When an insecticide affects the adaptive value of intraguild predation by an invader

Biological invasions can generate major ecological disturbances, such as changes in species diversity and structure of communities. It is believed that the multicolored Asian ladybeetle, Harmonia axyridis Pallas (Col, Coccinellidae), recognized as one of the most invasive insects in the world, has reduced native coccinellids populations in several areas and is considered as a threat for biodiversity at large. A significant trait, favoring its invasiveness and its dominance over indigenous ladybeetles, is intraguild predation (IGP). IGP has advantageous adaptive value for individuals, removing competitors, potential predators and providing an alternative nutritive resource, when main resources are scarce. Previous research demonstrated that this invasive ladybeetle is highly susceptible to the reduced-risk insecticide novaluron, a chitin synthesis inhibitor, whereas the North American indigenous competitor, Coleomegilla maculata DeGeer (Col, Coccinellidae), is not. Our study explores the adaptive value of IGP for each of the two coccinellids after preying on each other’s larvae, previously treated with insecticide. Our first hypothesis is that the invasive ladybeetle, susceptible to the insecticide, should lose the adaptive value of IGP, while the native predator not. Our second hypothesis is that the adaptive value of IGP for the invasive predator will be recovered over time, as a result of neutralisation of the insecticide by the intraguild prey (native species). The results support both hypotheses, and show that an insecticide can completely remove the adaptive value of IGP for the invader, while it does not change for the indigenous ladybeetle. Moreover, the study demonstrates that if the intraguild prey (non-susceptible to the insecticide) undergoes molt after being exposed to the insecticide, the adaptive value for the intraguild predator is restored.