Investigation of Burst Pressure in Pipes With Square Wall Thinning by Using FEA and API579 FFS-1

Author(s):  
Atsushi Yamaguchi

Boilers and pressure vessels are heavily used in chemical industrial plants and equipment is inspected periodically for damage. The most common type of damage is wall thinning due to Flow-Accelerated Corrosion (FAC) or corrosion under insulation (CUI). Any damage must be repaired or replaced as necessary. On the other hand, optimization of the time required in order to replace damaged equipment by evaluating the load carrying capacity of pipes with wall thinning is expected in chemical industrial field. In the present study, FE analysis is used in order to evaluate the load carrying capacity in pipes with wall thinning. Burst pressure is a measure of the load carrying capacity in pipes with wall thinning. The pipes subjected to burst testing are carbon steel tubes for pressure service STPG370 (JIS G3454). The examined wall thinning is rectangular, and the eroded depth is half the pipe wall thickness. The burst pressure is investigated by comparing the results of burst testing with the results of FE analysis. Moreover, the reduced maximum allowable working pressure (MAWPr), which is calculated by fitness-for-service (FFS) assessment, and the safety margin for burst pressure are investigated. The burst pressure calculated by FEA agrees well with the test results, except for square wall thinning for circumferential angles of less than 15°. Also, the safety margin of MAWPr based on FFS-1 Part 4 is over 4.0 times for burst pressure.

Author(s):  
Atsushi Yamaguchi

Boilers and pressure vessels are heavily used in numerous industrial plants, and damaged equipment in the plants is often detected by visual inspection or non-destructive inspection techniques. The most common type of damage is wall thinning due to corrosion under insulation (CUI) or flow-accelerated corrosion (FAC), or both. Any damaged equipment must be repaired or replaced as necessary as soon as possible after damage has been detected. Moreover, optimization of the time required to replace damaged equipment by evaluating the load carrying capacity of boilers and pressure vessels with wall thinning is expected by engineers in the chemical industrial field. In the present study, finite element analysis (FEA) is used to evaluate the load carrying capacity in T-joints with wall thinning. Burst pressure is a measure of the load carrying capacity in T-joints with wall thinning. The T-joints subjected to burst testing are carbon steel tubes for pressure service STPG370 (JIS G3454). The burst pressure is investigated by comparing the results of burst testing with the results of FEA. Moreover, the maximum allowable working pressure (MAWP) of T-joints with wall thinning is calculated, and the safety margin for the burst pressure is investigated. The burst pressure in T-joints with wall thinning can be estimated the safety side using FEA regardless of whether the model is a shell model or a solid model. The MAWP is 2.6 MPa and has a safety margin 7.5 for burst pressure. Moreover, the MAWP is assessed the as a safety side, although the evaluation is too conservative for the burst pressure.


2005 ◽  
Vol 33 (4) ◽  
pp. 210-226 ◽  
Author(s):  
I. L. Al-Qadi ◽  
M. A. Elseifi ◽  
P. J. Yoo ◽  
I. Janajreh

Abstract The objective of this study was to quantify pavement damage due to a conventional (385/65R22.5) and a new generation of wide-base (445/50R22.5) tires using three-dimensional (3D) finite element (FE) analysis. The investigated new generation of wide-base tires has wider treads and greater load-carrying capacity than the conventional wide-base tire. In addition, the contact patch is less sensitive to loading and is especially designed to operate at 690kPa inflation pressure at 121km/hr speed for full load of 151kN tandem axle. The developed FE models simulated the tread sizes and applicable contact pressure for each tread and utilized laboratory-measured pavement material properties. In addition, the models were calibrated and properly validated using field-measured stresses and strains. Comparison was established between the two wide-base tire types and the dual-tire assembly. Results indicated that the 445/50R22.5 wide-base tire would cause more fatigue damage, approximately the same rutting damage and less surface-initiated top-down cracking than the conventional dual-tire assembly. On the other hand, the conventional 385/65R22.5 wide-base tire, which was introduced more than two decades ago, caused the most damage.


2001 ◽  
Vol 15 (2) ◽  
pp. 153-157
Author(s):  
V V Erofeev ◽  
M V Shakhmatov ◽  
M V Erofeev ◽  
V V Kovalenko

1989 ◽  
Vol 21 (11) ◽  
pp. 1454-1459
Author(s):  
N. A. Makhutov ◽  
M. I. Burak ◽  
V. B. Kaidalov

Author(s):  
Jin Weon Kim ◽  
Chi Yong Park

The pipe failure tests were performed using 102mm-Sch.80 carbon steel pipe with various simulated local wall thinning defects, in the present study, to investigate the failure behavior of pipe thinned by flow accelerated corrosion (FAC). The failure mode, load carrying capacity, and deformation ability were analyzed from the results of experiments conducted under loading conditions of 4-point bending and internal pressure. A failure mode of pipe with a defect depended on the magnitude of internal pressure and axial thinning length as well as stress type and thinning depth and circumferential angle. Also, the results indicated that the load carrying capacity and deformation ability were depended on stress state in the thinning region and dimensions of thinning defect. With increase in axial length of thinning area, for applying tensile stress to the thinning region, the dependence of load carrying capacity was determined by circumferential thinning angle, and the deformation ability was proportionally increased regardless of the circumferential angle. For applying compressive stress to thinning region, however, the load carrying capacity was decreased with increase in axial length of the thinned area. Also, the effect of internal pressure on failure behavior was characterized by failure mode of thinned pipe, and it promoted crack occurrence and mitigated a local buckling of the thinned area.


