scholarly journals MONETARY AND FISCAL POLICY ANALYSIS: WHICH IS MORE EFFECTIVE?

2015 ◽  
Vol 29 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Muhamad Yunanto ◽  
Henny Medyawati

Fiscal policy is an adjustment in the income and expenditure of government as stipulated inthe state budget in order to achieve better economic stability and pace of development. Themain objective of this study was to measure and analyze Fiscal and Monetary Policy of theGross Domestic Product (GDP). Fiscal Policy Multiplier (FPM) and Monetary PolicyMultiplier (MPM) are used to answer the debate where more effective between fiscal policy andmonetary policy. Short-term models derived through error correction model (ECM), which alsoforms the derivative equation. A system of simultaneous equations two stage least squares(TSLS), is used to describe the sensitivity analysis (response) of shocks to the policy change ofimportant macroeconomic indicators. The results showed that during the study period,Indonesia's monetary policy more effective than fiscal policy.Keywords: monetary policy, fiscal policy, Mundell-Flemming Model

2015 ◽  
Vol 29 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Muhamad Yunanto ◽  
Henny Medyawati

Fiscal policy is an adjustment in the income and expenditure of government as stipulated inthe state budget in order to achieve better economic stability and pace of development. Themain objective of this study was to measure and analyze Fiscal and Monetary Policy of theGross Domestic Product (GDP). Fiscal Policy Multiplier (FPM) and Monetary PolicyMultiplier (MPM) are used to answer the debate where more effective between fiscal policy andmonetary policy. Short-term models derived through error correction model (ECM), which alsoforms the derivative equation. A system of simultaneous equations two stage least squares(TSLS), is used to describe the sensitivity analysis (response) of shocks to the policy change ofimportant macroeconomic indicators. The results showed that during the study period,Indonesia's monetary policy more effective than fiscal policy.Keywords: monetary policy, fiscal policy, Mundell-Flemming Model


2017 ◽  
Vol 3 (2) ◽  
Author(s):  
Arundhati Mallick ◽  
Narayan Sethi

Monetary policy and fiscal policy have their own perspective towards maintaining economic stability of the country. However, for a well- functioning economy, they need to work in coordination with each other. In this paper we are empirically examining the interaction between monetary and fiscal policy by using Vector Error Correction Model (VECM) for the period of April 2010 to March 2015. The study also discusses game theoretic approach to know about the strategic interaction between monetary and fiscal policy. The study uses change in gross fiscal deficit and output to represent fiscal policy and inflation and interest rate to represent the monetary policy. The results indicate that fiscal policy responds well to any changes in monetary policy but reverse is not taking place.


2014 ◽  
Vol 104 (10) ◽  
pp. 3154-3185 ◽  
Author(s):  
Eric T. Swanson ◽  
John C. Williams

According to standard macroeconomic models, the zero lower bound greatly reduces the effectiveness of monetary policy and increases the efficacy of fiscal policy. However, private-sector decisions depend on the entire path of expected future short-term interest rates, not just the current short-term rate. Put differently, longer-term yields matter. We show how to measure the zero bound's effects on yields of any maturity. Indeed, 1- and 2-year Treasury yields were surprisingly unconstrained throughout 2008 to 2010, suggesting that monetary and fiscal policy were about as effective as usual during this period. Only beginning in late 2011 did these yields become more constrained. (JEL E43, E52, E62)


2014 ◽  
Author(s):  
Πέτρος Βαρθαλίτης

This thesis is about monetary and fiscal policy in New Keynesian DSGE models. Chapter 2 presents the baseline New Keynesian DSGE model. Monetary policy is in the form of a simple interest rate Taylor-type policy rule, while fiscal policy is exogenous. Chapter 3 extends the model of Chapter 2 to include fiscal policy. Now, both monetary and fiscal policy are allowed to follow feedback rules. Chapter 4 sets up a New Keynesian model of a semi-small open economy with sovereign risk premia. Finally, Chapter 5 builds a New Keynesian DSGE model consisting of two heterogeneous countries participating in a monetary union.Throughout most of the thesis, policy is conducted via "simple", "implementable" and "optimized" feedback policy rules. Using such rules, the aim of policy is twofold: firslty, it aims to stabilize the economy when the latter is hit by shocks; secondly, it aims to improve the economy's resource allocation.


2020 ◽  
Vol 6 (3) ◽  
pp. 266-274
Author(s):  
Sh. Sitmuratov

The article examines an effectiveness of government monetary and fiscal policy for Uzbekistan by constricting IS-curve for goods market and LM-curve for money market, simultaneously. For the both markets equilibrium interest rate is also determined. The results show that the variables are co integrated, that the variables have long-run or short-run equilibrium relationship between them. According to the empirical results, the long-run equilibrium interest rate for covered period was 22.0% for Uzbekistan, for the current period we recommend the equilibrium interest rate around 15%.


2015 ◽  
Vol 2015 ◽  
pp. 1-12
Author(s):  
Eiji Tsuzuki

We examine the effects of policy lags on local economic stability using a Kaldorian model. This study analyzes two cases: the case of a monetary policy with a time lag and the case of a policy with both fiscal and monetary lags. Similar to the case of fiscal policy lags examined in a previous study, monetary policy lags have destabilizing effects on economic stability. However, in the case of the existence of both fiscal and monetary policy lags, there is a possibility that a monetary policy lag can stabilize an economy.


