Deconstructing Masculinity: A Qualitative Study of College Men's Masculine Conceptualizations and Gender Performance

NASPA Journal ◽  
2009 ◽  
Vol 45 (4) ◽  
Author(s):  
Frank Harris

Informed by the constructionist epistemological perspective, the purpose of this study was to examine socially constructed conceptualizations of masculinity and gender performance among 12 culturally diverse undergraduate men. The participants espoused seemingly productive conceptualizations of masculinity, yet their gendered behaviors were inconsistent with the conceptualizations they espoused. Based on the findings, recommendations for supporting the gender identity development of college men are proposed.

Author(s):  
Cassandra R. Homick ◽  
Lisa F. Platt

Gender and sexual identity play a significant role in the lives of developing youth. The developments of gender and sexual identities are shaped by a variety of factors including, but not limited to, biological, cognitive, and social elements. It is crucial to consider that gender and sexual minority individuals face additional complexities in the two processes of gender identity and sexual identity development. Cisgender identity development is most commonly understood with the help of early cognitive and social theories, although biological components play a part as well. Specifically, the theories of Lawrence Kohlberg, Sandra Bem, Alfred Bandura, and David Buss have made significant contributions to the understanding of cisgender identity development. Modern transgender identity development models are helpful in exploring transgender identity formation with the most popular being the Transgender Emergence Model founded by Arlene Lev. Similar to cisgender identity development, heterosexual identity development is typically understood with the help of early psychosocial theories, namely that of Erik Erikson. Sexual minority identity development is often comprehended using stage models and life-span models. Sexual minority stage models build off the work of Erik Erikson, with one of the most popular being the Cass Model of Gay and Lesbian Identity Development. Offering more flexibility than stage models and allowing for fluid sexual identity, life-span models, like the D’Augelli model, are often more popular choices for modern exploration of sexual minority identity development. As both sexual and gender identity spectrums are continuing to expand, there also comes a need for an exploration of the relationship between sexual and gender identity development, particularly among sexual minority populations.


2018 ◽  
Vol 24 (2) ◽  
pp. 291-303 ◽  
Author(s):  
Nastasja M de Graaf ◽  
Ilham I Manjra ◽  
Anna Hames ◽  
Claudia Zitz

Background: Little is known about how social and cultural variants interact with gender identity development. This article aims to identify the ethnicities of children and young people referred to the United Kingdom’s national Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS), and compare the ethnicity data with the UK child population and referrals to Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS). Methods: GIDS referrals made between April 2012 and April 2015 for children and young people were retrieved. Ethnicity data were obtained by the ‘16 + 1’ ethnicity list. Chi-square and t-tests were performed on the demographics. Results: Less than 10% of the 995 referrals at GIDS were from Black and minority ethnic (BME) groups – an underrepresentation as compared with both the national population and CAMHS figures. No significant differences in ethnic representation were found between the demographic birth-assigned sexes, across age groups, or year of referral. Conclusions: Hypotheses proposed for this underrepresentation take into account both the potential barriers to accessing services and the possibility of cross-cultural variations in the conceptualisations of gender, gender roles and gender diversity. Ethnicity, culture and religion, and their overlapping relationship with gender need further exploration.


2018 ◽  
Vol 24 (2) ◽  
pp. 277-290 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jos Twist ◽  
Nastasja M de Graaf

There has been a recent rise in the number of people who hold a non-binary gender identity. However, the proportion of young people attending gender services who identify as non-binary has not yet been investigated. This article presents the findings from a pilot study of newly designed questionnaire, the Gender Diversity Questionnaire, which included questions about gender identity and gender expression. Responses from 251 adolescents attending the United Kingdom’s National Gender Identity Development Service between June 2016 and February 2017 are reported here. The majority, 56.9%, of young people identified as trans, 29.3% identified as a binary gender (male or female), 11% identified as non-binary and 1.2% as agender. There were no significant differences in self-defined identities based on assigned gender or age. However, once young people were separated into these groups, some of them were very small; thus, a larger sample is required. In terms of aspects of gender expression that were important to the young people, the data formed five themes – name and pronouns, external appearance, the body, intrinsic factors and ‘other’. Strengths and weaknesses of the research are discussed as well as future work that will be conducted.


