Grain Crushing, Pore Collapse and Strain Localization in Porous Sandstone

2009 ◽  
pp. 239-254 ◽  
Author(s):  
Teng-fong Wong ◽  
Patrick Baud
2020 ◽  
Vol 53 (11) ◽  
pp. 5081-5093
Author(s):  
Chao Sun ◽  
Jan V. M. Borgomano ◽  
Jérôme Fortin ◽  
ShangXu Wang

Author(s):  
Jérôme Fortin ◽  
Yves Guéguen ◽  
Alexandre Schubnel

Solid Earth ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 12 (1) ◽  
pp. 141-170
Author(s):  
Kathryn E. Elphick ◽  
Craig R. Sloss ◽  
Klaus Regenauer-Lieb ◽  
Christoph E. Schrank

Abstract. We analyse deformation bands related to horizontal contraction with an intermittent period of horizontal extension in Miocene turbidites of the Whakataki Formation south of Castlepoint, Wairarapa, North Island, New Zealand. In the Whakataki Formation, three sets of cataclastic deformation bands are identified: (1) normal-sense compactional shear bands (CSBs), (2) reverse-sense CSBs, and (3) reverse-sense shear-enhanced compaction bands (SECBs). During extension, CSBs are associated with normal faults. When propagating through clay-rich interbeds, extensional bands are characterised by clay smear and grain size reduction. During contraction, sandstone-dominated sequences host SECBs, and rare CSBs, that are generally distributed in pervasive patterns. A quantitative spacing analysis shows that most outcrops are characterised by mixed spatial distributions of deformation bands, interpreted as a consequence of overprint due to progressive deformation or distinct multiple generations of deformation bands from different deformation phases. As many deformation bands are parallel to adjacent juvenile normal faults and reverse faults, bands are likely precursors to faults. With progressive deformation, the linkage of distributed deformation bands across sedimentary beds occurs to form through-going faults. During this process, bands associated with the wall-, tip-, and interaction-damage zones overprint earlier distributions resulting in complex spatial patterns. Regularly spaced bands are pervasively distributed when far away from faults. Microstructural analysis shows that all deformation bands form by inelastic pore collapse and grain crushing with an absolute reduction in porosity relative to the host rock between 5 % and 14 %. Hence, deformation bands likely act as fluid flow barriers. Faults and their associated damage zones exhibit a spacing of 9 m on the scale of 10 km and are more commonly observed in areas characterised by higher mudstone-to-sandstone ratios. As a result, extensive clay smear is common in these faults, enhancing the sealing capacity of faults. Therefore, the formation of deformation bands and faults leads to progressive flow compartmentalisation from the scale of 9 m down to about 10 cm – the typical spacing of distributed, regularly spaced deformation bands.


Author(s):  
Neelima Kandula ◽  
Jessica McBeck ◽  
Benoît Cordonnier ◽  
Jérôme Weiss ◽  
Dag Kristian Dysthe ◽  
...  

AbstractUnderstanding the mechanisms of strain localization leading to brittle failure in reservoir rocks can shed light on geomechanical processes such as porosity and permeability evolution during rock deformation, induced seismicity, fracturing, and subsidence in geological reservoirs. We perform triaxial compression tests on three types of porous reservoir rocks to reveal the local deformation mechanisms that control system-size failure. We deformed cylindrical samples of Adamswiller sandstone (23% porosity), Bentheim sandstone (23% porosity), and Anstrude limestone (20% porosity), using an X-ray transparent triaxial deformation apparatus. This apparatus enables the acquisition of three-dimensional synchrotron X-ray images, under in situ stress conditions. Analysis of the tomograms provide 3D distributions of the microfractures and dilatant pores from which we calculated the evolving macroporosity. Digital volume correlation analysis reveals the dominant strain localization mechanisms by providing the incremental strain components of pairs of tomograms. In the three rock types, damage localized as a single shear band or by the formation of conjugate bands at failure. The porosity evolution closely matches the evolution of the incremental strain components of dilation, contraction, and shear. With increasing confinement, the dominant strain in the sandstones shifts from dilative strain (Bentheim sandstone) to contractive strain (Adamswiller sandstone). Our study also links the formation of compactive shear bands with porosity variations in Anstrude limestone, which is characterized by a complex pore geometry. Scanning electron microscopy images indicate that the microscale mechanisms guiding strain localization are pore collapse and grain crushing in sandstones, and pore collapse, pore-emanated fractures and cataclasis in limestones. Our dynamic X-ray microtomography data brings unique insights on the correlation between the evolutions of rock microstructure, porosity evolution, and macroscopic strain during the approach to brittle failure in reservoir rocks.


2013 ◽  
Vol 49 ◽  
pp. 50-63 ◽  
Author(s):  
Roger Soliva ◽  
Richard A. Schultz ◽  
Gregory Ballas ◽  
Alfredo Taboada ◽  
Christopher Wibberley ◽  
...  

