Abstract. Increasing climatic pressures such as drought and
flooding challenge agricultural systems and their management globally. How
agricultural soils respond to soil water extremes will influence
biogeochemical cycles of carbon and nitrogen in these systems. We
investigated the response of soils from long-term agricultural field sites
under varying crop rotational complexity to either drought or flooding
stress. Focusing on these contrasting stressors separately, we investigated
soil heterotrophic respiration during single and repeated stress cycles in
soils from four different sites along a precipitation gradient (Colorado,
MAP 421 mm; South Dakota, MAP 580 mm; Michigan, MAP 893 mm; Maryland, MAP
1192 mm); each site had two crop rotational complexity treatments. At the
driest (Colorado) and wettest (Maryland) of these sites, we also analyzed
microbial biomass, six potential enzyme activities, and N2O production
during and after individual and repeated stress cycles. In general, we found
site specific responses to soil water extremes, irrespective of crop
rotational complexity and precipitation history. Drought usually caused more
severe changes in respiration rates and potential enzyme activities than
flooding. All soils returned to control levels for most measured parameters
as soon as soils returned to control water levels following drought or flood
stress, suggesting that the investigated soils were highly resilient to the
applied stresses. The lack of sustained responses following the removal of
the stressors may be because they are well in the range of natural in situ
soil water fluctuations at the investigated sites. Without the inclusion of
plants in our experiment, we found that irrespective of crop rotation
complexity, soil and microbial properties in the investigated agricultural
soils were more resistant to flooding but highly resilient to drought and
flooding during single or repeated stress pulses.