Developmental Shift Hypothesis and Preferred Memory Attributes in Elementary School Children
Developmental preferences for memory attributes were investigated through an analysis of errors on a word-recognition test for children in grades 2, 4, and 6. 20 male and 20 females participated at each grade level. It was predicted that developmental shifts would occur whereby second graders would demonstrate a preference for orthographic distractors, fourth graders would prefer acoustic distractors, and sixth graders would evidence a preference for the associative-verbal distractors. Posttest comparisons showed that only second graders demonstrated the predicted preference. There were no other significantly preferred attributes according to grade level or sex. These findings offer limited support to the developmental shift hypothesis. Children, rather than shifting from one preferred attribute of memory to another in an orderly fashion as has been suggested, may progress through alternating stages where a number of attributes are prominant in recall to periods of development where a definite preference exists.