Education ◽  
2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jeffrey M. Poirier ◽  
Allison Mattheis ◽  
Deborah Temkin

This review synthesizes recent literature and research on students in K–12 schools who are attracted to the same gender (lesbian, gay), attracted to people of the same or other genders (bisexual), or identify as a gender different than the one they were assigned at birth (transgender). Lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) young people have historically experienced vulnerability in schools because of challenges such as invisibility in school curricula; peer and staff rejection, harassment, and violence; and ill-equipped school professionals who lack the competence and will to effectively address bias and foster inclusive school environments. Foundational research in the field examines this vulnerability to document the experiences and needs of this population—and to draw attention to gaps in school policy, practice, and outcomes for LGBT students. Research examining vulnerabilities and challenges for this population is also prominent in the early 21st century because many of these concerns persist. At the same time, more recent research on LGBT youth in schools is attending to these young people’s positive assets and their resilience, including their abilities to effectively navigate conflict and stress and adapt to different situations. Throughout this article, “LGBT” is used as an umbrella acronym. Although the rich diversity of sexual orientation and gender identity and expression, such as students who are queer, genderqueer, or questioning their sexual orientation or gender identity is important, this article aims to provide a working vocabulary to address this population of youth discussed here. This article also aligns its terminology with the content of articles. In other words, if an article examines only transgender students, then the full LGBT acronym is not used when writing about that article. Research on LGBT youth in schools is substantial, given the growth of research studying related issues during the late 20th and early 21st centuries. This expanding research on LGBT youth in schools has spanned topics beyond their school experiences to include myriad issues such as their identity development within the school context; school-based policies, practices, and supports such as inclusive nondiscrimination policies; teacher practices that foster welcoming and inclusive school settings, and the benefits of safe spaces and targeted supports for LGBT students; and how school administrator and teacher preparation programs can lead to better school practice and outcomes for LGBT students. Other areas of research on LGBT youth in schools continue to emerge as the field’s understanding about diverse sexual orientation and gender identities expands, and as there is more attention given to the complexity of identity and expression including intersectionality (e.g., youth in schools who are LGBT and of color, or LGBT and immigrants).


2016 ◽  
Vol 16 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Trevor MacDonald ◽  
Joy Noel-Weiss ◽  
Diana West ◽  
Michelle Walks ◽  
MaryLynne Biener ◽  
...  

2020 ◽  
Vol 4 (Supplement_1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Rebecca Persky ◽  
Joan C Han ◽  
Anna Neyman ◽  
Reuben D Rohn ◽  
Ravikumar Balasubramanian ◽  
...  

Abstract Background: Sex hormones play a role in gender identity development. For example, 46,XY individuals with complete androgen insensitivity typically have a female gender identity. Isolated GnRH deficiency (IGD) leads to hypogonadism due to decreased GnRH-induced gonadotropin production. It is unknown if decreased sex hormone exposure leads to differences in gender identity among individuals with IGD compared with the general population. Our objective was to determine if the gender identity in subjects with IGD differs from controls. Methods: We distributed a validated questionnaire; the Gender Identity/Gender Dysphoria Questionnaire for Adults and Adolescents (GIDYQ-AA) (1), to IGD participants who previously enrolled in a phenotyping study. Subjects also provided their age, sex assigned at birth (SAAB), gender and information about their condition and treatment. Group survey scores are expressed as mean ± SD. IGD subject scores were compared with control data (Student’s t-test) obtained from a validation study for the GIDYQ-AA (2). Results: Out of 79 subjects who were contacted, 8 males (M) assigned at birth and 7 females (F) assigned at birth chose to participate and one person actively declined. Average age was 30 y for F and 28 y for M. At the time of the study, all subjects were on hormone supplementation except for one F. A score of 5 indicates a gender identity congruent with SAAB. Among F, mean scaled IGD score was 4.73 ± 0.29 vs. controls (4.8 ± 0.28, n=57; not significant (ns)), and for M it was 4.62 ± 0.52 vs. controls (4.82 ± 0.24, n=37; ns). One female identified as “non-gendered”, one male identified as “intersex/DSD” (14% of respondents), one female did not respond and gender was congruent with SAAB in the remainder. The lowest mean score for an individual question for the IGD F group was in response to whether they felt satisfied being a woman and for the IGD M group, it was in response to whether they felt they were a real man. Conclusions: Men and women with IGD did not show a significant difference in their gender identity compared with controls, and gender was found to be congruent with SAAB for the majority. However, the individual question responses and the self-described gender in this small cohort may suggest that there are differences in how some individuals with IGD experience their gender development. We speculate that this may be related to how they perceive the differences in physical development that they experienced related to their condition. Larger studies in participants with IGD and other disorders that alter sex hormone production/effect are necessary to further understand the relationship between decreased sex hormone exposure during critical developmental periods and gender identity development. References: (1) Deogracias, J.J, et al. J. Sex Res., 2007, 44:4, 370–379 (2) Singh, D. et al. J. Sex Res. 2010, 47:1, 49–58


Author(s):  
Yao Chiachen ◽  
Ya-huei Wang

<p class="AbstractText">All human beings seek certain identities in order to understand their existence and position in society, the groups to which they belong, and the unique characteristics they have. This paper examines how, in <em>Jane Eyre</em>, Charlotte Bronte examines socially constructed institutionalism in Victorian England. This paper also explores how the protagonist, Jane Eyre, oppressed due to her social class and gender, struggles to live with equality, dignity, and freedom, and finally reaches independence and self-fulfillment. Jane successfully completes the stages of identity development, and, after acquiring a sense of competence, achieves happiness and intimacy in an equal partnership with her true love, Mr. Rochester.</p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document