This chapter explores what Christian identity means for pedagogical practice. By examining the connections that teachers make between their Christian identity and their actions in the classroom, this chapter investigates how teachers believe their Christianity influences the why, what, and how of teaching. Overall, teachers in the survey differentiated between two major perspectives on how Christianity changed the ends, content, and methods of their courses, identified as spiritual addition and Christian transformation. Spiritual addition professors understood their Christian identity as inspiring the addition of certain objectives, content, and methods to their classroom. Christian transformation professors drew upon the Christian tradition to reconceptualize major parts of their objectives, content, and methods in more radical ways than the former category of teachers. This chapter illustrates these differences and classifies the specific ends and content that the professors in the study claimed were influenced by their Christian identity.