2016 ◽  
Vol 138 (5) ◽  
Author(s):  
Mechri Abdel Ghani ◽  
Ghomari Tewfik ◽  
Djouadi Djahida

The evaluation of pipelines having external corrosion defect and their remaining load-carrying capacity is a concern which becomes important in energy industry, especially with the increasing operating pressures and the consequences which can occur following the bursting of these pipelines. A lower bound analytical solution for the prediction of the burst pressure of pipelines is proposed. This solution is based on the approach of plastic-instability criterion in terms of material strain-hardening exponent of internally pressurized corroded pipelines. The suggested solution is evaluated by using database comprising more than 100 carried out tests of pipelines with or without corrosion defects. This database is collected from the literature and covers the majority of steel materials as well as the various standard sizes. The accuracy of the proposed solution is compared with B31.G method and its improved version B31.G Mod by using statistical analyses in terms of average error and its correspondent standard deviation. The proposed solution is accurate than B31.G and modified B31.G methods that are conservative and provide in some cases of middle and high strength material an overestimated burst pressure predictions.


Author(s):  
Yang-chun Deng ◽  
Gang Chen

To reduce the waste of austenitic stainless steels due to their low yield strengths, the strain hardening technology is used to significantly improve their yield strength, in order to increase the elastic load carrying capacity of austenitic stainless steel pressure vessels. The basic principle of strain-hardening for austenitic stainless steel pressure vessels and two common models of strain hardening, including Avesta Model for ambient temperature and Ardeform Model for cryogenic temperature, were briefly introduced. However, it was fully established by experiments, the lack of a necessary theoretical foundation and the safety concern affect its widespread use. In this study, we investigated the load carrying capacity of strain-hardening austenitic stainless steel pressure vessels under hydrostatic pressure, based on the elastic-plastic theory. To understand the effects of strain hardening on material behavior, the plastic instability loads of a round tensile bar specimen were also derived under two different loading paths and validated by experiments. The results of theoretical, experimental and finite element analyses illustrated, considering the effect of material strain hardening and structural deformation, at ambient temperature, the static load carrying capacity of pressure vessels does not relate to the loading paths. To calculate the plastic instability pressures, a method was proposed so that the original dimension and original material parameters prior to strain hardening can be used either by the theoretical formula or finite element analysis. The safety margin of austenitic stainless steel pressure vessels under various strain hardening degrees was quantitatively analyzed by experiments and finite element method. A 5% strain as the restrictive condition of strain hardening design for austenitic stainless steel pressure vessels was suggested.


1999 ◽  
Vol 122 (2) ◽  
pp. 198-203
Author(s):  
H. F. Chen ◽  
D. W. Shu

A simplified numerical method for both lower and upper-bound limit analyses of 3-D structure has been developed in our previous work. The load-carrying capacities of 3-D pipelines with either one or two part-through defects of various geometrical configurations were calculated by the proposed method. In the present paper, the effects of the distance between two defects on the load-carrying capacity of pressure vessels are evaluated and discussed in details. Using curve-fitting schemes, an empirical formula for obtaining the load-carrying capacity of pressure vessels with double defects from that of pressure vessels with a single defect are proposed. Some engineering suggestions are presented simultaneously. All the numerical results confirm the applicability of the simplified numerical method. [S0094-9930(00)00102-5]


Author(s):  
J. Błachut

The current paper examines the effects of corrosion induced wall thinning on buckling of domed closures onto cylindrical vessels. It is assumed that corrosion is axisymmetric and that the wall is corroded on inside, only. The ratio of corroded wall thickness, tc, to the non-corroded thickness, t, is varied between 0.10 ≤ tc/t ≤ 1.0. Both depth of corrosion and its meridional extend are varied during numerical calculations. Three modelling scenarios for placement of corrosion are considered: (i) corrosion confined to the knuckle, (ii) corrosion spanning evenly the knuckle and spherical parts, and (iii) patchtype area positioned at the apex. Numerical results indicate that the following factors influence buckling performance of the dome: (i) meridional position of corroded area, (ii) depth of corrosion itself, and (iii) meridional span of corroded wall. For example, wall thinning of 10 % over 10 % of meridional length causes almost 20 % drop in buckling strength. The largest drop of load carrying capacity is found when the corroded wall is at the knuckle/crown junction. Here it is shown that assessment of strength based on the collapse mechanism is not only wrong but dangerous. For the case of the corroded dome, the collapse pressure overestimates the load carrying capacity associated with asymmetric bifurcation buckling by 40 %.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document