Author(s):  
Thomas A. Dewers ◽  
Kathleen A. Issen ◽  
David J. Holcomb ◽  
William A. Olsson ◽  
Mathew D. Ingraham

1992 ◽  
Vol 45 (8) ◽  
pp. 281-293 ◽  
Author(s):  
Teng-fong Wong ◽  
Hiram Szeto ◽  
Jiaxiang Zhang

Grain crushing and pore collapse are the dominant compaction mechanisms in high porosity clastic rocks. These micromechanical processes control the evolution of strain hardening during cataclastic flow, and they can also result in embrittlement of the rock. The mechanics of the transition from brittle fracture to homogeneous cataclastic flow for the Berea and Kayenta sandstones were investigated in the laboratory. The mechanical data show that the transition is sensitively dependent on the stress state as well as the porosity. In the stress space, the complete locus for brittle failure by shear localization can be determined by tests on normally consolidated and overconsolidated samples along different loading paths. Using porosity as the hardening parameter, the evolution of the inelastic yield locus with strain hardening can be mapped out in the stress space. This yield locus expands with decreasing porosity. Scanning electron microscope and acoustic emission measurements were used to elucidate the micromechanics. The onset of grain crushing and pore collapse was marked by a surge in acoustic emission activity. A Hertzian fracture mechanics model was formulated to analyze the roles of porosity, grain size and fracture toughness in controlling the onset of hydrostatic and shear-enhanced compaction. Stereological measurements of the microcrack density show that significant stress-induced anisotropy was induced by shear-enhanced compaction, with preferred orientations of the stress-induced microcracks subparallel to the maximum compression direction.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kathryn E. Elphick ◽  
Craig R. Sloss ◽  
Klaus Regenauer-Lieb ◽  
Christoph E. Schrank

Abstract. We analyse deformation bands related to both horizontal contraction and horizontal extension in Miocene turbidites of the Whakataki Formation south of Castlepoint, Wairarapa, North Island, New Zealand. In the Whakataki Formation, four sets of cataclastic deformation bands are identified: (1) normal-sense Compactional Shear Bands (CSBs); (2) normal-sense Shear-Enhanced Compaction Bands (SECBs); (3) reverse-sense CSBs; and (4) reverse-sense SECBs. During extension, CSBs form most frequently with rare SECBs. Extensional CSBs are often, but not exclusively, associated with normal faults. During contraction, distributed SECBs are observed most commonly, sometimes clustering around small reverse faults and thrusts. Contractional CSBs are primarily found in the damage zones of reverse faults. The quantitative spacing analysis shows that most outcrops are characterised by mixed spatial distributions of deformation bands, interpreted as a consequence of overprint due to progressive deformation or distinct multiple generations of deformation bands from different deformation phases. Since many deformation bands are parallel to adjacent juvenile normal- and reverse-faults, bands are likely precursors to faults. With progressive deformation, the linkage of distributed deformation bands across sedimentary beds occurs to form through-going faults. During this process, bands associated with the wall-, tip-, and interaction damage zones overprint earlier distributions resulting in complex spatial patterns. Regularly spaced bands are pervasively distributed when far away from faults. Microstructural analysis shows that all deformation bands form by inelastic pore collapse and grain crushing with an absolute reduction in porosity relative to the host rock between 5 and 14 %. Hence, deformation bands likely act as fluid flow barriers. Faults and their associated damage zones exhibit a spacing of order ten metres on the scale of 10 km and are more commonly observed in areas characterised by higher mudstone to sandstone ratios. As a result, extensive clay smear is common in these faults, enhancing the sealing capacity of faults. Therefore, the formation of deformation bands and faults leads to progressive flow compartmentalisation from the scale of ten metres down to about ten centimetres, the typical spacing of distributed deformation bands.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Elliot Rice-Birchall ◽  
Daniel Faulkner ◽  
John Bedford

<p>As sandstone reservoirs are depleted, the pore pressure reduction can sometimes result in pore collapse and the formation of compaction bands. These are localised features which can significantly reduce the bulk permeability of the reservoir and are therefore problematic in the oil, water, geothermal, and CO<sub>2</sub> sequestration industries. However, the influence that grain size, grain shape and sorting have on compaction band formation in sandstone is still poorly understood, due to the fact that finding natural sandstones with specific properties is challenging. Consequently, a method of forming synthetic sandstones has been developed, in order to produce a suite of sandstone specimens with controlled grain size and porosity characteristics. During production of the synthetic sandstones, amorphous quartz cement and sodium chloride are precipitated between sand grains as a product of the reaction between sodium silicate and hydrochloric acid. The salt can then be dissolved, resulting in synthetic sandstones that have very comparable physical properties to their natural counterparts. In this study, triaxial experiments were performed on synthetic sandstone cores with four different grain size ranges of 250-300, 425-500, 600-710 and 850-1000 microns, at three different starting porosities of 27%, 32% and 37%. The samples were each axially loaded from a point along their hydrostat corresponding to 85% of their hydrostatic yield point, P*, values. These conditions mean that failure will occur within the shear-enhanced compaction regime so as to try and produce localised compaction structures. All samples were taken to 5% axial strain. The microstructural results indicate that localisation of deformation within the samples did occur and was favoured in the low starting porosity, small grain size samples. Localisation of deformation was most easily recognised by grain size reduction through grain crushing. This was weakly correlated to a change in porosity but recognition of the localisation of deformation was difficult to make using variations in porosity alone. Porosity reduction was not necessarily associated with a reduction in grain size. With increasing grain size and starting porosity, the deformation becomes more distributed in the samples with the highest starting porosity samples (37%) exhibiting more widely distributed grain crushing which was less intense overall. The results indicate a significant grain size and starting porosity influence on localisation, but also that compaction can occur by two mechanisms; one involving mostly grain rearrangement and the other primarily by grain fracturing. Consequently, the localisation of deformation is most evident in grain size reduction and is only weakly shown by porosity reduction.</p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document