scholarly journals Review Comments on the study of “Understanding Tropical Forest Abiotic Response to Hurricanes using Experimental Manipulations, Field Observations, and Satellite Data” by Ashley E. Van Beusekom et al.

2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
Anonymous
2021 ◽  
Vol 8 ◽  
Author(s):  
Frédéric Mélin

Uncertainty estimates are needed to assess ocean color products and qualify the agreement between missions. Comparison between field observations and satellite data, a process defined as validation, has been the traditional way to assess satellite products. However validation statistics can provide only an approximation for satellite data uncertainties as field measurements have their own uncertainties and as the validation process is imperfect, comparing data potentially differing in temporal, spatial or spectral characteristics. This study describes a method to interpret in terms of uncertainties the validation statistics obtained for ocean color remote sensing reflectance RRS knowing the uncertainties associated with field data. This approach is applied to observations collected at sites part of the Ocean Color component of the Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET-OC) located in coastal regions of the European seas, and to RRS data from the VIIRS sensors on-board the SNPP and JPSS1 platforms. Similar estimates of uncertainties σVRS (term accounting for non-systematic contributions to the uncertainty budget) are obtained for both missions, decreasing with wavelength from the interval 0.8–1.4 10−3 sr−1 in the blue to a maximum of 0.24 10−3 sr−1 in the red, values that are at least twice (but up to 8 times) the uncertainties reported for the field data. These uncertainty estimates are then used to qualify the agreement between the VIIRS products, defining the extent to which they agree within their stated uncertainty. Despite significant biases between the two missions, their RRS products appear fairly compatible.


1998 ◽  
Vol 25 (1) ◽  
pp. 37-52 ◽  
Author(s):  
PHILIPPE MAYAUX ◽  
FRÉDÉRIC ACHARD ◽  
JEAN-PAUL MALINGREAU

Definition of appropriate tropical forest policies must be supported by better information about forest distribution. New information technologies make possible the development of advanced systems which can accurately report on tropical forest area issues. The European Commission TREES (Tropical Ecosystem Environment observation by Satellite) project has produced a consistent map of the humid tropical forest cover based on 1 km resolution satellite data. This base-line reference information can be further calibrated using a sample of high-resolution data, in order to produce accurate forest area estimates. There is good general agreement with other pantropical inventories (Food & Agriculture Organization of the United Nations Forest Resources Assessment 90, World Conservation Union Conservation Atlas of Tropical Forests, National Aeronautics & Space Administration [USA] Landsat Pathfinder) using different approaches (compilation of existing data, statistical sampling, exhaustive survey with satellite data). However, for some countries, large differences appear among the assessments. Discrepancies arising from this comparison are here analysed in terms of limitations associated with each approach and they are generally associated with differences in forest definition, data source and processing methodology. According to the different inventories, the total area of closed tropical forest is estimated at 1090–1220 million hectares with the following continental distribution: 185–215 million hectares in Africa, 235–275 million hectares in Asia, and 670–730 million hectares in Latin America. A proposal for improving the current state of forest statistics by combining the contribution of the various methods under review is made.


2015 ◽  
Vol 120 (3) ◽  
pp. 637-654 ◽  
Author(s):  
Deborah Verfaillie ◽  
Vincent Favier ◽  
Marie Dumont ◽  
Vincent Jomelli ◽  
Adrien Gilbert ◽  
...  

Author(s):  
Meng Lu ◽  
Eliakim Hamunyela

In recent years, the methods for detecting structural changes in time series have been adapted for forest disturbance monitoring using satellite data. The BFAST (Breaks For Additive Season and Trend) Monitor framework, which detects forest cover disturbances from satellite image time series based on empirical fluctuation tests, is particularly used for near real-time deforestation monitoring, and it has been shown to be robust in detecting forest disturbances. Typically, a vegetation index that is transformed from spectral bands into feature space (e.g. normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI)) is used as input for BFAST Monitor. However, using a vegetation index for deforestation monitoring is a major limitation because it is difficult to separate deforestation from multiple seasonality effects, noise, and other forest disturbance. In this study, we address such limitation by exploiting the multi-spectral band of satellite data. To demonstrate our approach, we carried out a case study in a deciduous tropical forest in Bolivia, South America. We reduce the dimensionality from spectral bands, space and time with projective methods particularly the Principal Component Analysis (PCA), resulting in a new index that is more suitable for change monitoring. Our results show significantly improved temporal delay in deforestation detection. With our approach, we achieved a median temporal lag of 6 observations, which was significantly shorter than the temporal lags from conventional approaches (14 to 21 observations).


1988 ◽  
Vol 19 (4) ◽  
pp. 225-236 ◽  
Author(s):  
Henrik Søgaard ◽  
Thorkild Thomsen

Based on NOAA-AVHRR satellite data and runoff records from one of the major drainage basins in Western Greenland methods for monitoring snow cover, snowpack water equivalent and runoff have been elaborated and evaluated by use of field observations and hydrological simulation. Data from six years and more than 40 satellite scenes have been used in the analysis. A procedure for snow cover mapping in areas with alpine relief is presented, and it is shown that the snowpack water equivalent can be derived by applying either a hydrological simulation or a degree-day approach. Finally, the applicability of the results with respect to hydro-power production in Greenland is discussed.


2017 ◽  
Vol 14 (20) ◽  
pp. 4663-4690 ◽  
Author(s):  
Deborah A. Clark ◽  
Shinichi Asao ◽  
Rosie Fisher ◽  
Sasha Reed ◽  
Peter B. Reich ◽  
...  

Abstract. For more accurate projections of both the global carbon (C) cycle and the changing climate, a critical current need is to improve the representation of tropical forests in Earth system models. Tropical forests exchange more C, energy, and water with the atmosphere than any other class of land ecosystems. Further, tropical-forest C cycling is likely responding to the rapid global warming, intensifying water stress, and increasing atmospheric CO2 levels. Projections of the future C balance of the tropics vary widely among global models. A current effort of the modeling community, the ILAMB (International Land Model Benchmarking) project, is to compile robust observations that can be used to improve the accuracy and realism of the land models for all major biomes. Our goal with this paper is to identify field observations of tropical-forest ecosystem C stocks and fluxes, and of their long-term trends and climatic and CO2 sensitivities, that can serve this effort. We propose criteria for reference-level field data from this biome and present a set of documented examples from old-growth lowland tropical forests. We offer these as a starting point towards the goal of a regularly updated consensus set of benchmark field observations of C cycling in tropical forests.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document