2017 ◽  
Vol 7 (1) ◽  
pp. 77-82
Author(s):  
Krešimir Bošnjak ◽  
◽  
Tunjo Perić ◽  

The paper explored the interaction of monetary and fiscal policy through game theory. In the first part of the paper it isin short presented theoretical basis of fiscal and monetary policy, and then explained the theoretical part of game theory also in short. After theoretical part, the analysis was conducted based on the collected data and then the results of the paper are presented. A function of payments for monetary and fiscal policy have been created on the basis of data inflation, unemployment rate, total liquidity and the rate of government spending in the Republic of Croatia. Multiple linear regression, which is processed using software solutions Eviews, derived parameters for independent variables. In this way, holders of monetary and fiscal policy can decide on quantities of independent variables, and based on that, determine their strategy. The obtained result, based on the functions of payments for monetary and fiscal policy, generated the matrix of payments. Solving the matrix of payments resulted with non-dominated solutions. For solving the problem, PROMETHEE method has been applied. Analysing the game by using the PROMETHEE method, it generated optimal solutions in terms of assumption when a greater impact on the economy, in this case on the inflation and unemployment, has the fiscal policy and in terms of assumption when a greater impact on the economy has monetary policy. As the optimal results we obtained only two strategies although the game has been repeated in many stages.


2021 ◽  
Vol 92 ◽  
pp. 07023
Author(s):  
Tapdig Guluzada ◽  
Esmira Guluzada

Research background: Today, the acceptance of fiscal policy decisions necessitates the analysis of policy efficiency with the help of optimization issues, the study of cause-and-effect relationships between budget expenditures and macroeconomic indicators such as economic growth, revenues, and the evaluation of a number of econometric models among all. The need for these areas makes it important to study and analyze the effects of fiscal policy on the economy, which allows to justify the relevance of the topic of the article. Purpose of the article: The article is devoted to the assessment of the fiscal and economic consequences of changes in oil prices in the world market, as well as the study of the relationship between state budget revenues and government expenditure in Azerbaijan. It was revealed that a 1% increase in oil prices, in the long run, increased Azerbaijan’s GDP by 0.52% and state budget expenditures by 0.88%. The calculations allow to conclude that there is a high correlation between government spending and state budget revenues in Azerbaijan. The obtained result indicates a positive relationship between the aforementioned economic variables. Methods: The most common method of analyzing the possible causal relationship between macroeconomic indicators is the causality test proposed by Granger in 1969. However, from a methodological point of view, the application of this test to study the causal relationship between economic indicators requires these indicators to be stationary. This statistical feature can be violated in the case of the economic indicator having the single root elements. To do this, we tested the Unit root problem of the variable using the Augmented Dickey-Fuller test. Simultaneously, a number of other important features of the evaluated models were tested and the adequacy of the models was confirmed. Findings & Value added: As a result of the research, it was determined that there is a short-term and long-term causal relationship between world oil prices and Azerbaijan’s GDP and state budget expenditures. According to the results, a 1 percent increase in oil prices leads to the increase of the current level of GDP growth in Azerbaijan by 0.20 percent in the short term, and by 0.52 percent in the long term. Parallelly, it was revealed that a 1 percent increase in world oil prices leads to a 0.88 percent increase in Azerbaijan’s state budget expenditures in the long run. The correlation between Azerbaijan’s government expenditures and state budget revenues was analyzed, and a high correlation between these two macroeconomic indicators was identified.


2014 ◽  
pp. 107-121 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. Andryushin

The paper analyzes monetary policy of the Bank of Russia from 2008 to 2014. It presents the dynamics of macroeconomic indicators testifying to inability of the Bank of Russia to transit to inflation targeting regime. It is shown that the presence of short-term interest rates in the top borders of the percentage corridor does not allow to consider the key rate as a basic tool of monetary policy. The article justifies that stability of domestic prices is impossible with-out exchange rate stability. It is proved that to decrease excessive volatility on national consumer and financial markets it is reasonable to apply a policy of managing financial account, actively using for this purpose direct and indirect control tools for the cross-border flows of the private and public capital.


Author(s):  
Paul Dalziel ◽  
J. W. Nevile

There was much in common in the development of post-Keynesian economics in Australia and New Zealand, but there were also many differences. Both countries shared a common heritage in higher education. In the first twenty-five years after World War II, both countries adopted broadly Keynesian policies and experienced very low levels of unemployment. Increasingly over these years more theorizing about macroeconomic policy had what now would be called a post-Keynesian content, but this label was not used till after the event. In both countries, apart from one important factor, the experience of actual monetary policy and theorizing about it were similar. Keynesian ideas were more rapidly adopted in Australia than in many other countries. Not surprisingly for a couple of decades after 1936, analysis of policy and its application was Keynesian rather than post-Keynesian, with fiscal policy playing the major role. The conduct of both monetary and fiscal policy depends on the theory of inflation. This chapter examines post-Keynesian economics in Australasia, focusing on aggregate demand, economic growth, and income distribution policy.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document