We present a comparison of microseismic data denoising methods based on their effect on the polarization attributes of 3C microseismic signals. The compared denoising methods include the classical band-pass filtering, and three recently proposed denoising techniques: restricted domain hyperbolic Radon transform denoising, singular value decomposition-based reduced-rank filtering, and empirical mode decomposition denoising. In order to draw the comparison, we have denoised 3C synthetic data contaminated with noise extracted from actual field data records, calculated their rectilinearity, azimuth, and dip polarization attributes, and arranged them into histograms. The comparison has been drawn by measuring the distances between the polarization histograms of the clean and denoised data, assuming that one method outperforms another if the aforementioned distance is smaller. This strategy allows to quantify the improvement in the calculated polarization attributes due to the different denoising processes. In addition, we have also calculated the quality factor of the denoised signals, which adds value and robustness to the comparison. Our results have indicated that the method based on singular value decomposition preserves the original polarization attributes better than the other techniques tested in this work. Moreover, it has also retrieved the denoised signal with the highest quality factor. Finally, we have tested the methods with field data and assessed their performance qualitatively on the basis of the insight gained from the numerical tests with synthetic data.
Integration of Extreme-point Symmetric Mode Decomposition and Singular Value Decomposition for Dynamic Deflection Denoising of Urban Bridges Obtained by Ground-based Microwave Interferometry
