of community function in relatively simple communities but that increasing richness beyond a threshold has little detectable effect. We generated self-assembled communities with a wide range of diversity by growth of cells from serially diluted seawater on brown algal leachate. We subsequently isolated the most abundant taxa from these communities via dilution-to-extinction in order to compare productivity functions of the entire community to those of individual taxa. To parse the effect of different types of organismal interactions, we developed relative total function (RTF) as an index for positive or negative effects of diversity on community function. Our analysis identified three overall regimes with increasing diversity. At low richness (<12 taxa), potential positive and negative effects of interactions are both weak, while at moderate richness (12-20 taxa), community resource uptake increases but the carbon use efficiency decreases. Finally, beyond 20 taxa, there was no net change in community function indicating a saturation of potential interactions. These data suggest that although more diverse communities had overall greater access to resources, individual taxa within these communities had lower resource availability and reduced carbon use efficiency, indicating that competition due to niche overlap increases with diversity but that these interactions saturate at a specific threshold.